Archive for Thursday, January 13, 2011

Kassie Liebsch pleads guilty to wire fraud, faces up to 20 years in prison in KU ticket scandal

January 13, 2011, 8:47 a.m. Updated January 13, 2011, 2:26 p.m.


Kassie Liebsch

Kassie Liebsch

— The former head of the ticket office at Kansas Athletics Inc. pleaded guilty Thursday to taking part in a scheme to steal at least $2 million worth of athletics tickets, to reap a total of $5 million from their sales and to elude payment of taxes on the transactions.

And she told a federal judge that she’d accept spending up to 20 years in prison for her five years’ worth of crimes, condensed in an indictment to five words: conspiracy to commit wire fraud.

“From approximately age 22 to age 27, Kassie Liebsch made decisions and took actions which she now deeply regrets,” said David Bell, her attorney, after the hearing. “By pleading guilty today in court, she has accepted full responsibility for her decisions and actions. She looks forward to moving on to a new chapter in her life.”

As part of a plea agreement accepted and approved by U.S. District Judge Wesley Brown, Liebsch, now 28, also must repay up to as much as $2 million — either on her own or jointly with other codefendants in the case, should they be found guilty. She admitted to receiving $100,000 in illegal proceeds from the sale of tickets, and already has forfeited a 2008 Toyota Camry she’d purchased with cash received as part of the scheme.

Liebsch’s sentencing is set for March 30.

With federal agents looking on from the gallery, Liebsch also promised to cooperate with prosecutors in their investigation and prosecution of others said to be involved in the crimes. In exchange, prosecutors agreed to recommend a reduced sentence.

Rodney Jones, a former assistant athletics director in charge of KU’s Williams Educational Fund, also is charged with conspiracy to commit wire fraud and is scheduled to plead guilty at 10:30 a.m. Friday, also before Brown in U.S. District Court in Wichita.

Others charged are Charlette Blubaugh, who preceded Liebsch as leader of the ticket office; Blubaugh’s husband, Thomas Blubaugh, who served as a paid consultant to the athletics department; and Ben Kirtland, who had been Jones’ boss as associate athletics director for development.

The Blubaughs and Kirtland are scheduled to stand trial beginning Feb. 15, although Kirtland is seeking a delay to give his attorney at least 30 additional days to review evidence: nine boxes of documents provided by KU, plus disks containing 12,000 pages of e-mails involving Kirtland and another 50,000 e-mails involving other alleged co-conspirators.

“Counsel would suggest that the charges in this case are unusual, if not novel,” attorney Robin Fowler wrote, in his request for a delay.

Brown has not yet ruled on Kirtland’s latest request — he had rejected an earlier one on procedural grounds — but the judge did acknowledge Thursday that the case against Liebsch involved an oddity: While Liebsch arrived at the hearing facing up to 30 years in prison for conspiracy to commit wire fraud, such a sentence would presume that the case had involved a financial institution.

“KU is not a financial institution,” he told attorneys, ruling that the maximum sentence therefore would be reduced to 20 years in prison.

Richard Hathaway, assistant U.S. attorney, noted that other portions of the case involved having ticket brokers write checks to cash at out-of-state banks so that the money could be “given to intermediaries to give back to conspirators in Kansas.”

Earlier in the hearing, Brown had acknowledged the complicated nature of the conspiracy, instructing Hathaway to describe the facts of the case slowly and deliberately.

“It’s quite a caper,” Brown said.

Specifically, Hathaway said:

• Liebsch graduated from KU in 2005, and was hired by Charlette Blubaugh as a systems analyst in the ticket office, with responsibilities to serve as a liaison between the ticket office and about 10 development officers, including Jones and Kirtland.

• Liebsch received requests for tickets from Jones and Kirtland, and originally sought permission from Charlette Blubaugh before filling them — until Charlette Blubaugh told her that a group of tickets had been “separated” for the pair and that Liebsch should “never tell Rodney and Ben ‘no’ regarding a request for tickets.”

• In 2005, Liebsch began receiving cash from Jones, and received instructions from him how to convert cash into money orders in amounts that would allow for avoidance of currency reporting requirements.

