Kansas Court of Appeals overturns Eudora woman’s murder conviction in baby’s death, orders new trial
photo by: Sara Shepherd
A Eudora woman’s 2018 murder conviction in the death of a 9-month-old boy was overturned on Friday by the Kansas Court of Appeals and sent back to the Douglas County District Court for a new trial.
The court ruled Carrody Buchhorn, now 47, received ineffective counsel during her 2018 trial, which denied her the right to a fair trial. The court said her attorneys failed to properly question a coroner’s ruling on how the boy died, among other issues.
However, the Douglas County District Attorney’s Office told the Journal-World it plans to appeal the ruling to the Kansas Supreme Court.
A jury previously found Buchhorn guilty of second-degree murder after 9-month-old Oliver “Ollie” Ortiz was found unresponsive at a Eudora day care. She was convicted of his murder and was sentenced to more than 10 years in prison.
“It is not an easy decision to grant a new trial to someone who has been convicted of killing another human being,” the court wrote in its opinion on Buchhorn’s appeal. “But more important than the severity of the crime is the fundamental principle of American law — all accused must receive a fair trial, even those accused of killing a child. That legal principle has guided our decision to order a new trial for Carrody M. Buchhorn.”
photo by: Contributed
The court said Friday that Buchhorn was convicted after a coroner, Dr. Erik Mitchell, ruled the boy’s death was instantaneous and caused by a blow to the head. As the Journal-World previously reported, the coroner testified that Oliver had a fractured skull caused by an incident forceful enough — not a drop, fall or the actions of another child — to render him unresponsive right away and, without intervention, dead within minutes.
The court specifically said Buchhorn’s attorneys failed to properly investigate the coroner’s ruling and noted that the case hinged on that because there was no direct evidence connecting Buchhorn to the boy’s death.
“Buchhorn’s counsel failed to make a comprehensive investigation of Dr. Mitchell’s medical opinions, thus failing to equip Buchhorn with what she needed for a proper defense,” the court said in its opinion. “It was not a reasonable strategy that led counsel to decline to investigate Dr. Mitchell’s theory, but, rather, lack of thoroughness and preparation.”
Related coverage
• NOv. 18, 2019 — Woman convicted of killing Eudora baby sentenced to 10-plus years; parents tell court about devastation of losing child
• Oct. 24, 2019 — Judge denies new trial for Eudora day care worker convicted in infant’s murder
• March 14, 2019 — Under scrutiny, coroner stands by ruling on Eudora baby’s death that led to caregiver’s murder conviction
• Feb. 19, 2019 — Defense lawyers stand by trial performance in Eudora day care murder case, say client was wrongly convicted
• Feb. 7, 2019 — Trial lawyer, former AG calls ineffective counsel claim ‘laughable’ at hearing for Eudora woman convicted of murdering baby
• Dec. 21, 2018 — Medical experts skewer coroner’s ruling in baby’s death as convicted woman seeks new trial
• Dec. 19, 2018 — Prosecutors offer rebuttal to attacks on coroner, defense team by woman convicted of murdering baby
• Sept. 16, 2018 — Calling coroner’s ruling ‘junk science,’ lawyers seek new trial for Eudora woman convicted of murdering baby
• Aug. 31, 2018 — Eudora woman convicted of baby’s murder seeking new trial; sentencing delayed
• July 26, 2018 — Woman guilty of 2nd degree murder in baby’s death at Eudora home day care
• July 25, 2018 — Jury deliberations still underway in Eudora day care murder trial
• July 24, 2018 — Jury deliberating case of day care worker charged with murdering baby
• July 23, 2018 — Defense expert in murder trial says baby’s injury could have occurred much earlier; jury sees video of autopsy
• July 20, 2018 — Autopsy photos show internal injuries of baby allegedly murdered by Eudora day care worker
• July 19, 2018 — Day care owner testifies at murder trial that she did not hurt infant; defendant’s police interview played for jury
• July 18, 2018 — Eudora first responders detail attempts to revive baby
• July 17, 2018 — Parents testify about their 9-month-old son’s death at Eudora day care
• July 16, 2018 — Trial underway for woman accused of murdering baby at Eudora day care
• May 25, 2018 — Murder trial approaching for Eudora day care worker charged with killing baby; wrongful death suit settled
• April 19, 2018 — Eudora baby’s parents sue operators of home day care where he died
• Jan. 26, 2018 — Murder trial pushed back 5 months for woman accused of killing baby at Eudora day care
• Dec. 14, 2017 — Buttons picturing Eudora baby won’t be allowed at trial of woman accused of murdering him
• Sept. 21, 2017 — Eudora day care worker must stand trial for murder in infant’s death, judge rules
• June 21, 2017 — Judge denies request to modify house arrest condition for woman charged with murdering infant
• April 27, 2017 — Affidavit: Woman accused of killing infant at Eudora day care was only person with access to the child
• April 17, 2017 — Woman accused of infant’s death at a Eudora day care formally charged with first-degree murder
• April 14, 2017 — District attorney files murder charge against woman accused of killing infant at a Eudora day care
• March 21, 2017 — Investigation into death of infant at Eudora daycare nearing completion
• Oct. 24, 2016 — Infant dies at Eudora day care, police say; facility’s license under emergency suspension
COMMENTS