Archive for Thursday, January 27, 2011

Charlette Blubaugh pleads guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud in KU ticket scandal

January 27, 2011, 10:59 a.m. Updated January 27, 2011, 2:03 p.m.


Related document

Charlette Blubaugh plea agreement ( .PDF )

Former University of Kansas athletic department consultant, Thomas Ray Blubaugh, and his wife Charlette Blubaugh, left and center, leave the U.S. Federal Courthouse, in Wichita, Kan., on Wednesday, Dec. 8, 2010, after being arraigned on a charge of conspiring to commit wire fraud. Prosecutors say the couple, along with others, are charged with stealing athletic tickets and scalping them for cash to ticket brokers and third parties outside the university totally $5 million.

Former University of Kansas athletic department consultant, Thomas Ray Blubaugh, and his wife Charlette Blubaugh, left and center, leave the U.S. Federal Courthouse, in Wichita, Kan., on Wednesday, Dec. 8, 2010, after being arraigned on a charge of conspiring to commit wire fraud. Prosecutors say the couple, along with others, are charged with stealing athletic tickets and scalping them for cash to ticket brokers and third parties outside the university totally $5 million.

KU ticket scandal

David Ray Freeman, a Lawrence builder, pleaded guilty Tuesday to conspiring to commit bank fraud in connection with an anticipated building boom in Junction City.

— Another former ticket manager for Kansas Athletics Inc. has admitted in federal court that she took part in a scheme that converted stolen KU basketball and football tickets into tax-free cash through sales by ticket brokers and others.

Charlette Blubaugh pleaded guilty Thursday morning to one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, a crime that carries a potential prison term of 20 years and a $250,000 fine. She now is responsible for paying up to $2 million to the government, to cover her share of ill-gotten gains.

She admitted her guilt and entered into a plea agreement approved during a hearing before U.S. District Judge Wesley Brown, in federal court in Wichita. Sentencing is set for 10 a.m. April 14.

“Charlotte’s happy to get this matter behind her, and she accepts responsibility,” said John Rapp, one of her defense attorneys, after the 47-minute hearing.

Blubaugh is the latest in a string of former colleagues at Kansas Athletics to plead guilty in connection with the scam, which prosecutors say ran from 2005 to 2010. Already having pleaded guilty to conspiracy are:

Kassie Liebsch, a former systems analyst who took over the top tickets job after Blubaugh left the department.

Rodney Jones, who had been an assistant athletics director in charge of the Williams Fund.

Still awaiting trial is Ben Kirtland, who is accused of conspiracy. His trial is scheduled to begin March 8 in Wichita.

In February 2010, as federal agents had been investigating the ticket scam, Blubaugh resigned to take a job in the athletics director’s office at the University of Central Oklahoma, telling Kansas Athletics officials that she’d wanted to be closer to family. At the request of Kansas Athletics, she agreed to continue working with the department to help compile information about the ticket scam for investigators.

On Thursday in court, Assistant U.S. Attorney Richard Hathaway documented that Blubaugh actually had been an active participant in the scam. He said KU had hired Blubaugh away from her job in the ticket office at the University of Oklahoma, to become “kind of a consultant” to Kansas Athletics, where she would work her way up to become an assistant athletics director for ticket operations.

During that time, Hathaway said:

• Blubaugh became familiar with Liebsch, Jones and Kirtland and, in 2005, “a conspiracy commenced,” with Blubaugh providing tickets to “various employees” for illegal resale.

• Blubaugh received tickets from the department’s printer, and set aside “a large number” of season tickets — “originally at the request of Ben Kirtland” — for distribution through conspirators.

• Such diversion of tickets escalated to the point that tickets would be moved through her husband, Tom Blubaugh, who worked as a consultant to Kansas Athletics from August 2007 to January 2010, with documents authorizing his $115,000 of total compensation being approved by Kirtland.

• Received proceeds from tickets channeled through Liebsch, Jones and Kirtland. Tickets “moved” through her husband were sold through brokers in Oklahoma, and only the Blubaughs split those proceeds, Hathaway said.