• Liebsch joined the conspiracy, knowing that tickets were being taken for sale to third parties, in violation of university policies; accepting cash from such sales; and engaging in a phone conversation with Charlette Blubaugh, Kirtland and others that included Charlette Blubaugh discussing plans to manipulate the department’s computer system before responding to requests from law enforcement regarding ticket assignments.

While the ticket scheme is said to have started in 2005, its existence became exposed early last year. Jones had been placed on administrative leave, Charlette Blubaugh had resigned to take another job in Oklahoma, and federal agents had been asking questions within the athletics department. KU announced in March that it was conducting its own investigation, while federal authorities were pursuing their own.

KU’s internal report, released in May, would identify Jones, the Blubaughs, Kirtland and Jones as conspirators. Two other former department employees — Brandon Simmons and Jason Jeffries — also were named in the KU report, a document that included financial details about more than 20,000 tickets for regular-season football and basketball games that had been improperly diverted for conspirators’ personal gain.

Liebsch had been cited in the report as having helped expose the scheme. Only later, when news of the federal indictments was released Nov. 18, did Liebsch resign from Kansas Athletics.

Simmons and Jeffries already have pleaded guilty in federal court to failing to notify authorities about the scheme, and now are cooperating with prosecutors and awaiting sentencing.

As the scandal unfolded, Lew Perkins announced in June that he would resign as athletics director at the end of the 2010-11 school year. By September, however, Chancellor Bernadette Gray-Little had accepted Perkins’ departure “effective immediately,” a full year ahead of schedule.

In the plea agreement, Liebsch said she and her co-defendant misled Perkins into believing there was a computer system in place to prevent tickets from being stolen, converted or taken by fraud.

Interactive Timeline

KU ticket scandal timeline

View timeline on a new page.


consumer1 7 years, 5 months ago

The first snitch gets the best deal. Rodney Jones has his rear covered.

Alceste 7 years, 5 months ago

If "....Rodney Jones has his rear covered...." because he came clean first, I'd say he's the smarter of the lot....not a "snitch". All of 'em knew what they were doing.....the others were just too stupid to understand they had been caught. Ain't no such thing as a "partner in a crime" when it comes time to pay the piper.

I am curious to know how the profits were divided. Evenly? shrug

yankeevet 7 years, 5 months ago

She is making a deal to save herself; do not pass go; just go strait to jail............

doc1 7 years, 5 months ago

There is no deal. She confessed to it all and didn't make any deal to reduce anything.

doc1 7 years, 5 months ago

He didn't know anything about it so he wouldn't need anyone protecting him.

funkdog1 7 years, 5 months ago

Really? Twenty years? There are people who commit murder and get far less time.

trinity 7 years, 5 months ago

"employees have pleaded guilty in the case, which involves more then $1 million in football and basketball tickets." i copied and pasted this line simply due to the use of "then" where T-H-A-N should be. good lord.


Jonathan Kealing 7 years, 5 months ago

Sorry about that. Got it fixed now. Thanks for pointing it out.

Bob_Keeshan 7 years, 5 months ago

How did the KU investigation miss over $100,000 in personal gains?

Can't wait to hear what Jack Focht has to say about that. Liebsch was deemed so immaterial to this scandal that she got promoted.

kuprof54 7 years, 5 months ago

They missed it the same way they missed many things in the Bschool review: They didn't want to find anything and they very carefully controlled what the audit firm was allowed to look at. A coincidence that the firm that did athletics did the Bschool review? I don't think so.

As a professor, I know that the office who was ultimately responsible for execution of the Bschool problems/DT was the provost's office. The comptroller was also involved in the review. That office was charge of internal controls. Sound fishy that the parties who would be held responsible if something were to be found wrong were the ones that conducted the review? Same thing with the Athletics review - the people who were ultimately responsible oversaw the review.

goodcountrypeople 7 years, 5 months ago

Same thing goes with KU's whistleblower policy. Apparently, the assigned investigators are often the people at fault, yet they abuse the authority granted by their positions to point fingers of blame at others. Such is the appalling level of conflict-of-interest politics at KU and in Lawrence that KU officials are even often allowed by Charles Branson and his cronies down on Eleventh Street to use local law enforcement mechanisms to wrongfully persecute people.

