Devoted KU basketball fans stand by their team; psychologists not at all surprised

photo by: Nick Krug

Kansas fans in the northern student section sing the Alma Mater before tipoff against Alcorn State during the first half, Wednesday, Dec. 2, 2009 at Allen Fieldhouse.

At Ladybird Diner in downtown Lawrence, Susan McCarthy was perusing the newspaper Thursday morning, trying to keep up with the latest news on the college basketball corruption trial underway in New York.

A devout KU basketball fan, McCarthy has had season tickets for decades. But at the moment, she is practicing tough love with her team, which has been in the news for several weeks during the federal trial for former Adidas representatives implicated in a college recruiting scandal.

“I hate to see it happen. I was hoping our program was as clean as it looks. But, I have my doubts. I love this team and I will love it no matter what. I feel so sad to be involved in this mess. It hurts.”

However, she firmly believes KU is not a victim. “It’s more they got caught. I think other teams are doing the same thing, and the Adidas thing backfired. I hate the money aspect.”

KU basketball fans are working at coping with their emotions right now because their identity as fans is threatened, said Dan Wann, a professor of psychology at Murray State University in Western Kentucky. Wann was the guest lecturer at KU on Wednesday evening, as part of the third annual Mawson Scholar Speaker Series. His book “Sports Fans: The Psychology and Social Impact of Spectators,” was just released.

“One thing KU fans are doing right now is being biased in their attribution and blaming a source not team-related,” Wann said.”They will try to externalize the blame and try to find a scapegoat.”

They will tell themselves, “We are not as bad as so-and-so; maybe we broke a few rules, but not the big rules,” Wann said.

Now that the trial has forced national attention on big-name shoe companies such as Adidas paying a player’s family to send their athlete to a certain university, McCarthy hopes all teams will deal with the issue.

“I hope it’s not pushed under the rug but the NCAA confronts it,” she said.

Around town, other KU basketball fans were searching for scapegoats. At Jock’s Nitch Sporting Goods, 837 Massachusetts St., where you can turn in any direction and spot a Jayhawk, Conner Riley was hanging some new KU apparel. The KU junior says he’s a basketball fan and accepts the way players are recruited.

“I’m under the assumption that everyone has done shady work,” Riley said. “College sports are that way.”

What’s important to him is that the players are treated right.

“When they go on to the NBA, I hope they’ll reflect positively on their time here,” Riley said.

Stepping into Rex Porter’s Stadium Barber Shop, 1033 Massachusetts St., is like walking into a shrine for KU athletics. Customers sit in crimson and blue chairs, jerseys from various sports cover the walls and ceiling, and athletes stop by for haircuts.

Porter, wearing an Adidas windbreaker, said he believes all college basketball teams are victims in the basketball corruption trial.

“We are in this world of shoe companies offering so much money to the kids,” Porter said.

However, regarding suggestive text messages between Self and Adidas consultant T.J. Gassnola (who has pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud), Porter said, “You can read anything into those conversations.”

Porter quoted television’s Judge Judy: “I don’t want to know hearsay; I want to know the truth.”

Across town, Andy Vigna, owner of Stoneback Appliance, 925 Iowa St., also wasn’t interested in rumors.

“Our coaching staff hasn’t done anything wrong. It’s just hearsay. I have complete faith in our basketball program, and I’m proud to be part of the Jayhawk family,” Vigna said.

Omri Gillath, professor of psychology at the University of Kansas, is a devout KU sports fan. Plus, he understands the psychology of being part of the in-group. The in-group is not just sports teams; it can involve being part of a race or political party.

While people want their sports to be clean and pure, at the same time they will justify their team’s behavior, Gillath said.

“If Bill Self is accused of being corrupt, this is our in-group and we are all being called corrupt,” Gillath said. “We are basically enjoying when they win and suffering when they lose or there is an attack on them. That is an attack on us.”

He said “basking in reflective glory” is when your team is winning and you feel everything is great. However, on the negative side, when your team is under attack, you experience it as a threat to your sense of self.

