White tiger at K.C. Zoo comes with controversy

Critics say breeding animals does not help save species

? The gift shop at the Kansas City Zoo already is flush with white tiger toys as park officials anticipate the popularity of their special summer exhibit.

A 325-pound tiger with cream-colored fur and somewhat blue-hued eyes will be both the star attraction of a new Asian-themed exhibit and the centerpiece of the zoo’s summer marketing campaign.

The 16-year-old cat named Silver will be on exhibit through Oct. 1.

The animal is beautiful, no doubt, but she also is part of a controversy in the conservation community.

Critics say that white tigers are a genetic anomaly and that breeding them does nothing to help efforts to preserve their critically endangered orange cousins.

To breed or not?

Defenders say responsible breeding of white tigers does no harm and allows zoos to improve their bottom line – which is what makes other conservation efforts possible.

“We’re producing white tigers simply because they’re very popular with the public and they’ve helped us with the gas and light bill,” said Lee Simmons, director of the Henry Doorly Zoo in Omaha, Neb., which has lent Kansas City its summer exhibit.

White tigers are not albinos. They are the result of both parents having a recessive gene for white coloration. The official species survival plan for tigers, a compact among zoos, does not recommend their breeding because they are not pureblooded specimens of any of the five remaining subspecies of tiger.

Silver is a white tiger on loan to the Kansas City Zoo from the Henry Doorly Zoo in Omaha, Neb.

Natural selection works against white tigers. They are extremely rare in the wild because standing out in the jungle does not help catch prey.

But some zoos and private owners deliberately breed them because the public likes to see them. Las Vegas performers Siegfried & Roy enjoyed a cottage industry with them before Roy Horn was severely mauled by a white tiger during a 2003 performance.

Irresponsible breeders may mate close relatives, such as a parent and an offspring, to better the odds of producing white cubs. But that also leads to many birth defects, and animals that cannot be displayed often are discarded, according to the Big Cat Rescue sanctuary in Tampa, Fla.

“From my perspective it is irresponsible, if not reprehensible, because they are bringing these animals into the world purposefully for profit,” said Ron Tilson, director of conservation at the Minnesota Zoo and coordinator of the Tiger Species Survival Plan.

But Simmons said zoos breed responsibly by periodically crossing white tigers with orange ones to maintain a healthy gene pool.

“Ron (Tilson) is a good friend but he’s a little bit idealistic,” Simmons said of his Minnesota colleague. “I absolutely do not have the slightest little guilt feeling” about breeding or displaying white tigers.

Zoo ‘needs help’

Kansas City Zoo Director Randy Wisthoff knows tigers are severely threatened but says he does not have the facilities or resources to pursue conservation efforts here and abroad that other, larger zoos do.

“Me showing one white tiger here in Kansas City for a summer is not going to make or break the world’s tiger population,” Wisthoff said.

“Why are we doing it? Because this zoo needs help, and conservation costs money. You’ve got to start with getting people to come to your zoo.”

The Omaha zoo has three white tigers, all of which are currently on loan to other zoos.

The zoo also has a large collection of pureblood tigers of three subspecies and is very active in tiger conservation.

It produced the first test-tube tiger and the first tiger born by artificial insemination.

The Kansas City Zoo’s last tiger, a 14-year-old of the Amur subspecies, was euthanized because of old-age complications in 2001.

The five buildings of Kansas City’s old Cat Walk, which has not housed cats since 2003, have been spruced up for an exhibit that also includes several Asian animals new to the zoo, including Francois langur monkeys, tufted deer and wreathed hornbills.

The white tiger’s roughly 1,000-square-foot space is slightly larger than the outdoor display areas in Omaha and includes shade and a watering hole.

Her diet will consist of 9 pounds of fortified horse meat five days of the week, a knuckle bone to chew on on Sundays and one day of fasting.