KU's HR Department needs to replaced wholesale. Tampering with evidence in order to support false legal charges is a felony, and these people are not above that. They're a complete joke when it comes to professionalism and ethics and respecting diversity. One of their investigators is great at putting smearing racism allegations against workers and then punishing them before they've received legally required due process. I've also witnessed this Department, in charge of safeguarding employee health privacy laws, cruelly and unethically savaging them.

JoRight 7 years, 5 months ago

Heh, sounds like you're all too familiar eh?

Also, interesting point. . .but as far fetched as this sounds, it's most likely true. Crazy.

BillybobThorten 7 years, 5 months ago

Actually he spent time in jail. And exactly what did he steal??

xyz 7 years, 5 months ago

Further proof that all KU employees on the internal team that investigated this mess, as well as whomever (besides Lew) decided to promote Kassie should be fired ASAP. And Jack Focht needs to return his check. New AD Zenger needs to clean the Lew stench from his department ASAP.

Shane Rogers 7 years, 5 months ago

"Brown asked Assistant United States Attorney Richard Hathaway, who appeared for the prosecution, to outline Liebsch's involvement in the case and to do so deliberately." -- On my first read-through I'm thinking to myself, "Self, who is this mysterious Mr. Brown fellow?". So I rescan the previous couple of paragraphs thinking that I have most certainly glossed over the person's name....nope.

So I continue reading....ah, so perhaps it's this Judge Wesley Brown fellow.

LJW, this is not the first time that I've noticed this reading your site. Can we please introduce the person's complete name before referring to them by their last name?


Kash_Encarri 7 years, 5 months ago

Maybe they are referring to UPS. You know "what can Brown do for you?"

xclusive85 7 years, 5 months ago

both pleaded guilty to pleaded guilty to committing misprision, a felony punishable by up to three years in prison, a $250,000 fine and a year of supervised release.

Also, pleaded guilty to pleaded guilty to? Do the editors even read the articles before allowing them to be posted?

Richard Payton 7 years, 5 months ago

Tom Delay only received 3 years for wire fraud. Same crime but not same amount of time. RNC #2 man received special treatment? Depends on your viewpoint.

VTHawk 7 years, 5 months ago

Not really the same crime. The "wire fraud" statute in Texas was used in a way that it hadn't before, and the crime didn't involve theft. Delay was convicted for funneling out of state money through the RNC before sending it back to Texas, thus circumventing restrictions on out of state money in TX elections. In most states, no such restriction exists.

This fraud plea condenses several different crimes--all involving theft for personal gain--into one plea. Such actions would be illegal in 50/50 states.

yankeevet 7 years, 5 months ago

Such a young greedy woman; well; so much for her career...........

Danielle Brunin 7 years, 5 months ago

I hope it was worth it. She made all of that money and she bought a 2008 Camry? Don't get me wrong; Camry's are great cars, but if I'm going to do something that has the potential to send me to prison for 20 years, I'm going to buy a ridiculousy awesome car, or maybe a hover craft!

jcphawk 7 years, 5 months ago

She hasn't been sentenced yet. They are just saying that she could receive up to 20 years. She'll get much less for cooperating.

John Spencer 7 years, 5 months ago

JK, in the last paragraph.

both pleaded guilty to pleaded guilty to committing misprision

Rob Zerwekh 7 years, 5 months ago

This is from the U.S. Attorney's office. Like the others, I'm sure she thought she wouldn't get caught.

