One size does not fit all for garden tool users

People ask: What essential garden tools do you recommend?

The short answer is hand pruners for trimming, a hoe for weeding and a shovel for moving plants about. A well-tuned garden demands these tasks frequently, so choose your weapons carefully. They should be comfortable, balanced and sharp.

I dislike a shovel whose blade is too big, making it bottom heavy, or too curved, causing it to twist as you work the soil. I hate tools that bend at the first sight of Virginia clay. I don’t like hoes that are angled badly and are difficult to sharpen.

As a fellow who is relatively tall (a hair over 6 feet), I find handles of most shovels and rakes entirely too short, but I live with that just as I do with sinks and ATM keyboards set too low. I sometimes wonder, however, how difficult and unpleasant it must be for a woman to wrestle with poorly designed industrial-strength garden tools. Others wonder too.

“Most are designed for the average man, and women have been left out of the equation altogether,” said Dorian Winslow, owner of a company called Womanswork. “Women don’t have the same upper body strength as men. Products designed for women require less brute force,” she said. “And the other thing is height; you just get better leverage if a product is designed for your height.”

Her company, based in Sharon, Conn., sells garden gloves, principally. Gloves too are essential tools. They prevent blisters and allow you to work longer. Winslow said she started the small company in 1985 after she realized that garden gloves made for women were just smaller version of men’s gloves. Yet a woman’s hand, she says, is not only smaller but proportionately longer.

Triumph over machismo

Other companies also are recognizing that one size does not fit all, spurred, no doubt, by market research showing that the majority of gardeners in America are female; that more and more households are headed by women; and that a vast cohort of middle-aged folks is getting, duh, older.

Ames True Temper, based in Camp Hill, Pa., is the world’s largest manufacturer of non-powered lawn and garden tools. This spring, it introduced a line of “friendlier” implements designed specifically for women and seniors. The Earth Tools — two rakes, a hoe, a cultivator and a shovel — are smaller and lighter than traditional models. Not surprisingly, the products are also finding favor with able-bodied men, some of whom, it turns out, have a physique closer to Woody Allen’s than Hulk Hogan’s.

I always reach for the smaller shovel over the larger one for hours-long digging tasks — small and steady seems to triumph over displays of machismo.

Universal design

OXO, a company that made its name with ergonomically sound kitchen gadgets, has now ventured into the garden with a line of short-handled tools with three subtly different handle designs. The first, used in tools that are pushed, contains a gel that flexes to absorb pressure and reduce the hand stress of digging. The second design, for tools that are struck and pulled, such as a cultivator, permit you to choke up on the handle for added strength or use both hands for maximum effort. The third type is used on garden scissors, loppers and pruners with various handles designed to absorb pressure from squeezed hands.

All are shaped by a philosophy of universal design, the company says, in which handles are painstakingly created to accommodate as many different users as possible, including women, southpaws and the frail.

One of the largest European garden tool makers, WOLF Garten, of Betzdorf, Germany, has ventured in the American market in 2000 with a trademark series of tools whose implements are interchangeable with a variety of wooden and fiberglass handles. Called Interlocken, they snap on and off like seatbelts. This not only allows you to carry your day’s tools and a handle in a bucket to the garden (avoiding repeated trips to the shed for fresh tools), but it also is useful to match handle height to the size of the gardener. The tools snap on to a short handle for kneeling work, but also to 10 different wooden or aluminum handles in four lengths, from 39 inches to 59 inches, plus two telescoping handles for tree care called Vario, which extend from 5 1/2 to 10 feet or seven to 13 feet. Rejoice, tall fellows.

I have taken to this brand for another reason: There are at least a dozen different hoe designs alone, angled nicely and with razor sharp, removable blades. Once they dull, off they come to the rasp or grinder. You get the sense that these were designed by people who actually garden and not taken from a pattern book for outdated and primitive homesteader gear.

This is not to say that you cannot find traditionally crafted tools that are a treat to use as well as own.