Archive for Tuesday, November 7, 2006

Clinics seek to thwart inquiry

Kansas Supreme Court asked to stop Kline’s investigation

November 7, 2006


— Leaders at two health care clinics Monday asked the Kansas Supreme Court to stop Atty. Gen. Phill Kline's investigation into abortion records, seal the patients' information and launch a probe into an alleged leak from the records.

The clinics said their legal effort was prompted by statements Friday by Kline, an ardent opponent of abortion, and Fox News' Bill O'Reilly.

"We've fought the attorney general's attempts to invade the privacy of medical records, in part because we feared that, once invaded, they would be misused in pursuit of the attorney general's right-wing agenda," said Peter Brownlie, chief executive officer of Planned Parenthood of Kansas and Mid-Missouri. "It appears, unfortunately, that fear has been justified."

Kline denied any wrongdoing, calling the clinics' legal filing frivolous.

"The women are not under any investigation, and their privacy is not in jeopardy," Kline said. "These records have not been provided in any fashion to any other party by this office."

The move comes on the eve of a bitter election fight between Kline and Democratic challenger Paul Morrison, who has accused Kline of abusing his authority and invading patients' privacy.

The O'Reilly Factor

Fox News' Bill O'Reilly discusses the late-term abortion by a Kansas doctor and its influence on the state's attorney general race. Enlarge video

The Kansas Supreme Court took no immediate action in the latest go-round. Kline and state District Court Judge Richard Anderson, whose court has overseen the records' inquisition, have five days to respond to the clinics' motion.

The filings represent another battle in a two-year-long war between Kline and clinics operated by Planned Parenthood in Overland Park and by Dr. George Tiller, a late-term abortion specialist in Wichita.

Kline sought through a lower court the records of 90 women and girls from the clinics, alleging possible sexual crimes against minors and illegal late-term abortions.

The Kansas Supreme Court allowed the subpoena of records provided that the identities of the patients was redacted. Because of concerns about the privacy of patients, the court also admonished all parties to "resist the impulse to further publicize their respective legal positions."

Kline received the records Oct. 24.

On Friday, he appeared on "The O'Reilly Factor" television show to talk about the case.

Reader poll
Will you vote today?

or See the results without voting


During the show, O'Reilly said he had information that the records showed many of the late-term abortions, which he called "executing babies," were granted for depression. On the show and numerous times before, Kline has stated publicly the allegations of his investigation.

In their petition filed Monday, the clinics said the court needed to take control of the investigation "given the obvious and apparent cavalier attitude to the public dissemination of the contents of the record by respondent Kline and the public allegation by O'Reilly that he has an inside source with respect to the records' contents."

The clinics noted that each medical record, even after the identity of the patient is removed, contains detailed personal history.

Kline said he has no idea where O'Reilly allegedly got his information. O'Reilly has declined to speak to reporters about the matter.

Kline also said that Tiller was trying to thwart the investigation, and that the clinics' motion has no basis in law.

But the clinics argued that a special prosecutor needs to take over the case because Kline is so prejudiced against Tiller, even noting in a campaign memo of the need to use churches to raise funds "to match Tiller's blood money."

The clinics added: "Kline has shown that he is unwilling or unable to separate his duties as a licensed attorney and a public official, entrusted with enormous power, from his desire for personal political gain."

In the last few days of the campaign, Kline has repeatedly told crowds they appeared to be in good health and added, "Of course, I already knew that. I've got all of your medical records."

In their court filing, the clinics described Kline's line as an "offensive joke."


crohan1978 11 years, 4 months ago

If Tiller is breaking the law, it is the Attorney General's job to enforce the law. Don't give me this "political gain" crap. He is fulfilling his elected duty. If the state says late term abortions are illegal, and Tiller is allegedly performing them, Kline should investigate. Anyone who supports late-term abortion is sick. Of course, I believe there are special circumstances where it can be used.

If sexual crimes are being committed against minors, and Tiller is not reporting those crimes, he should be punished for that as well.

opinion 11 years, 4 months ago


"[Key there is "intelligent American viewers"; for the average NeoCon extremist wingnut that makes up @ 85% of Faux New's audience, O'Reilly can lie all he wants and they'll go down on both knees before him.]"

Why would you feel the need to throw this into your statement? You appear bright and have often demonstrated that you have thought out your positions fully. I am sure your ideas can stand on their own merit without resorting to name calling.

SettingTheRecordStraight 11 years, 4 months ago

The records are in the Attorney General's hands because a judge believes there's reason to believe a crime has been committed.

SettingTheRecordStraight 11 years, 4 months ago

If my medical files helped convict a rapist or an abortionist, I would want law enforcement to have those files and use them to bring law breakers to justice.

Agnostick, You and I have no idea A) If Bill O'Reilly is telling the truth, or B) Where O'Reilly got the supposed abortion records.

SettingTheRecordStraight 11 years, 4 months ago

How does Peter Brownlie sleep at night? When he lays down he must be absolutely tortured by the horrible thought, "I'm the CEO of Planned Parenthood of Kansas and Mid-Missouri!"

opinion 11 years, 4 months ago


Re-read what I wrote. I do believe Agnostick is bright and do believe he thinks his positions out fully (at least more often than not). Agnostick is one that I often disagree with but will always read their posts. Sometimes I learn something. I just hate to see civility fly out the window time and time again. I guess that's "my problem".

Bob Forer 11 years, 4 months ago

Too bad Kline's term will expire before the people of Kansas have a opportunity to impeach him.

Baille 11 years, 4 months ago

"The records are in the Attorney General's hands because a judge believes there's reason to believe a crime has been committed."

OK. So why are they in O'Reilly's hands?

BTW, a couple of my favorite O'Reilly quotes:

Guy like that should be writing children's books.

What? He has? Sweet!

opinion 11 years, 4 months ago


Just make sure you bring ME back in line, gently, WHEN I let my frustration get the best of me!

Commenting has been disabled for this item.