Liebsch, who started as a freshman at KU in the fall of 2001, was hired as a student worker at the Kansas Athletics Ticket Office. She answered phones, helped customers, processed mail and took orders for tickets to athletic events. When she graduated in 2005, co-defendant and Associate Athletic Director Charlette Fay Blubaugh hired her as a systems analyst at a salary of $30,000 a year. In the course of her duties, Liebsch worked with co-defendants Rodney Jones and Ben Kirtland, both of whom were employed by the Williams Educational Fund, the fund-raising arm of KU Athletics. Upon becoming a systems analyst in 2005, Liebsch received requests for tickets to athletic events from Jones and Kirtland. At first, she sought Blubaugh's approval before providing the tickets. Then Blubaugh told Liebsch she had set aside a group of tickets for the Williams Educational Fund and Liebsch no longer needed to ask permission. Blubaugh told Liebsch "never tell Rodney and Ben no" when they asked for tickets. Sometime in 2005, Jones began giving Liebsch cash. He showed her how to convert the cash to money orders in amounts low enough to avoid currency reporting requirements. Rather than alerting athletic officials to the scheme, Jones joined the conspiracy. She continued to provide tickets to Jones, Kirtland and others, knowing that some or all of the tickets would be sold to third parties in violation of university policy. She continued accepting money from Jones that she knew came from the proceeds of tickets being sold in violation of university policy. She took part in phone conversations with Charlotte Blubaugh and Kirtland in which Kirtland said he had received money from Jones and Blubaugh talked about making changes to the ticket computer system before responding to a law enforcement request for information on ticket assignments. Liebsch used some of the cash she got from Jones to make payments on a 2008 Toyota Camry. In addition to diverting tickets, the conspirators misled the Director of Athletics to believe that a computer system was in place to prevent tickets from being stolen, converted or taken by fraud.

Mkultra 7 years, 5 months ago

March 20th is a Sunday and during the NCAA tournament how ironic.

Mkultra 7 years, 5 months ago

Oh now it says 30th perhaps it was changed or I read it wrong but it is still during the Tournament haha

sad_lawrencian 7 years, 5 months ago

So happy I graduated from Wichita State and not KU! This means I won't be associated with a university that has all these problems. Rah, Rah, Wichita!

alman84 7 years, 5 months ago

Right, because when I choose the school that's best for me and when employers are looking at my resume, I immediately think of the athletics department...

It's unfortunate these things happened, but this has no bearing on the quality of the education I recieve(d) at the university, and I'm quite proud of my engineering curriculum.

doc1 7 years, 5 months ago

I agree. I'd throw my KU degree up against a Wichita degree any day of the week. When people think of Wichita they think of dirty old run down trailer parks.

sad_lawrencian 7 years, 5 months ago

You are so right! Lawrence doesn't have ANY trailer parks!

hujiko 7 years, 4 months ago

And Wichita has a great university free of ANY corruption!

Kontum1972 7 years, 5 months ago


olddognewtrix 7 years, 5 months ago

So, when she "cooperates" with the prosecutors to try and get their help at sentencing time, one wonders what other person or persons will possibly end up being accused of fraud.

olddognewtrix 7 years, 5 months ago

So, when she "cooperates" with the prosecutors to try and get their help at sentencing time, one wonders what other person or persons will possibly end up being accused of fraud.

blindrabbit 7 years, 5 months ago

What is the latest "skinny" on others (not KUAD employees) that have been mentioned in connection with the ticket scandal story. Keep hearing about "other shoes to fall", but that's kind of a old story. Maybe waiting for BB season to be over!

ralphralph 7 years, 5 months ago

I wouldn't think the Feds are too worried about the basketball season. I do, though, share your curiosity about "the others" ...

gphawk89 7 years, 5 months ago

"Liebsch made decisions and took actions which she now deeply regrets"

Does she really, truly, deeply regret her actions? Or does she just regret getting caught? Lacking any investigation, would she still be stealing and selling tickets today? If so, then the regret is not all that deep.

4everahawk 7 years, 5 months ago

There are now 16...SIXTEEN...associate athletics directors currently in athletics. Prior to Lew, there were 4 positions that highly ranked and perhaps 6 or 7 assistant athletics directors. That was back when those positions actually meant something and had some relevance. The people in those positions earned those top spots, especially the associate ADs. Lew made sure that he promoted all his hires to the highest paid positions and created positions if one didn't exist. He created new titles and placed people (some from within) into those jobs. It is believed by some that he made sure he took care of his 'people' before he left. Hopefully the new AD will see that athletics is completely top heavy and that most of those positions have few duties and could be eliminated. That alone would save at least a million/year in salaries. It will be interesting to see how the next few months play out.

xclusive85 7 years, 5 months ago

Well, I'm not saying that we could not do with less than 16 associate athletics directors, but the department has gotten larger. I looked at another well respected university's employee list and found 19 associate athletics directors. Here is a link.