• Failed to report any of the proceeds to the IRS nor to the NCAA through Kansas Athletics, therefore avoiding payment of taxes.

In all, Hathaway said, the conspirators reaped proceeds of more than $2 million from the ticket scam.

Now Charlette Blubaugh and others who have pleaded guilty are responsible for giving up the gains.

“You understand that you’re responsible for a monetary judgment of $2 million?” Judge Brown said.

“Yes, sir,” she responded.

“You understand?” he repeated.

“Yes, sir,” she said.

As part of her deal with prosecutors, she has agreed to provide information about all of her assets since 2005 — part of an examination into her financial situation that could include a lie-detector test.

She also must assist authorities in their investigation and prosecution of the case and “all related conduct.”

Her husband is scheduled to plead guilty to conspiracy at 10 a.m. Friday, also before Judge Brown.

Two other former colleagues, Jason Jeffries and Brandon Simmons, previously had pleaded guilty to failing to disclose the scam to authorities. They and others who already have pleaded guilty also await sentencing.

Interactive Timeline

KU ticket scandal timeline

View timeline on a new page.

A previous version of this story incorrectly stated that Charlette Blubaugh pleaded guilty to bank fraud.


Paul R Getto 7 years, 2 months ago

"As part of their plea agreements, the co-conspirators consent to cooperating with investigators and prosecutors as they pursue the case and related items." === Such a sad situation, where greed got ahead of common sense. How this unfolds and upon whom it unfolds will be most interesting and, in the end, tragic.

mfagan 7 years, 2 months ago

Yes, she had resigned from Kansas Athletics to take a job at another school in Oklahoma -- and Kansas Athletics folks said at the time that she didn't have anything to do with anything that might be going on with tickets or anything else improper (university and federal officials had not yet acknowledged the existence of any investigations). Kansas Athletics had her help compile information for investigators, until they and others realized that she might be part of the scam. - Mark Fagan, reporter

sr80 7 years, 2 months ago

king lew has already been his peons will be dealt with.yeah right.NOT!!!

Richard Heckler 7 years, 2 months ago

When I was working on houses in Bauer Brook, I noticed that Rodney was always at Doug Compton's house. It was always Dave Freeman(Junction City crime activity), Rodney Jones, and Doug Compton. In fact, I saw Rodney at Compton's birthday party just a couple of months ago. Lew Perkins was there too. Are these guys all involved in this? I'm not saying they are, I'm just curious. I know that Compton has many seats to basketball games. Is he paying for all of them? Usually where there's smoke, there's fire.

kuprof54 7 years, 2 months ago

Just to mess with you, by your theory that would mean that you're in on it too.

BruceWayne 7 years, 2 months ago

i have noticed that on most of the away games this year, Doug is sitting right behind Coach Self. Looks shady to me.

guess_again 7 years, 2 months ago

If you take the ticket issue off the table, I am still amazed that Blubaugh was allowed to repeatedly contract with and authorize payments to her husband for his "consulting services." And this wasn't any secret, it was apparently known to many.

This shows that on the expenditure side of the department, which involves people outside of the ticket office, that there was/is a serious lack of appropriate internal controls.

kuprof54 7 years, 2 months ago

That goes on at another place at KU. In the Bschool, Dean Bill Fuerst hired his wife to run the accounting department and his daughter (a few years ago but she no longer works there) as a consultant. His daughter wasn't listed on the payroll because she was a consultant, but Fuerst makes about $310k and his wife another $85+ for I think 70% appointment, so his family was taking in just under half a million from KU. Nepotism at its best? I'd say so.

imastinker 7 years, 2 months ago

I hate to break it to you, but that's everywhere at ku. Look at a listing of KU employees by last name and see how many have the same one. Then figure there's even more on account of marriages and name changes.

Vinny1 7 years, 2 months ago

This is seriously breaking news how?

If you thought anything other than a guilty plea was going to happen you're just naive.

Steve Jacob 7 years, 2 months ago

Made the front page of, so it's big enough news.

yankeevet 7 years, 2 months ago

Wow; there are so many crooks in this town!!