Martin Watson, a devoted KU fan, is the owner of Watson’s Barber Shop, 925 Iowa St., where many of the basketball players come for haircuts. Sometimes Watson and his staff will go up to campus to offer cuts to the team.

“No matter what the outcome,” Watson said, with assurance, “KU basketball will survive.”

Tim “Nellie” Nelson, another barber at the shop, asked, “Is there any clean college programs? If you ain’t cheating, you ain’t trying, except for in marriage.”

Lawrence and KU basketball are synonymous for Charles Cornwell, who works in maintenance on the KU campus. He grew up in Lawrence and remembers his dad taking him to Hoch Auditorium to watch games. He watched such basketball legends as Clyde Lovellette and Wilt Chamberlain play.

The current events don’t come as a surprise to him.

“Losing coaches get fired and winning coaches are rehired,” Cornwell said. “To win, you have to have the best players. This has been going on forever. I don’t know how you can stop it.”

Coverage: College basketball corruption trial

Oct. 2 — As college basketball corruption trial opens, attorney admits client paid $20K to get De Sousa to come to KU

Oct. 3 — Witness details secret payments in college hoops recruiting

Oct. 4 — Father testifies on pay for play at college hoops programs

Oct. 9 — Basketball player’s father: Louisville assistant gave cash

Oct. 10 — Self declines to comment on testimony of former Adidas consultant; questions surface about KU compliance

Oct. 11 — Latest testimony in college basketball corruption trial goes into further details on KU’s involvement

Oct. 15 — ‘We good?’ ‘Always’: Texts between Self, fixer presented in college basketball corruption trial

Oct. 16 — ‘If that’s what it takes’: KU assistant coach taped by feds discussing recruit’s demand for cash

Oct. 18 — Defense attorney argues Bill Self knew about payments to families of KU players

More coverage: KU and the college basketball scandal

Oct. 18, 2018 — Chancellor won’t say whether he still has ‘complete confidence’ that KU follows recruiting rules

Oct. 17, 2018 — As college basketball corruption trial comes to a close, KU could be facing several NCAA code violations

Oct. 12, 2018 — As allegations mount, KU mum about Adidas ties and extra $1.5M it has received from the company

Oct. 3, 2018 — KU’s De Sousa could be ruled ineligible, NCAA rules experts say; chances of vacating Final Four appearance less clear

Oct. 1, 2018 — Girod, other KU leaders listed as potential witnesses in college basketball corruption trial

July 24, 2018 — KU releases federal subpoenas in college basketball investigation

July 11, 2018 — KU coach Bill Self, new AD Jeff Long discussed ongoing FBI investigation during interview process

July 10, 2018 — KU acknowledges having received federal subpoena in ongoing FBI investigation into college basketball

July 6, 2018 — Report: Feds seeking more information regarding KU forward Silvio De Sousa

April 27, 2018 — Reports: AAU director linked to NCAA bribery case, KU families pleads guilty

April 23, 2018 — KU didn’t produce written report of recent examination of athletic department; chancellor saw no need for external report

April 13, 2018 — Former prosecutor: KU not in clear yet, but one past case provides hope

April 13, 2018 — Chancellor sees no need for independent investigation of KU Athletics in wake of indictment

April 10, 2018 — Employee of apparel company illegally paid 2 KU basketball players’ guardians, federal indictment alleges

Feb. 23, 2018 — Kansas linked to college basketball scandal in Yahoo Sports report

Nov. 28, 2017 — Multimillion-dollar KU-Adidas deal remains unsigned as investigation into Adidas executive continues

Oct. 20, 2017 — KU provides more details of NCAA-mandated basketball review, enlists law firm to help

Oct. 17, 2017 — Analysis: Understanding the legal case building against the college basketball world

Oct. 16, 2017 — Zenger: KU will comply with NCAA requirement of all schools to review basketball program

Sept. 26, 2017 — NCAA basketball coaches, Adidas executive among 10 charged in bribe scheme


Welcome to the new Our old commenting system has been replaced with Facebook Comments. There is no longer a separate username and password login step. If you are already signed into Facebook within your browser, you will be able to comment. If you do not have a Facebook account and do not wish to create one, you will not be able to comment on stories.