Now, I am not doubting your numbers, but where did you get your info from?

4everahawk 7 years, 5 months ago

Go to, inside athletics, then directory. Some of these positions were recently created and some of the staff recently promoted to associate ADs. I know this to be true. As a matter of fact, Nicole, chief of staff, is now an associate AD, but I don't believe it has been changed on the directory. It's a case of very high ranking, highly paid staff 'in charge of' others who actually do the work. Also true.

xclusive85 7 years, 5 months ago

Again, I am not disputing what you said, but where are the numbers from before Lew took over?

Andrea Hoag 7 years, 5 months ago

I can't help but feel a little bit sorry for Ms. Liebsch given how young she is.

Danielle Brunin 7 years, 5 months ago

It does seem like Rodney Jones and Charlette Blubaugh groomed her for their scheme, and used her youth and inexperience just so they could have a fall person in case their scheme fell apart. That said, she should've known better as she grew up. That's a hard lesson to learn at such a young age. Maybe she will use this experience for good once she gets out of prison.

opobserver 7 years, 5 months ago

I find it interesting that Jones is pleading a deal when he is supposedly the ringleader. Hmmm?

opobserver 7 years, 5 months ago

A Lawrence woman got 8 yrs in fed. today for an ebay sceme selling stolen tools. I am sure it was not a million dollar scheme like this.....I hope Jones doesn;t get off with less than that. Maybe white collar crime has different rules. Don't know. We will have to wait and see.

Alceste 7 years, 5 months ago

Funny how Liebsch's photo is all dolled up and the actual mug shot taken when she was booked is never used. In fact, it's not been used on any of these arrogant little twits involved in this matter.

Alceste 7 years, 5 months ago

And, now, at 6:18am, Friday, January 14, 2010 Liebsch's pretty picture is on the front page of the on line edition. Why not post her mug shot, please? posts the mug shots of the "common" criminal. Show us the despair and regret which must surely exist in the photograph taken by the authorities following her arrest, please.

Alceste 7 years, 5 months ago

She "....hasn't been arrested ..."?????? Why is she being prosecuted? Doesn't one have to be arrested before one is prosecuted?

Trust me.....I don't care....I'm simply trying to demonstrate via example that "connected" white girls NEVER get their mug shot posted......some "glam shot" is always substituted......Now......wait....I'll ask that question later.....

Aiko 7 years, 5 months ago

Alceste, do you have a link that will show her mugshot? Please send it if you do.. thnx

Maracas 7 years, 5 months ago

Nothing would make me happier than to see Rodney Jones go down hard. That man is a huge wart on society's bum.

JustNoticed 7 years, 5 months ago

“KU is not a financial institution,” he told attorneys ..." Very funny. He must be thinking of the good old days.

wysiwyg69 7 years, 5 months ago

They put the "pretty picture" in to tease all of the pretty girls in prison.

sherbert 7 years, 5 months ago

I wonder if the court takes into account that this young woman was brought into this when she accepted the job. This was probably her first real job, and an exciting one, in most young peoples eyes. They showed her that this is how it's done here, and even though she probably realized at some point that it was illegal, it's how it's done and how she was trained to do the job. She probably thought it was how the department was run for a long time. I think this should be taken into consideration. It was much bigger than her and she was innocently pulled into it. I don't know her at all, but this is what it sounds like.

doc1 7 years, 5 months ago

Thats a good point. Very good point indeed. You have to feel kind of sorry for her.

Alceste 7 years, 5 months ago

She never knew the difference between "RIGHT.....vs. WRONG"???? or did she, at a very early age, grow accustomed to a sense of entitlement? Arrogance indeed.

thesloss 7 years, 5 months ago

Yes, excellent point. Liebsch moved into a big established machine with Uncle Lew looking down at her (like the Grinch looking over Whoville) patting little CindyLoo (Liebsch) on the head saying, "This is how we do things here in my kingdom little one".

Frightwig 7 years, 5 months ago

Check out the last sentence of the article. It appears that Cindy Loo was pulling the wool over the Grinch's eyes. :)

doc1 7 years, 5 months ago

She hasn't been arrested or sentenced yet for that to happen.

