City Hall

City Hall

What has become of the art for East Ninth Street?

This file photo from April 2017 shows a portion of East Ninth Street in Lawrence.

This file photo from April 2017 shows a portion of East Ninth Street in Lawrence.

January 7, 2018


The idea of bringing public artwork to East Ninth Street is not dead, but time is running out if the art is going to be incorporated into the city’s design to reconstruct the roadway.

The City Commission has approved funding for the street reconstruction, and plans are underway for the project to begin in the spring. Porter Arneill, the city’s director of communications and creative resources, said the further along the design process is, the harder it will be to integrate more complicated art.

“There’s ways of doing some things to accommodate some artworks, but the opportunity to be fully integrated is waning quickly,” Arneill said.

The city’s street project will reconstruct East Ninth Street from New Hampshire Street to Pennsylvania Street, including sidewalks, lighting and storm sewers. A final design for the street project is forthcoming, but whether permanent public art will even be proposed is still unknown.

A new work group

The Lawrence Arts Center is leading the art portion of the street project, and a proposal made in July planned for the design process to begin this month. But Interim Arts Center CEO Cindy Maude said that is not yet happening, and that instead the center is “taking a step back” because of feedback from the organization funding the project and from city leaders.

The art for East Ninth is being funded by a $500,000 ArtPlace America grant, and Maude said ArtPlace accepted the proposal made over the summer, but with the caveat that the Arts Center work with the East Lawrence Neighborhood Association throughout the process. Maude also noted that Mayor Leslie Soden gave similar direction. Maude said the process going forward will be “more inclusive of what the East Lawrence Neighborhood is about.”

“I think the main thing is that we’re all trying to work together and utilize these funds for the good of the community, the artists in Lawrence and for the East Lawrence Neighborhood,” Maude said.

A work group composed of Maude and ELNA board members Dave Loewenstein and Josh Davis has been meeting for a couple of months and will present a preliminary proposal for the project at ELNA’s meeting on Monday. Maude provided limited specifics to the Journal-World about what will be presented and said that what they have is a broad outline with potential ideas that the neighborhood will discuss before a final proposal is created.

Art options

Since the ArtPlace grant was awarded — now 3 1/2 years ago — the artistic elements of the East Ninth Street project have been significantly scaled back. In 2015, a $3.8 million design concept by el dorado inc. was proposed that integrated artistic elements such as natural rock seating, native grass and light and sound displays. The Lawrence City Commission did not move forward with that design and subsequently denied the Art Center’s request to provide city funds toward public art, voting instead to commission another company to create the traditional street design that is now in progress.

Maude said although having permanent art in the project is definitely still an option, it is not a guarantee. She said art could include some permanent works as well as performance art or ephemeral pieces.

What is known is that there is a continued desire to involve local artists in whatever artwork is produced. Maude said the proposal calls for working with about 15 artists total and extending invitations to the five local artists previously selected as part of the original el dorado concept: Meredith Moore, Rachael Perry, Nick Carswell, Stephen T. Johnson and Zia.

Funding will also dictate what art may be created. There is about $343,000 left of the $500,000 grant, according to information Maude provided to the Journal-World. The largest expenses so far have included $50,000 toward the el dorado design, $28,125 for the project director, $21,000 for artist fees and $21,000 for artists' supplies. Other costs included accounting, administration and printing and publications.

Letting a new process unfold

Some residents in East Lawrence were originally against the el dorado project, also referred to as “the arts corridor,” because of concerns about the initial decision-making process and what effects the project might have on the neighborhood.

Loewenstein, a local muralist whose studio is on East Ninth Street, is one of the residents who spoke out against the initial iteration of the project. Loewenstein said what the new work group is trying to do with the second iteration is difficult, and he hopes it will be allowed to unfold.

“It takes some guts to do this, I think, because of all the emotions and perceptions that were generated the first time around,” Loewenstein said. “So I really appreciate that (Maude and Davis) were willing to do this.”

Loewenstein said he also appreciates that the ELNA board was willing to re-engage with the project, which he said he sees as a great first step. He said he thinks the new project is an opportunity to build trust among all involved — and also a chance to create something cool.

Even if the next proposal is too slow in coming to be integrated into the street reconstruction design, there may still be options. Though Arneill said deadlines for art proposals aren't currently set, he said simpler projects could likely be added late in the process. In addition to programmatic art or performances, Arneill said there are ways to hold space in the design for permanent artwork even if it’s not yet known what it will be.

“There are situations where it is possible to put in sort of a placeholder,” Arneill said. “In other words, identify (that) this artwork would go on this spot and perhaps pour a concrete pad or something along those lines.”

The broad proposal will be presented at ELNA's monthly meeting Monday, and the association plans to vote on a final proposal in February. Maude said the Arts Center must have the project completed and all grant funds spent before June 2020.


Bob Smith 1 month, 1 week ago

Everybody sobered up and decided the gratuitous art was a lousy idea?

Fred Whitehead Jr. 1 month, 1 week ago

You mean that there is not enough junk in the junkyard for the local "artists"??

Tony Peterson 1 month, 1 week ago

Knew it wouldn't take long for the nasty comments to start. Happens any and every time there's a news article with some connection to East Lawrence.

Kendall Simmons 1 month, 1 week ago

It's not about East Lawrence, though. It's about half a million dollars and, for example, things like literal "street art" that didn't last more than 3 weeks. (And NOT because of graffiti.)

Sure, there are people who don't support public art. Or who will point to the graffiti in the Pinckney tunnel. Or that it's been 3 and a half years since grant funding was awarded and, while $157,000 has already been spent on "a chance to create something cool", there's actually nothing to see.

But it's not East Lawrence that people are complaining about. It's the large amounts of money being spent with nothing to show for it.

Tony Peterson 1 month, 1 week ago

It is partly. Anytime there's anything about East Lawrence the trolls come out in droves. There could be an announcement that a business was opening that would provide 50 new jobs and there'd be some comment about the "trashy" neighborhood and some slam about the residents. I've seen it over and over and over during the 25 years I've lived here.

Stacy Napier 1 month, 1 week ago

Question of the day "What has become of the art for East Ninth Street?"

Answer of the year " No one cares"

Half a million dollar grant for art? Are you kidding me? Why not use that money to pay for peoples health insurance for a year or start an annuity for Heartland Heath Center. I think that would double one of their efforts. They show they gave $1500 last month in rent assistance. half a mil would make almost that much in simple interest a month.

Aaron McGrogor 1 month, 1 week ago

Because they can't. They use that money for this project, or they give it back.

Stacy Napier 1 month, 1 week ago

Yea I get that. My point was where ever the money came from they were dumb for putting it to that when they could have put it to help people. Priorities

Bob Summers 1 month, 1 week ago

Since there is little or no "job lock" in East Larryville, what would the inhabitants do without other peoples money for their sculpting and macrame projects?

March in the streets?

Nuh huh....

Give these critical thinkers what they need to keep them peaceful. Complacent.

Dennis Domer 1 month, 1 week ago


More lovely words and phrases. They are so instructive. I'm going to add "critical thinkers" to your Little Dictionary along with "East Larryvile," and "The Bird". So I suppose "uncritical thinkers" might be logically the opposite of critical thinkers? Would you be an uncritical thinker, for example, or a critical thinker? Denny

Bob Smith 1 month, 1 week ago

Tony, any similar project would be met with the same hooting no matter where in Lawrence it was to be located.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.