Five Kansas cities and a water district are part of a class action lawsuit filed against the largest manufacturer of the herbicide atrazine.
The federal lawsuit, which was filed this week in a U.S. District Court in southern Illinois, asks that atrazine-maker Syngenta pay for the cost of removing the chemical from the public’s drinking water.
Miami County Rural Water District No. 2 and the cities of Carbondale, Dodge City, Marion, Oswego and Plains are among the 16 communities in six states that are part of the lawsuit.
The most widely used herbicide in the United States, atrazine is spread on corn and sorghum fields every spring.
That chemical is washed into surface water and eventually finds its way into much of the country’s drinking water.
Atrazine is banned in the European Union.
The lawsuit claims that exposure to atrazine has been linked to birth defects, low birthweights and premature births. Other studies have shown that it is a possible human carcinogen and an endocrine disrupter, the lawsuit claims.
In a released statement, Syngenta called it “another frivolous atrazine lawsuit” that “only harms U.S. farmers.”
The company noted that since 2005 no water system in the country has been over the allowable limit for atrazine set by the Environmental Protection Agency, which has a 1,000-fold safety standard.
Jere White, executive director of the Kansas Corn Growers Association and the Kansas Grain Sorghum Producers Association, said he was surprised by the number of Kansas communities involved in the lawsuit.
That’s because two of the cities, Dodge City and Plains, pull their water source from aquifers, not surface water, and he has heard little public discussion about the lawsuits.
“We would maintain it is more about water systems being promised they could get money without any investment on their part,” White said.
Last fall, the Natural Resource Defense Council released a report that claimed the EPA wasn’t collecting data that took into account spikes in atrazine levels occurring during spring runoffs.
Following that report, the Lawrence Journal-World reported that one-time readings from public water systems in Kansas exceeded the annual average limit set by the EPA more than 300 times in five years. Some water systems had levels that were 15 times higher than the annual average limit.
The Miami County Rural Water District has added carbon to its water treatment process in large part because of atrazine levels, the water district’s attorney, Carl Hartley, said.
“I think it is a common-sense approach,” Hartley said. “If you are required to provide clean, safe water and an element is introduced in the environment that requires the process to be more expensive than it would be, your patrons carry that expense.”
Comments
LJWorld.com doesn’t necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post. Read our full policy. Also, read about banned accounts and harassing comments.
sbell10 (anonymous) says…
this should be front page news. Terrifying.
true_patriot (anonymous) says…
It's ashame this had to be dealt with tediously and over years or decades in the legal system rather than up front with better regulation and enforcement.
dudedog12 (anonymous) says…
calm down , you are upset because you don't know anything about what they are talking about, don't take it at face value.
Centerville (anonymous) says…
.It's just a sleazy money grab, read the story.
just_another_bozo_on_this_bus (anonymous) says…
"Atrazine is banned in the European Union."
As it should be here.
GTFB (anonymous) says…
To say that atrazine is banned in Europe, without additional clarification, is a deliberate distortion of the facts, i.e., a lie. Atrazine is not “banned” in Europe. It is subject to a blanket restriction on the use of any pesticide that has been detected in groundwater at above 0.1 parts per billion. Indeed, European regulatory reviews of atrazine health and safety data have concluded that atrazine is safe to humans and the environment. Furthermore, atrazine has been replaced in Europe by an almost identical herbicide, terbuthylazine, also produced by Syngenta. The toxicological and ecological profile of terbuthylazine is similar to that of atrazine.
GTFB (anonymous) says…
Why don't we just move back into a cave somewhere? This lawsuit doesn't have a thing to do with safe water or recovering expenses. It is about skank trial attorneys trying to make soemething from nothing. These systems are fools for getting sucked into it. Why would anyone want our community to join this nonsense.
GTFB (anonymous) says…
As far as Marci goes, because she has been involved in observing real world agricultural issues, she probably would see this scam for what it is.