Building weathers criticism

Snowy Cleveland winter puts school's roof to the test

? The shiny, swirling $62 million building that houses the business school at Case Western Reserve University is a marvel to behold. But it is sometimes best admired from afar.

In its first winter, snow and ice have been sliding off the long, sloping stainless-steel roof, bombarding the sidewalk below. And in bright sun, the glint off the steel tiles is so powerful that standing next to the building is like lying on a beach with a tanning mirror.

The peculiar Peter B. Lewis Building was designed by Frank Gehry, the internationally renowned architect who also created the titanium-covered Guggenheim museum in Bilbao, Spain.

“You might have to walk on the road to make sure you don’t get hit by ice,” said Adam Searl, a junior at Case Western’s Weatherhead School of Management. “Maybe they should have thought about it before they had built the building. It’s Cleveland. We get ice. We get snow. We get rain.”

The building is about five stories high. Instead of walls on the south side, it has a curving roof, made of 20,000 stainless-steel shingles, that seemingly tumbles to the ground.

On a sunny day, the building produces a shimmering glare, with patches of concentrated heat. In Cleveland’s winter, though, sun glare isn’t the problem. The city has seen more than 86 inches of snow this season, and is on a pace to break the 1995-96 record of 101 inches.

The university ordered barricades erected on the sidewalk to keep pedestrians away after the first big snow of the season produced something like an avalanche off the roof, said J.B. Silvers, associate dean for resource management and planning.

No one has been hurt, he said, but “I asked for the sidewalk barricades so we wouldn’t have people getting snow inadvertently dumped on their heads.”

Barricades protect people from falling snow and ice outside the Peter B. Lewis building at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland. The new 2 million building is the creation of renowned architect Frank Gehry. But in its first winter, snow and ice have been sliding off the stainless-steel roof.

The sidewalk will soon be eliminated and replaced with landscaping, and a new walkway will be created.

Gene Matthews, director for plant services for the campus, said the university was working closely with Gehry’s firm to fix the problem without detracting from the building’s character.

Silvers said the harsh winter had given the university an excellent opportunity to test the new building and see how it stands up to the elements.

Meanwhile, some of Case Western’s 9,500 students brave the sidewalk anyway, stepping around the barricades. But most stay clear.

Rosalyn Foster, a graduate student, said the sidewalk barricades and falling snow and ice were easy to live with, considering the modern facilities inside.

“It’s a great facility, it really is. It accommodates everyone who works here, as well as the students,” Foster said.