It’s unfortunate that the tenure of the new Haskell Indian Nations University president already is stirring suspicions. However, the shadowy allegations put forth in a DVD now circulating on the Haskell campus may provide a positive opportunity to air some complaints and allay some fears.

Haskell President Linda Warner is exactly right when she says that it would be far better for students or others with complaints to stand up and say “I think X, Y or Z” rather than hiding behind an anonymous video that she sees as “almost terroristic.” Her terrorism comparison may be a bit overstated, but the “Trick or Treaty” DVD clearly is an attempt to destroy trust in Warner’s administration by spreading fear while making no serious attempt to let the president respond or explain.

In fact, Warner seems to have very logical explanations for many of the charges leveled in the video. She was criticized for giving responsibility for Haskell football concessions to a private contractor rather than leaving it with students. The action was a trial, she said, that is expected to net as much income for student organizations while taking away the burden of students organizing and staffing the concession stands. It seems like a good idea. Why not give it a try?

Warner also was criticized for assigning her executive assistant, who has a journalism background, to be an adviser for The Indian Leader, Haskell’s student newspaper. Critics apparently see the move as an attempt to spy on or influence the newspaper staff. Although the newspaper editor said the staff was disappointed not to have a say in the appointment, he had to admit his fears that she might try to influence the newspaper’s content hadn’t been realized.

Perhaps the most volatile rumor was that Warner intended to seek a steep increase in student fees. The fear that fees would drive a number of students away from Haskell was tied to the idea that Warner was plotting to close the school. Many students who attend Haskell have limited financial means and the school is a wonderful opportunity for them to pursue a higher education. Even with a significant fee increase, however, the school still would be a bargain compared to any other university, public or private. A fee increase would need to be discussed with the Haskell Board of Regents and it seems a bit extreme to connect a fee increase to Haskell’s imminent closing.

Whether the rumors are simply false or have some element of truth, “Trick or Treaty” is a cowardly way to raise these issues. Change is difficult, but it’s not necessarily bad. Haskell students, faculty and supporters should give the new president a chance to hear and address their concerns rather than assume the worst.