New report shows Douglas County’s disparity between black and white incarceration rates is higher than national average

photo by: Screenshot

This screenshot shows members of the Douglas County Criminal Justice Coordinating Council during their meeting via Zoom on June 9, 2020.

Black inmates in Douglas County generally spend more time in the county jail than white inmates, and this problem is more pronounced in Douglas County than the national average, according to a new analysis presented to the local Criminal Justice Coordinating Council on Tuesday.

Matt Cravens, data analyst for the CJCC, said the county’s incarceration rate for black people is about 4.7 times the white rate. Nationally, the black incarceration rate is about 3.2 times higher than the white rate, he said.

The incarceration rate is different from the number of people booked into the jail. Cravens’ analysis showed that the rate of black arrestees booked into the Douglas County Jail in 2019 was 3.1 times the rate of white arrestees. But the difference between black and white incarceration rates is larger than that, in part because black inmates spend more time in the Douglas County Jail on average, Cravens said.

White inmates spent an average of 16 days in jail in 2019; black inmates spent an average of 27 days, and Native American inmates an average of 19 days. Asian inmates spent an average of 16 days and Hispanic inmates 10 days.

Even though roughly one-third of the jail’s population comprises residents of counties other than Douglas, Cravens said he doesn’t reach a different conclusion when factoring in residency.

Mike Brouwer, Douglas County criminal justice coordinator, said having this statistical evidence to show what the council believed was true is “kind of another level. It validates what we all believe.”

“I think this gives us an opportunity to establish a baseline that as we implement training, that as we work through the recommendations of the law enforcement contact study, that we look at other national initiatives, we can now begin to have a baseline to compare ourselves to, and look at progress that we’re making,” Brouwer said.

Cravens did another analysis to examine the factor of race. He adjusted for conditions such as age, gender, number of charges at arrest, classification of felony or misdemeanor, specific offenses, court jurisdiction, case type and status in the courts. Some variables, such as criminal history and victim statements, were not factored into the analysis.

That model showed that for each day a white inmate spends in jail, a black inmate will spend 1.3 days, and a Native American inmate will spend 1.4 days, according to Cravens’ report. Hispanic and Asian people spend slightly less time, 0.9 days and 0.7 days, respectively.

In an analysis of hypothetical inmates sentenced for burglary under similar conditions, a white inmate would spend 90 days in jail, a black inmate would spend 111 days and a Native American inmate would spend 122 days, according to Cravens’ report.

Lawrence Mayor Jennifer Ananda sought more guidance from the rest of the CJCC members for next steps for the racial and ethnic disparities work group, but there didn’t seem to be much of a consensus.

Some members suggested further data collection that could glean additional insights, such as looking at how mental illness factors into the new analysis or trying to include criminal history data. However, it wasn’t entirely clear from the rest of the discussion what the next concrete steps would be.

Brouwer said the data in the report doesn’t prove what causes it, but that doesn’t mean the CJCC shouldn’t keep trying to address racial inequalities.

“That doesn’t mean we don’t do the work; that doesn’t mean we don’t try to make a difference,” he said.

— Journal-World reporter Dylan Lysen contributed to this article.

Contact Mackenzie Clark

Have a story idea, news or information to share? Contact public safety reporter Mackenzie Clark:

COMMENTS

Welcome to the new LJWorld.com. Our old commenting system has been replaced with Facebook Comments. There is no longer a separate username and password login step. If you are already signed into Facebook within your browser, you will be able to comment. If you do not have a Facebook account and do not wish to create one, you will not be able to comment on stories.