Synjyn Smythe 7 years, 2 months ago

'tis just a matter of time before we read about Mr. Perkins' indictment!

Haiku_Cuckoo 7 years, 2 months ago

He was never accused and isn't even considered a suspect. At least two of those involved admitted during their pleas that they hid the scam from him. He made the mistake of trusting his employees. If he was involved in any way it would have come out a long time ago and he would have been terminated from KU with cause rather than resign.

ralphralph 7 years, 2 months ago

  • mistake of trusting his employees *

BS. He failed to put proper procedures in place. Banks "trust their employees", but they still count their money and have cameras on them, and auditors, etc.

You can't just leave millions of dollars worth of tix in the hands of these flunkies, with no effective audit system, and expect anything different than what happened. Doesn't KU have an accounting program in the Business School? It's not a new idea.

friendlyjhawk 7 years, 2 months ago

"Charlotte is happy to get this matter behind her." None of this is behind her, she still has to pay the monies back and faces a jail sentence of some kind. Nothing is behind her-she has lots more misery to look forward too.

SELF_RESPECT 7 years, 2 months ago

Conspiracy the day Rodney D Jones called Jeffries back from Nebraska and then he ran to Oklahoma to invite Charlette Stuart and Tom Blubaugh to join the "club"! Poor little Lebiesch sat right there and thought she could protect herself by knowing what role everyone played. Well who is the lowest of lows now??????? Oklahoma really should investigate the Stuart/Blubaugh ring. Those 2 knew how to make the computer system work for them and they learned that as a Sooner!!!!


Maracas 7 years, 2 months ago

The Blubaughs look rather over fed. Very over fed. One wonders whether they do any exercise besides walking to the fridge. Must be nice eating on stolen money while you're going for the hat trick of stealing from your employer, their customers, and the government.

Wayne Propst 7 years, 2 months ago

The tickets were sold to brokers and others....the "others" should be busted for receiving stolen goods at the very least and banned from KU functuions....

Justice2011 7 years, 2 months ago

Many gave up protesting their seat assignments in disappointment and disgust when they saw the Federal Bench sitting with Perkins year after year. Ralph had it right with the Judge Enjoys Court Side Company Article - "two pees in a pod."

LJW provided an opportunity for him to explain it and took it. "Since the beginning of the men's basketball season, John Lungstrum, chief judge of the U.S. District Court of Kansas, has sat courtside with Kansas University Athletic Director Lew Perkins. The two often can be seen in the background during televised games, Lungstrum wearing his lucky blue KU sweater.

"He's there as my guest," Perkins said. "We're friends, and we enjoy talking basketball with each other."

Said Lungstrum, "I guess I'm just a lucky guy, is basically what it amounts to."

The two met at a party a couple years ago, Lungstrum said. At the time, Perkins' daughter, Holly, was considering going to law school.

"He called me and said, 'You're the only person I know on the law school faculty. Would you mind talking to my daughter about law school?'" Lungstrum said. "I said I'll be happy to. ... That was the beginning of our having more than just a casual acquaintance."

Perkins' daughter ended up going to KU law and this year has a for-credit internship working in Lungstrum's chambers in Kansas City, Kan.

Lungstrum, a member of the Williams Fund, holds four season tickets.

During the summer, Perkins asked Lungstrum to come and sit courtside with him. Lungstrum said he was able to accept the offer in part because of his long-standing policy to not hear any cases related to KU.

"I never have taken KU cases because I'm on the faculty. I am conflicted out of any litigation that would involve the University of Kansas," he said. "If that were not the case, I probably would have declined Lew's offer to sit there because I recognize that I'm fairly visible sitting down there."

Guess so. Photo by Nick Krug

John Lungstrum, left, chief judge of the U.S. District Court of Kansas, sits courtside with Kansas University Athletics Director Lew Perkins during Saturday's men's basketball game against University of Texas.

Being chief judge of the Kansas district means overseeing administrative functions of the court - such as electronic records management, scheduling of dockets and court rules - in addition to a regular caseload. Lungstrum said he does not have any influence on the opinions of the other federal judges in the district.

