Archive for Thursday, February 22, 2018

Court: Kansas can’t cut Medicaid funds to Planned Parenthood

Kansas Statehouse in Topeka, February 2014.

Kansas Statehouse in Topeka, February 2014.

February 22, 2018


— Kansas can't cut Medicaid funds to a Planned Parenthood affiliate over videos anti-abortion activists secretly recorded in 2015, a federal appeals court ruled Wednesday.

The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals' decision leaves in place a lower court's preliminary injunction that blocked Kansas from ending the contract. It is the fifth of six circuits to uphold the right of patients to receive health care from their preferred qualified provider.

The decision applies to Kansas' Medicaid contract with Planned Parenthood Great Plains, which has two health centers in Kansas and three in Missouri. However, the appeals panel sent back to the lower court a related injunction involving the state's effort to terminate its contract with Planned Parenthood of the St. Louis Region, which serves some Kansas patients at its clinic in Joplin, Missouri.

Planned Parenthood Great Plains in an emailed statement called the appeals court's decision a "huge win" for Kansas Medicaid patients who know and trust it as their health care provider, saying the state's termination of its contract was "baseless and politically motivated."

"The 10th Circuit's decision sends a strong message that state officials should not play politics with Medicaid — or the health care and wellbeing of Kansans," said Dr. Brandon Hill, the group's president and CEO.

Gov. Jeff Colyer's spokesman, Kendall Marr, said in an email that the state is studying the 10th Circuit decision and considering further legal options.

"We will continue the fight for life," Marr said.

Planned Parenthood provides health exams, contraception services, cancer screenings, and testing for sexually transmitted diseases, the court said, adding that while some of its clinics offer abortions, Medicaid seldom pays for those.

U.S. District Judge Julie Robinson in Kansas City, Kansas, issued the temporary ruling in July 2016 in a lawsuit filed by what was then called Planned Parenthood of Kansas and Mid-Missouri and the organization's St. Louis regional affiliate. Robinson wrote that Medicaid patients have "the explicit right to seek family planning services from the qualified provider of their choice."

In July 2015, the anti-abortion group Center for Medical Progress released a series of edited videos purportedly depicting Planned Parenthood of America executives talking about the sale of fetal tissue.

Based on that, Kansas began investigating the affiliates in Kansas. The Kansas Board of Healing Arts determined in 2016 that after review of the investigative materials no further action would be taken. The Missouri attorney general investigated the affiliate in his state and also announced it found no evidence of wrongdoing.

Kansas already has blocked Planned Parenthood from receiving federal family planning dollars for non-abortion services in the state. The affiliate provides both surgical and medication abortions at its clinic in Overland Park, in far eastern Kansas near Kansas City, Missouri. It provides medication abortions at its Wichita clinic.

Federal courts have blocked attempts by other states to cut off Medicaid funding for Planned Parenthood, including Arkansas, Arizona, Indiana, Louisiana and Utah.


Dale Miller 2 months, 4 weeks ago

Having rogue courts irresponsibly rule and carry the water for liberal organizations who dishonestly hide their true agendas needs to stop. Our court system interference in the matters such as Planned Parenthood demonstrate just how broken that branch truly is.

Alex Landazuri 2 months, 4 weeks ago

pretty sure there was a whole witch hunt by the federal government last year that found no wrong doing. during that same witch hunt they used data that was so wrong that even the head of the hunt had to apologize for it. so you may need to re evaluate your facts.

Greg Cooper 2 months, 4 weeks ago

"Having rogue courts irresponsibly rule and carry the water for liberal organizations who dishonestly hide their true agendas needs to stop."

Yep, and when we find a "rogue court" doing that, we all will rise up in anger. There's huge difference between an "agenda" and following the law. Maybe you should research a bit, Dale, and then return with a comment that addresses the law rather than your preconceived notions of what the law says.

Dale Miller 2 months, 4 weeks ago

Greg, I've seen first hand how our courts cherry pick the laws they want to enforce as well as they don't. I'll start doing research when the other side displays ethics. Until then.....

Greg Cooper 2 months, 4 weeks ago

I get it: continue following wrong-headed actions until the "other side" changes, even if you can't really tell what they're doing wrong. That makes complete sense. So, everybody can just do what they like forever and ever. Makes perfect sense to me.

And, to follow up on your first-hand evidence, would you please cite some specifics as to what laws were ignored by the courts? I'd be really interested in seeing that. I'll hold my breath.

Dale Miller 2 months, 4 weeks ago

Don't like it done to you, we don't like it done to us.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.