Archive for Tuesday, March 31, 2009

Obama tests diplomatic waters in Iran

March 31, 2009


If you want to know how President Obama is changing America’s foreign-policy strategy, watch the short video in which he wishes Iran’s people and leaders a happy Nowruz.

Nowruz is the Persian new year, an ancient holiday celebrated on the first day of spring. The president’s greeting (www., broadcast last Friday, shows how he intends to fulfill his pledge to reach out to Iran.

Obama’s Nowruz message was striking for what it included — and what it omitted. His words were sharply different in tone from messages sent by President George W. Bush, who considered Iran’s regime part of the “axis of evil.” Unlike Bush, Obama addressed Iran’s leaders as well as the Iranian people, making it clear that he is not seeking regime change.

The president said clearly that “the United States wants the Islamic Republic of Iran to take its rightful place in the community of nations.” But he added that such a place “cannot be reached through terror or arms.”

At the same time, by sending his message on a traditional holiday not linked to religion, Obama showed his respect for the Persian nation. He praised Iran’s “great civilization.” And, to counter those who say past differences between our two countries can’t be overcome, he quoted the words of the Persian medieval poet Saadi: “The children of Adam are limbs to each other, having been created of one essence.”

Iran expert Karim Sadjadpour, of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, was visiting Dubai when Obama delivered his message. He said the large Iranian community there had an “overwhelmingly positive” reaction to Obama’s recognition of Iran’s new year and its rich culture.

Perhaps most important, Obama never mentioned Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, whose call for Israel to be “wiped off the map” has convinced many Americans of the impossibility of dialogue with Tehran. Some Iran experts have criticized Obama for not responding to a letter the Iranian president sent him after he won election. However, Obama’s new-year message was a better idea than a quick response to the mercurial Ahmadinejad.

That’s because Obama’s message was directed at Iran’s leaders — plural. He made clear that he recognizes that Ahmadinejad is not the key figure in Iran’s power structure; the supreme clerical leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, holds that position. Some reports indicate Obama may follow up with a private message directly to the supreme leader.

Press reports noted Khamenei’s cool reaction to the extended hand of Obama. The cleric insisted the United States would have to make “real changes” in foreign policy before relations could improve.

Many experts argue that Khamenei considers anti-Americanism to be an immutable tenet of the regime’s ideology. Obama’s new-year message, and his new policy, will put that thesis to the test.

Sadjadpour contends that the Nowruz video will provoke an internal Iranian political debate over whether Iran should take up Obama’s offer of honest engagement “grounded in mutual respect.” With Iranian elections coming up in June, the new U.S. approach will put the burden on hard-liners to justify continued enmity toward America at a time when Iran’s economy is in deep trouble.

“We may see Obama’s approach accentuate deep internal Iranian divisions,” Sadjadpour said, “between those who want to continue hostility for domestic reasons and those who recognize that the ‘death to America’ culture of 1979 is unproductive in 2009.” He thinks Obama’s offer will likely increase public pressure for Iran’s leaders to come down on the 2009 end of that debate.

Of course, there’s no guarantee Khamenei will be responsive. It won’t be easy to improve the United States’ toxic relationship with Iran’s Islamic republic or agree on a formula to deal with Tehran’s suspect nuclear program. It’s not clear whether Iran will even be willing to cooperate with Obama on areas of mutual security interest, such as stability in Iraq and Afghanistan.

And spoilers within Iran’s government will try to impede warmer relations by continuing to arrest Iranian-Americans. The latest victim is 31-year-old Roxana Saberi, a freelance journalist from North Dakota who was working in Tehran before being thrown in Evin prison nearly two months ago. Her father says she is depressed and suicidal.

Yet Obama is right to throw down a challenge to Iranian leaders and test the possibility of better relations. If they choose not to respond, the onus will be on them.

— Trudy Rubin is a columnist and editorial-board member for the Philadelphia Inquirer.


Harpo 8 years, 10 months ago

Good column. Smart move by the Obama administration. "Test the waters", of Iranian leadership while also appealing to Iranian public opinion. This softens the rhetoric without compromising the policy.

jaywalker 8 years, 10 months ago

"Of course, there’s no guarantee Khamenei will be responsive"

Oh yes there is. And odds are it'll be just as negative and derogatory as the last time. Khameini wants us to renounce all ties with Israel. Not gonna happen. And they believe they're in the position of strength, probably due to Russia's backing. I like the tack. But if it works it's gonna take a while.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.