Archive for Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Topeka repeals domestic violence law

October 11, 2011, 9:25 p.m. Updated October 11, 2011, 10:55 p.m.


— Over the past month, one by one, people suspected in domestic battery cases in northeast Kansas have been set free with no charges against them. Prosecutors say they’re overwhelmed with felonies and, faced with budget cuts, can’t afford to pursue the cases.

Busted budgets have forced tough decisions by governments and law enforcement officials nationwide, but the Shawnee County district attorney’s move to stop investigating domestic abuse and other misdemeanor cases has angered victims’ advocates who say austerity has gone too far.

The advocates are also outraged by the response from the capital city of Topeka, where the City Council and mayor repealed the city’s domestic abuse law Tuesday night — a move designed to ensure the city wouldn’t be stuck with the bill for prosecuting such cases.

“I absolutely do not understand it,” Rita Smith, executive director of the National Coalition Against Domestic Violence, said after the vote. “It’s really outrageous that they’re playing with family safety to see who blinks first. People could die while they’re waiting to straighten this out.”

City and county officials are still hoping to strike a deal to end the budget dispute. Interim City Manager Dan Stanley said repealing the local ordinance “removes the ambiguity” and puts Topeka, the county’s largest city, in a better position to negotiate.

Most council members put the blame for their situation on the county and emphasized that they want to resolve the impasse, not deny abuse victims protection.

But City Councilwoman Denise Everhart, who voted against the repeal, said: “I just ask everybody to consider the message we’re sending.”

Shawnee County District Attorney Chad Taylor has said he knew his decision would upset people but contends his hand was forced by the 10 percent cut in his budget for 2012, which he said will force him to lay off staff. He considered employee furloughs and “every angle” before making his announcement in early September.

His spokesman, Dakota Loomis, called the city’s decision drastic and unprecedented but said Taylor would re-evaluate his position. The repeal doesn’t end negotiations between city and county officials; “it just means there is a new dynamic in play,” Loomis said.

Topeka has had at least 35 reported incidents of domestic battery or assault since early September. Those cases are not being pursued, and as of last Friday, 18 people jailed have been released without facing charges, according to Topeka police. Prosecutors and police have refused to discuss details of the cases out of concern for victims’ privacy, making it difficult to assess in what situations suspects aren’t being prosecuted.

The use of a weapon in an assault or battery makes a crime a felony, which would be handled in state court.

Taylor’s decision has prompted furious reactions nationwide, and county commissioners say they’ve received hundreds of emails in the past few days from people upset by Taylor’s move and the city’s response. Outside the Shawnee County Courthouse on Tuesday, about two dozen people carried signs protesting the moves.

It also doesn’t help that the possible repeal comes during National Domestic Violence Awareness Month.

“It can’t continue like this. They have to be prosecuted,” said County Commissioner Ted Ensley, a Democrat. “Supposing they’re charged and they’re not prosecuted and it ends up they go back and cause a death of a woman or a child.”

In a memo, Taylor’s office said budget cuts would force it to drop its prosecution of misdemeanors occurring within Topeka’s city limits and “of greatest concern are domestic violence cases.”

Topeka officials feared the city’s ordinance against domestic violence could have forced the city to take over prosecuting cases and file them in its municipal court. Local officials said Topeka couldn’t handle the $74-a-day cost per inmate of renting space from the county to jail several hundred suspected abusers or hiring additional staff to handle prosecutions.

The city already handled misdemeanor cases of simple assault and battery, and incidents of assault or battery against its police officers. Domestic assault or battery involves a person in the same household, and victims often need additional services or shelter.

City Council members who voted to repeal said the moves would help victims by ensuring such cases are prosecuted in state court.

For years, the city and county agreed that the district attorney’s office would handle domestic violence prosecutions in the better-funded state courts. City officials also note that the county has more services for victims and runs the jail.

As in other places across the nation, state and local governments in Kansas are struggling to balance their budgets and find new revenue. Earlier this year, Republican Gov. Sam Brownback won big cuts in general aid to public schools and eliminated state funding for arts programs while forestalling any effort to raise revenue through taxes.

A recent National League of Cities report said cities’ property tax revenues, a key funding source, are expected to drop nearly 4 percent in 2011.

“No one wants to make these cuts in essential services, but that’s where we’re at,” said Gregory Minchak, a spokesman for the League of Cities.

Cities including Cleveland and Sacramento, Calif., for example, have laid off police officers. And in many Midwestern states, sheriffs have stopped busting meth labs after federal money aimed at cleaning up the crime scenes ran out.