Alceste 7 years, 5 months ago

How does one plea "GUILTY!!!!" to something they've never been accused of, let alone be sentenced from same plea?!

Kevin Millikan 7 years, 5 months ago

enjoy your new roommates Kassie, I'm sure they will enjoy you!!

Kontum1972 7 years, 5 months ago


opobserver 7 years, 5 months ago

Maracas - Couldn't agree more! And don't you also think it is odd that the ringleader (RJ) is trying to cut a deal? Heard he's been spending the past couple of months stashing his dough for later.

4everahawk 7 years, 5 months ago

xclusive85: In 2002 there were 6 associate ADs and a couple of assistant ADs. Granted, the department has grown, but the number of athletes and coaches didn't increase that much. The only job responsibilities that increased were those of the support staff and coaches who worked for each program/sport. Support staff in offices and coaches had more paperwork due to changes in recruitment and compliance, maintenance/custodial staff had more areas/buildings to clean/maintain, but the number of people hired to do those jobs didn't increase. An increase of 10 associate ADs and several assistant ADs to 'oversee' the support staff still doesn't make sense. Believe it's apparent that all those upper echelon staff weren't doing a very good job of overseeing their assigned offices. Actually it was some of the upper echelon who were committing the crimes!

xclusive85 7 years, 5 months ago

Again, I didn't disagree with anything you are saying. I just want to know where you got the info that there were only 6 associate ADs. How is it something that you know? Most people don't know all of the associate ADs. I just was wondering if you had a link or something that shows that?

Lana Christie-Hayes 7 years, 5 months ago

Just for the record everyone.... it says "faces UP TO 20 years in prison." It doesn't say that IS the sentence. That is yet to be determined! My guess is that it will be more like 3-5 years and then a LONG LONG LONG parole... because there will be restitution that there is likely no way she will ever be able to pay back in the course of her lifetime. Personally, I would love to see the book thrown at ALL of them. Regardless of what other sentences have been handed down to other offenders in other cases and jurisdictions. This one was in the backyard of the town I was born and raised in and love! It just sickens me that these greedy A-holes had to use the successes of KU Athletics to puff up their own pockets. Lord knows they were probably being paid a pretty nice salary already. GREEDY, DIRTY, B____tards!! I'm just glad that all of this finally came to light and that there has been a major sweep of the KU Athletics Dept. Rock Chalk Jayhawk.. GO KU !!!!!

onceajhawkalwaysajhawk 7 years, 5 months ago

Is Moringstar not indicted because he isn't a ku employee?? You would think that at least the FEDS / IRS would be on his tail for the cash he supposed to have taken..

Gary Hawke 7 years, 5 months ago

This is such a kick in groin to all the "old" KU fans who were kicked out of their season ticket seats by Lew's all the faculty and alums who have to sit in the nose-bleed section of the all the students who camp out and spend hours waiting in line for a seat. When I read this stuff, I get so angry I feel like Big Lew and his cronies (many of who are are still employed in top KU positions) need to face some kind of punishment. At best, this is criminal negligence on their part. When Lew was hired, Chancellor Heminway decided to scrap integrity for money. This is the result. The positives and negatives of any organization can be attributed, directly, to the top people in that organization. I'm a huge sports fan but I'm less in love with KU athletics after this!

Frightwig 7 years, 5 months ago

It was a smart business move. Do a Google search for "priority point system" and you'll see that many, many universities use the same method. Can you name any major NCAA athletic program that doesn't use the priority point system? It doubled KU's athletic budget and allowed new facilities to be built. It may have made some people angry, but it had to be done to keep KU competitive with other schools.

Wayne Propst 7 years, 5 months ago

Brandon Macneill Perkins' son-in-law (assoiate AD)passed out tickets for Lew.....He is now at Tulane....the Pres. of Tulane in from, you guessed it, U Conn. Where does Lew's doughter work? These people are clustering the tax payers and allums big time

Grump 7 years, 5 months ago

I wonder who the tickets were sold to? The purchasers must have known, or had reason to know, the tickets were stolen? The tickets must have been very expensive. Who could afford them? Will the people who purchased obviously stolen tickets be charged?

Commenting has been disabled for this item.