The show goes on with at least 5 more people to sentence as this cover blanket unfolds. Will this never end?

ralphralph 7 years, 2 months ago

File a complaint. Judges are subject to oversight. There is a process to file complaints if you think a judge is acting inappropriately. The standards are pretty high for them ... you generally would see requirements that they "avoid even the appearance of impropriety".

Follow up. File.

Kam_Fong_as_Chin_Ho 7 years, 2 months ago

Am I missing something? I fail to see anything illegal.

Kontum1972 7 years, 2 months ago

in the tropics somewhere....fuji is not a bad place or new zealand...its one heck of a long flight and boat ride....but darn good fun!

4everahawk 7 years, 2 months ago

guess-again: Go back and look over the documents made available to the media when the investigation started........there were invoices from Mr. Blubaugh for his services signed off on for payment by the chief financial advisor and one of the associate athletics directors. Lew said he wasn't aware he was a paid consultant. That alone is gross lack of institutional control.

BruceWayne 7 years, 2 months ago

Rosie O'Donnel will play her in the made for ESPN movie. Rosie or Jim Belushi, take your pick.

SELF_RESPECT 7 years, 2 months ago

OH GOD !!! You picked the perfect person to play her part!!! Rosie! Both are nauseating!

greenworld 7 years, 2 months ago

Regarding Lew, doesnt seem like there is a pattern that goes hand in hand with those who do something wrong. It seems when it all goes down they all either run or retire. So maybe there was more to Lew resigning then what meets the eye. As in if you take or remove yourself from a situation it makes it seem like your not a part of it. Idk seems pretty shady to me. And then he only gets fined 4000.00 for the equipment. hell, thats chump change to a millionaire.

Jim Williamson 7 years, 2 months ago

Doug Compton, involved in something shady? I would be SHOCKED! /endsarcasm/

4everahawk 7 years, 2 months ago

Some folks find it interesting that when Lew came to town and he started his 'friend' list, it included the chief of police, a federal judge, a multitude of attorneys and a very tight relationship with Compton. Just saying......

greenworld 7 years, 2 months ago

dont think these people will do the time that's been given to them. my brother got charged years ago with fraud and they charged him with 15-30 yrs and fined him. He did 90 days in a minimun fanility out in el paso. and another 90 days house arrest with ankle bracelet. These people will do probly less than a yr most of them if not 90 days -6 months. dont kid yourself. They will be right back out probly trying to scam somebody or make quick money. they might have millions of dollars buried somewhere and never half to work again. but you can guarantee one thing, they never will work around money , for any type of athletic department or financial institution again. i dont believe they cleaned out the whole department , im sure they were others involved and they might be have to go in a re-clean it out again in the next few years.

Kam_Fong_as_Chin_Ho 7 years, 2 months ago

You keyboard-Kojaks crack me up! You keep implicating Lew, Compton and Lungstrum despite the fact that none of them are suspects. Can I play along? Okay, my turn: I saw Compton at Hy-Vee standing in line behind Laird Noller! How does Laird fit into to this? Later that day I saw Danny Manning at the McDonald's drive thru. The kid in the window handed him a soft drink and a bag. I'll bet the bag was full of cash or tickets.

4everahawk 7 years, 2 months ago

Don't believe that 'keyboard-Kojaks' are trying to implicate Compton or Lungstrum in the ticket scam. Compton has plenty of money and Lungstrum just was getting some pretty fine benefits from being Lew's friend and helping Lew's daughter. I think the red flag is Lew circling himself with people in every walk of life that could benefit him in most any situation if needed. It just still seems odd that all this was going on right under his nose and he didn't suspect a thing! AND, for 5 years! Really? The Ron Olin hire a few weeks before he retires still puzzles many.

Haiku_Cuckoo 7 years, 2 months ago

You make it sound like it's unusual for a powerful person to have powerful friends. That's the way the world works. People with money hang out together. When you add the fact that they are big KU donors, it was smart for Lew to befriend them. Look at what happened earlier this week at UConn for example.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.