Archive for Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Wrong conclusion

September 30, 2008


To the editor:

I am responding to the Aug. 20 editorial. It implied that author Max McCoy sought to make Quantrill out to be a hero in real life.

This view contradicts the author's statements published on Aug. 12. In that article, McCoy tells us that he hopes to humanize Quantrill. I believe that his meaning was taken out of context. The fact is that we are dealing with a work of fiction, the characters of which are to be analyzed in a literary fashion, not a literal one.

If one views a painting of a war scene, we cannot leap to conclusions as to whether the artist is pro or con regarding war. McCoy is exercising his artistic license to "paint" his subject as he sees fit and, in this case, with the acknowledged realization that it would spark controversy.

We should recall that McCoy confirmed his belief that Quantrill was a monster, albeit a human monster. The infamous BTK killer was a man, and the fact that he functioned in society and was considered a good person by many was perhaps the most chilling part of that story.

Fictional works should be judged in the literary arena. I wonder how "I, Quantrill" would have been viewed had the name Quantrill and locale been changed. We should not demonize McCoy or his artistic work. He is guilty only of creating believable characters.

Dana Hummell,


Ragingbear 9 years, 8 months ago

Humanize is a way of showing you that history is not black and white. It is a way to see into the personality and motivations, or at least an attempt to do so. Kind of like that one jerk everyone hates, but gives a third of his paycheck to charities without fail. Not that that makes up for it, but it does give you a different outlook on something.History is alive. We see it all too often as obscure and 2-dimensional. This encourages people to think on a different level, and see a piece of history from a different angle. Kinda like those 3D art puzzles where you got to relax your eyes...

Charles L. Bloss, Jr. 9 years, 8 months ago

P.S, Are you related to Deanna? Thank you, Lynn

Commenting has been disabled for this item.