Archive for Wednesday, October 3, 2007
Illegal immigrants complicate health care plans
October 3, 2007
Advertisement
Most presidential candidates are proposing some kind of health care overhaul, but when Congress failed to pass immigration reform this year it might have created a major roadblock to lawmakers' ability to offer medical insurance to all.
So far, none of those proposing fixes to the health care system have said how they would treat illegal immigrants, understanding the furor the issue would cause on the campaign trail.
Yet, how any health care reform would treat illegal immigrants is almost certainly going to be a sticking point that would not have been the case had Congress already dealt with the overall immigration question.
Depending on who wins the Republican nomination, the issue could become a real dispute, because the general approach the major Democratic candidates have taken to such issues suggests they might favor including illegal immigrants in a health care overhaul.
Any such plan will face obstacles on Capitol Hill in 2009, no matter who wins the presidency. Even if the Democrats keep Congress and win the White House, agreement could be elusive. A divided government would make things even tougher.
There will be disagreements over the size of the government's role in health care, the changes it will require from insurance companies and individuals and, most of all, the cost and scope of coverage.
But the question of how to deal with the estimated 12 million people here illegally could become a chasm too wide to bridge, especially once this becomes an issue in the race and positions become etched in stone, as is likely to be the case.
Simply put, the politics associated with providing taxpayer subsidies to illegal immigrants so they can buy health insurance might be a very tough sell to many members of Congress and their constituents, especially Republicans, who represent much of the Sun Belt, Midwest and Rocky Mountain states.
And a plan that does not offer coverage and subsidies to illegal immigrants might be unpalatable to many Democrats, especially those from the heavily blue states along the upper Atlantic and Pacific coasts.
The candidates trotting out their various reform plans are not offering the specificity required when their ideas are turned into legislation. But their proposals generally have some government subsidy or financial incentive for low- and moderate-income families to buy insurance.
About 10 million of the estimated 47 million U.S. residents without health insurance are thought to be illegal immigrants, the vast majority of whom would fall into the eligible income range. Currently, Medicaid, the federal health program for the poor, pays for emergency care for illegal immigrants, although in some states that has been used to cover treatment for non-emergency-room services such as chemotherapy.
It would be easy to imagine the political controversy over whether undocumented workers and their families would be eligible for the same incentives and subsidies as legal residents.
Immigrant advocates, some health care experts and many Democratic officials and interest groups would almost certainly argue that leaving illegal immigrants out of the proposal would be a public health disaster.
In that case, these experts predict the most severe cases among illegal immigrants would flood hospital emergency rooms that by law are required to treat everyone, driving up costs and leading to poorer overall health that could migrate to the general population.
But those who would oppose including illegal immigrants argue that scenario is actually the case now for all U.S. residents without health insurance, and reform without undocumented residents would cut that current problem by almost 75 percent.
These groups that stopped the immigration reform proposal advocated by President Bush and bipartisan congressional leaders might well be expected to balk at giving illegal aliens any taxpayer money.
It is worth noting that the question of whether to include illegal immigrants has been a major - although not the only - sticking point in California, where Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's health care plan has stalled. And public opinion in California is probably more likely to favor such subsidies than it is in most states.
The outcome of the GOP presidential race will also be a factor. Former Gov. Mitt Romney and former Sen. Fred Thompson have both criticized front-runner Rudy Giuliani for lax enforcement of immigration laws while New York mayor.
If either Thompson or Romney wins the nomination, he might be more likely than Giuliani to make the status of illegal immigrants in any health care reform a campaign issue.
Like all things political, in health care reform, the devil is in the details. And this is one detail that could be very difficult to work out.
- Peter A. Brown is the assistant director of the Quinnipiac University Polling Institute
More like this
- Health care is new third rail February 6, 2007
- Clinton to announce health care plan today September 17, 2007
- Health bill by Senate panel to address GOP concerns 5 comments / September 15, 2009
- Health overhaul closer than ever — yet still far off 4 comments / October 3, 2009
- Government-run plan could trip up health overhaul 3 comments / March 7, 2009
Top ads RSS
Marketplace
Arts & Entertainment · Bars · Theatres · Restaurants · Coffeehouses · Libraries · Antiques · Services
- Nation has right to ask ‘why?’ November 21, 2009 · 56 comments
- Blog: In Plain Sight, 11/20/2009 November 20, 2009 · 7 comments
- Mangino's contract outlines probe November 21, 2009 · 71 comments
- KU's Wright didn't approach Perkins November 21, 2009 · 18 comments
- Palin stirs feminist ambivalence November 21, 2009 · 27 comments
- Blog: Palin Book Could Be Your Cheapest Source For Winter Fuel November 20, 2009 · 83 comments
- Blog: We Noticed November 19, 2009 · 125 comments
- Lawrence man charged in hit-and-run accident that killed bicyclist November 19, 2009 · 116 comments
- FINAL: McCoy leads Longhorns over Jayhawks, 51-20 November 21, 2009 · 3 comments
- Mangino denies validity of former player allegations November 19, 2009 · 158 comments
- Four decades in crisis mode November 21, 2009
- Winter sports officially begin for city schools November 17, 2009
- The cowboy way: Williamstown church ministry draws unique following November 21, 2009
- No line at H1N1 immunization clinic November 21, 2009
- Health and stress affect grades November 10, 2008
- Lawrence couple excel in triathlons November 21, 2009
- Americans save more but earn less as interest rates fall November 21, 2009
- KU's Wright didn't approach Perkins November 21, 2009
- Obesity activist crossing country to urge American Indians to embrace healthier diet November 20, 2009
- Mangino's contract outlines probe November 21, 2009
3 October 2007
at 8:14 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
SettingTheRecordStraight (Anonymous) says…
Government handouts promote a disincentive to progress and prosperity for our country. That is but one reason why we should say no to all those advocating a radical expansion of programs benefitting one group of people at the expense of another group.