The current budget for the Shawnee County district attorney’s office is just under $3.5 million, and would drop to a little more than $3.1 million in 2012 under the spending plan county commissioners adopted in August. Taylor said the cuts imposed by the commission would force him to lay off 11 of his 63 staff members.

County commissioners said Taylor decided independently not to prosecute misdemeanor cases, and that all county departments are taking cuts.

Advocates for abuse victims are irritated that officials couldn’t resolve the dispute. Advocates see plenty of examples of dwindling resources for courts, services and law enforcement. But publicly backing away from prosecutions or repealing an ordinance to avoid potential costs?

“People all over the country are amazed that they’re even having this conversation,” Smith said.


notorious_agenda 2 years, 6 months ago

This has nothing to do with Kansas Republicans. It has everything to do with Kansas Liberals. The liberals of Topeka made this happen. They could cut other things, but they cut this so they can say "oh we've been spending too much money but now women and children and even men are being abused without recourse so give us more!"


ridikkulus 2 years, 6 months ago

Maybe it's just me, but I kinda think this is going to be counterproductive in Brownie's "Get Married, Stay Married" agenda. It's not all about the money...


somedude20 2 years, 6 months ago

OK if they cannot afford to go after crimes of this level what crimes will they go after? I bet there are at least a few laws on the books that they will enforce that, on the grand scale of things, are not nearly as severe as domestic battery


Paul R Getto 2 years, 6 months ago

People voted for smaller government (Muscular Sam) and this is part of what it looks like.


BigAl 2 years, 6 months ago

But we have plenty of money to implement new laws for non-existent voter fraud?


Lindsey Buscher 2 years, 6 months ago

Welcome to your new reality, Conservitards. Paying for prosecution is a good use of taxpayer money but we gotsta cut cut cut those taxes.


FalseHopeNoChange 2 years, 6 months ago

Cities are going broke. Here are a couple other examples of cities going broke.

"Fire stations in Camden Co., Ga., will soon be staffed with prison inmates. They’ll be monitored by a surveillance system, and by the regular firefighters — who will have to undergo special training

Most of the streetlights in Highland Park, Mich., have been repossessed. The electric utility has removed 1,400 lights as part of a settlement that will save the city $4 million in unpaid bills."

(from a source)


JJE007 2 years, 6 months ago

I guess this is the wild west ag'in. Git y'r leg iron on'n' shoot the bash t'rds.


5rings 2 years, 6 months ago

The prosecutors are now between a rock and a hard place. With no funds to go after misdemeanors (although I BET they continue to prosecute traffic infractions...) then victims of long term, repeated assault (usually domestic violence) may feel trapped into resorting to violence to escape the situation. Because a physically weaker person must escalate the level of violence against a physically stronger person in order to prevail, this may well result in a homicide. Which the prosecutor will have no choice but to prosecute, as it's entirely likely that a necessary element of traditionally accepted self defense is likely to be missing, that is, immediacy of the threat. But, without a reasonable expectation of the protection of law, then it would seem that ongoing threats become proximate. So, if YOU are called to the jury pool for a case where a long term abuse victim kills an abuser, remember, the very state that is prosecuting this domestic victim is the same one that is financially unable to protect that victim. The state will argue that without an immediate threat such violence is unjustified. But place yourself in the abused' shoes. If you believe that, absent help, escape is impossible, then suddenly the definition of "proximate threat" changes. And violence may become necessary. The system does not want to hear this... But, don't just automatically trust the prosecutor's opinion. Ask yourself what YOU would have done, knowing there was no protection available from the law... And vote to convict or acquit accordingly.


Christine Anderson 2 years, 6 months ago

Good call, my arse! The Topeka City Council and mayor feel "these cases" are better handled at the county level. But Stupidheads, your Shawnee Co. DA has stopped prosecuting these cases. So, the City of Topeka and Shawnee Co. are simply playing a game of pass-the-buck. And it's going to be a deadly game for women, men, anyone who is being abused.


Fossick 2 years, 6 months ago

“Supposing they’re changed and they’re not prosecuted and it ends up they go back and cause a death of a woman or a child.”

Shouldn't that be "charged"?


pace 2 years, 6 months ago

They are planning tourist events. "Slap your grandma day' Bring your spouse to Topeka if you want to send her to the Moon Alice events. Awards for the most bruised but still living loved one.


Liberty275 2 years, 6 months ago

Good call. Unless persons by virtue of living inside the city have different needs regarding domestic violence, then the law was redundant. County law should be fine.


Commenting has been disabled for this item.