Archive for Monday, November 15, 2004

Where does God fit in Lawrence?

Survey suggests city less religious than rest of state

November 15, 2004

Advertisement

When Andrew Stangl was a senior at Andover High School near Wichita, he started a "freethinkers' club" for nonreligious students.

It was not a big hit.

"You notice that people become a little bit hesitant to associate themselves (with) you, or try to keep a respectable distance from you," Stangl, an "agnostic atheist," said of the reaction from a predominantly Christian student population.

That changed when Stangl came to Lawrence to attend Kansas University. His biology teacher taught evolution without apology to conservative sensibilities, the pressure to be silent about his lack of religious faith eased -- and Stangl felt a little more at home.

"You see a much higher degree of acceptance," said Stangl, president of the Society of Open-Minded Atheists and Agnostics.

In fact, a little-noticed 2002 nationwide survey suggested Lawrence was significantly less religious than the rest of Kansas -- and may be one of the least religious metropolitan areas in the United States.

At least one Kansas University official challenges the study's conclusions, but other observers say there's a widespread perception that religious faith isn't as deeply embedded here as in the rest of the state.

And several experts suggest that is a big reason Douglas County supported Sen. John Kerry in the presidential election -- while almost all the rest of Kansas supported President Bush.

"If you like this area, you say it's more cosmopolitan than the rest of Kansas," said Allan Cigler, a political science professor at Kansas University. "If you don't like it, it's a deviant county."

Andrew Stangl, president of the Society of Open-Minded Atheists and
Agnostics, speaks during a Thursday night meeting in the
International room at the Kansas Union.

Andrew Stangl, president of the Society of Open-Minded Atheists and Agnostics, speaks during a Thursday night meeting in the International room at the Kansas Union.

10th from the bottom

The 2002 study, performed by the Association of Statisticians of American Religious Bodies for the Glenmary Research Center, a Catholic missionary organization, found about half of Americans are claimed as adherents by 149 religious groups surveyed.

Kansas lined up with the national average, with 50.5 percent of the state's 1.3 million residents belonging to 89 different religious groups -- mostly Christian churches but including Jewish, Muslim and other faiths.

Lawrence was different. The study showed that:

How religious is Lawrence?

See the results without voting »

Note: This is not a scientific poll. The results reflect only the opinions of those who chose to participate.

Those figures may be one reason Lawrence often ends up in the midst of values-driven debates in Kansas -- such as clashes over the teaching of evolution and a human sexuality class taught at KU.

Religious divide

The Rev. Paul Gray, pastor at downtown's Heartland Community Church, said Lawrence was more liberal than the rest of the state on gay rights and abortion issues, and religion is a big reason for the divide.

"Lawrence is a very giving community," he said. "But it's also, I think primarily because of the influence of the university, gotten to be a super-liberal community to the point where traditional Judeo-Christian values are not the norm anymore."

Religious doesn't always mean conservative. Several Lawrence churches in recent years have opened their membership to gays, and some churches have been prominently involved in local protests about the war in Iraq.

But Lynn Bretz, a KU spokeswoman, said the survey might ignore the religious practices of university students, and could have undercounted members of other faiths.

"In looking at the survey, it appears to me the survey doesn't appear to acknowledge the religious preferences of college students who leave their hometowns," Bretz said. "A significant portion of the 26,000 students who call Lawrence home practice their religions here."

Political divide

Heartland Community Church worshippers listen during a service on
Sunday.

Heartland Community Church worshippers listen during a service on Sunday.

The Glenmary Research Center's study included a county-by-county map showing relative religious participation throughout the United States. It bore a striking resemblance to presidential election maps -- more religious states tending to support Bush, more secular states generally supporting Kerry.

"There does seem to be a relationship between church attendance ... and support for more conservative candidates," Cigler said.

And Lawrence, he said, fits squarely in that tradition.

"Public universities and the communities that surround them have less religious adherence than suburbs and rural areas," Cigler said.

Indeed, Stangl and Gray might not agree on religion, but they agree KU has a "secularizing" -- and liberalizing -- influence on the community.

Paul Mirecki, chairman of the religious studies department at KU, suggested that's because a liberal arts education requires an open mind.

"We discuss all issues, and look at them from various points of view -- historically, scientifically, psychologically, and try to let the students decide, as they say," he said.


The metropolitan areas with the lowest ratios of religious adherents, according to the Association of Statisticians of American Religious Bodies:
Metro area Percent of population claimed by a religious group Rank
Medford, Ore. 22 276
Corvallis, Ore. 22.6 275
Redding, Calif. 23.9 274
Eugene, Ore. 24.5 273
Jacksonville, N.C. 25.8 272
Muncie, Ind. 27.3 271
Chico, Calif. 27.4 270
Reno, Nev. 27.9 269
Grand Junction, Colo. 28.6 268
Yuba City, Calif. 28.6 267
Lawrence 29.1 266
Source: Association of Statisticians of American Religious Bodies

But the religion-and-politics connection may be a chicken-and-egg question, Mirecki added.

"I'm of the opinion that people are first political animals, then they select the religion that fits their political orientation," he said.

Bretz, however, resists the notion that KU or education makes Lawrence less religious.

"When I look at Lawrence's broad and robust groupings of churches, and the way they've grown since I've been in Lawrence ... I know that we contribute to that robust religious life," she said of the university.

Worries, hopes

Thursday night, Stangl presided over the first postelection meeting of the Society of Open-Minded Atheists and Agnostics.

Some 20 people -- most students, but some older adults -- attended. There was little talk about faith, religion or the lack thereof. Instead, they discussed what the re-election of President Bush meant for them.

The outlook was pessimistic.

"Eleven states banned gay marriage," said Jim Boyd, a Lawrence resident. "And we're less popular than gay people."

The mood was different the next night at Signs of Life, a downtown coffee shop and bookstore that caters to Christians.

"I've always felt, especially on campus, there's a strong Christian community," said Lydia Windheuser, a barista at the shop and a Christian who attends Lawrence Bible Chapel.

Her boss, John McClain, also was dubious of the study. He attends Grace Evangelical Presbyterian Church.

"I think Lawrence is a fairly spiritual town," he said. "Not necessarily evangelical Christian, but spiritual as a whole."

Commenting has been disabled for this item.