3 October 2007
at 8:20 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
geppetto (Anonymous) says…
Illegal immigrant health care should be outsource to Mexico.
3 October 2007
at 11:55 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
Confrontation (Anonymous) says…
If you want to see a waste of tax dollars, feel free to visit the Shawnee County Health Agency (Topeka's health department). The agency has to spend a fortune to fund spanish interpreters and provide health services to illegals who use fake social security numbers and have no intentions of paying their bills.
3 October 2007
at 12:21 p.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
True_To_KU (Anonymous) says…
Well, I'm all up for taller walls and more sharks in the ocean.
3 October 2007
at 12:34 p.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
Confrontation (Anonymous) says…
I think an electric fence and piranhas would be appropriate.
3 October 2007
at 1:12 p.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
KsTwister (Anonymous) says…
I am starting to understand that bumper sticker:
“You can have Social Security or
Illegal Immigrants but not both”.
3 October 2007
at 1:47 p.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
justfornow (Anonymous) says…
KsTwister, I have never seen the bumper sticker that you type of, but pretty much sums up what is happening.
3 October 2007
at 2:25 p.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
ljreader (Anonymous) says…
No way should illegal aliens be included in any American healthcare plan.
Give them medical treatment (so they'll be fit for the trip back home), then send the bill to the employers who lured them here, or the Mexican government who sends them here. Or, let the politicians who pander to them split all their bills..Since they seem to think it's OK for the rest of us to do, they shouldn't mind. We'll call them “racist” if they oppose.
4 October 2007
at 5:13 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
pje2111 (Anonymous) says…
Isn't the key word illegal?
4 October 2007
at 6:01 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
Dracul (Bill Chapman) says…
Any illegal immigrants, aliens, etc. should be imeddiately taken back to Mexico, after being finger-print and DNA processed against the national crime data base. If nothing pops up - back to Mexico, Do Not Pass Go! If something does pop up - put them in the system, sentence them for the maximum possible, and make them work it off doing any community job in the hopper.
Upon completion of sentence - back to Mexico, Do Not Pass Go!
By giving treatment before sending them back we encourage more to come across just for the medical care they might receive before being sent back. As for the maximum sentence, make them understand that they will be imprisoned for criminal activity and will be put on a “chain gang” during their sentence. I would like to force them into a Mexican jail, but that won't work.
5 October 2007
at 1:10 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
Brittanicus (Anonymous) says…
How can I help (ICE) Immigration & Customs Enforcement to protect my home, business and community? Notify ICE of inappropriate or suspicious behavior, including communications received by phone, fax, e-mail, third party, verbal communication or in writing. Always report crimes. To report suspicious activity, call our toll-free tip line at 1-866-DHS-2ICE. ”
Arizona, Colorado, Georgia, Oklahoma, Missouri and soon Kansas have enacted harsh I
5 October 2007
at 1:11 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
Brittanicus (Anonymous) says…
Immigration laws, to stop the hemorrhaging of the states economy. America can no longer support employers who hire foreign nationals for massive profits, while the citizens foot the bill. The media reports that their are large numbers of people fleeing these states, who are either self-deporting or are searching for a Sanctuary state or community. California is liable tip over and fall into the Pacific Ocean, but earthquakes will not be the cause?
About time that businesses and illegal immigrants looked over their shoulder?
5 October 2007
at 1:52 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
Rationalanimal (Anonymous) says…
Let's just all stop working and vote for the candidate who will promise us free everything—free money, free education, free housing, free healthcare, free beer, free food rations, free etc. And then some 20 years from now in a brief moment of sobriety we can say, “this concrete government housing really sucks,” and then go back to getting stoned or drunk.
21 April 2008
at 4:27 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
TopJayhawk (Anonymous) says…
Rationalanimal…We are close to that now. 1 in three people now are on medicaid in NYC. In a generation, if things don't change, I have heard estimates that 1 in 2 will be on medicaid, and other handout programs. We cannot afford this. If we don't limit things soon, I don't see how our economy can survive it. The more assistance you offer, the longer the line will be. It is the dark side of human instinct.