The cowboy way: Williamstown church ministry draws unique following

Conner Reich, 3, Valley Falls, claps to the music during a church service at the Crossroads Cowboy Church in Williamstown. The church’s attendance has grown weekly since it opened March 1.
They arrive in their coats and jeans, huddled on metal folding chairs that have seen better days. They dodge raindrops springing from holes in the yellow-and-white striped tent.
Outside, pickup trucks and sedans share equal space, while a horse trailer is triple-parked on a patch of frozen earth moonlighting as a parking lot.
Inside, hats removed, they bow their heads and pray, cool breath visible from their lips as they follow the lead of a man wearing jeans at an altar emblazoned by a cross with a horseshoe at its center. On the south side of the tent, a wood-burning stove crackles away, not doing much good on this November morning.
There’s no stained glass, no pews with lavish cushions, nor a choir dressed in robes. But don’t be fooled. This is a place of God.
Welcome to Crossroads Cowboy Church.
Located in Williamstown, at the intersection of Highways 24 and 59, the church is more than at a crossroads of a strips of asphalt. It’s the intersection between Christianity and Western culture, says the Rev. Terry Newell, pastor to the church, which has grown about 80 members since forming in March.
“It was just a vision that I had come up with. I mean, it’s not an original idea for sure, but I’ve been involved with horses and riding all my life,” says Newell, who was an associate pastor at the Williamstown Church of God before starting Crossroads as an off-shoot operation. “We wanted to further the ministry of the church I was at, and so we all thought it would be a great way to reach the Western culture.”
Tent-making
The tent that houses Crossroads filled up for the first time March 1, when 22 people came to hear the message on a Sunday so cold the outside temperature was in the single digits. But the idea came the previous May when Newell began exploring the idea of such a worship service, inspired in part by a television show aptly called “Cowboy Church.” The show is co-hosted by singer Reba McEntire’s sister, Susie McEntire Luchsinger, and the pastor of a successful cowboy church in Texas, Russ Weaver. Last fall, Newell attended a leadership conference headed by Weaver, hoping to learn how to form a cowboy church of his own. Just a few weekends ago, Newell spoke at this year’s conference, now a poster pastor for a successful plant.
Newell’s wife, Shella, says not only has the church crammed nearly 100 people into the tent at times, but it has had only one week when someone new didn’t attend.
“To me, it just goes to prove how many people out there of this culture had a hunger and a desire to go to church but just didn’t feel like they fit in or had the time to go there. We do it a lot earlier so they can go and rodeo or whatever they’re going to do that day,” Shella Newell says. “But yeah, we are surprised.”
But despite its rapid growth, Crossroads hasn’t caused Williamstown Assembly of God’s membership to suffer. In fact, it may have even helped the traditional church gain members.
“We’re averaging probably 135, and when we started the cowboy church, we sent over about 20 people and … we’re averaging about the same,” says the Rev. Rick Burcham, pastor of Williamstown, which is referred to as the “mother church” to Crossroads and is its landlord, too. “We haven’t changed numbers, but we’ve gained people. We’ve replaced those (that they lost).”
One person attending both churches is Priscilla Taylor of Meriden, who is possibly the only person at Crossroads this particular morning in traditional Sunday finery. Every Sunday, she attends Crossroads first and then makes her way over to Williamstown for its 10:30 a.m. service. Though skeptical in the beginning, Taylor says she’s grown quite fond to Crossroads, showing up every week except for the very first one.
“When I first heard about this … it seemed kind of sacrilegious to me, you know, because I’ve been raised in the church all my life,” she says, meaning bricks and mortar and stained glass. “And everybody said, ‘It won’t work, it won’t work.’ But I said, ‘Yes, it will, because it’s in a country community.'”
Country, Community, Cowboy, Comfort
And while the painted-wood “CCC” sign outside the tent could stand for “Country Community Church” as much as Crossroads Cowboy Church, it might very well have another meaning: comfort, comfort, comfort.
Bill McCall was one of several churchgoers who pointed out that this church, with its homespun, come-as-you-are vibe, is as much as about being at ease as it is being with God. He’d been looking for a church for five years since moving to Oskaloosa. In June, on the urging of a friend, he attended Crossroads, and now standing in the middle of the tent in a cowboy hat, coat and jeans, he fits right in.
“Well, the reason I attend here is because, first of all, our pastor preaches right from the word, and I mean he hits you right square in the face with his sermons. And the other reason is the fellowship that I’ve experienced since I’ve been coming here,” McCall says. “And plus the fact that the people here have a common interest in riding horses. And so all three of those is why I started coming here.”
Indeed: On Wednesday nights, the church’s youth group alternates horsemanship practice and mini-competitions, and the church had a full-on rodeo in July, something planned to become an annual event.
And though the rodeo will be at Crossroads in 2010, the church’s good-old yellow-and-white tent will not. This week, the church expects to have a permanent, pre-fab building delivered. But moving indoors won’t change his church’s focus, says Newell, unless you count the fact that the parishioners might be able to worship without their coats and scarves.
“Our primary focus is to share the gospel … and then our second is to mentor and develop others through living out our faith in every aspect of our lives, including our Western (activities),” Newell says. “And then, thirdly, one of our missions would be to bring back a sense of community and to help develop families through … equestrian events and activities, like rodeo Bible camps, barrel racing, team penning, all the different things that are related to Western culture.”