Man convicted of rape in Lawrence ‘sexsomnia’ case will get a special hearing to determine whether he had effective assistance of counsel
photo by: Kim Callahan/Journal-World
Reston Phillips holds hands with a young woman behind him during closing arguments in his rape trial on Thursday, May 15, 2025.
The Kansas Court of Appeals has ordered a hearing to determine whether a man convicted of rape — after his failed “sexsomnia” defense — had effective assistance of counsel at his Douglas County trial last year.
Reston Phillips, 32, was convicted of rape in May 2025 and is now serving a 12-year sentence at the Winfield Correctional Facility.
The jury found that he sexually assaulted a young woman during KU’s graduation weekend in 2017, when the two, both in their 20s, were spending the night on separate couches at a mutual friend’s residence in Lawrence.
Phillips, who evaded charges for years while living in Europe, claimed that if any sexual activity with the woman had occurred, it had been while he was in the throes of “sexsomnia.”
Sexsomnia refers to sexual activity that happens during sleep without the person’s knowledge. But the victim testified — and the jury believed — that Phillips had acted with knowledge of what he was doing. The woman accused Phillips of rape immediately after the incident and reported it to police.

photo by: Kim Callahan/Journal-World
Reston Phillips, left, appears with his defense attorney, Joe Huerter, Tuesday, May 13, 2025, in Douglas County District Court.
Attorney Cooper Overstreet had argued ahead of Phillips’ sentencing in January that Phillips’ trial counsel, Joe Huerter, had been ineffective because he did not request that an instruction be given to the jury that Phillips must have committed a “voluntary” act to be found guilty.
Judge Amy Hanley denied that request for a new trial. She found that Huerter’s representation of Phillips was “reasonable,” that the jury’s finding that Phillips had acted “knowingly” encompassed, as the state had argued, the idea of “voluntarily” and that a specific instruction on voluntariness wouldn’t have made a difference in the verdict.
The appeals court last week sent Phillips’ case back to the Douglas County District Court for what’s known as a Van Cleave hearing, which is a special hearing for when ineffective assistance of counsel is alleged.
The appellate order states that if Phillips receives an adverse ruling from Hanley at the hearing, he can have that decision reviewed by the Kansas Court of Appeals and can submit an amended notice of appeal within 15 days.
A date for the Van Cleave hearing had not been scheduled as of Monday afternoon.






