Archive for Saturday, November 22, 2014

Kansas prisons grapple with ‘dangerous’ staffing shortages

November 22, 2014


— During an incident in June, 10 prison guards at the Lansing Correctional Facility were injured when they were physically attacked by inmates. One reportedly had a small chunk of his forehead bitten off by an inmate.

In another incident at the Hutchinson Correctional Facility, a guard was stabbed 13 times with a plastic shank. One wound was so severe that it punctured one of the guard's lungs.

Rebecca Proctor, interim director of the Kansas Association of State Employees, told a legislative committee last week that those are just a few examples of how state correctional officers are being put at risk because of critical staffing shortages in state prisons, shortages that she said are the direct result of low wages and poor working conditions.

"All Kansas adult correctional facilities are operating short-staffed," Proctor told the committee. She said job vacancy rates in state prisons range from 10 to 20 percent at every facility.

"Recently at Topeka Correctional Facility (which houses female inmates), employees were told the facility would have no choice but to require workers to stay over for a second full shift - 16 hours on duty - because there was no one to relieve them," Proctor said.

Department of Corrections spokesman Jeremy Barclay said the officers involved in incidents at Lansing and Hutchinson have chosen not to speak to the media about them. But he confirmed that job vacancy rates in the state prison system range from 10 to 15 percent at each facility, and he said low wages and dangerous working conditions are a big part of the problem.

"Being a correctional officer is a difficult and challenging job," he said. "We can’t hire just anybody for the job. Every day, they face the challenge of working with inmates who’ve been deemed fit to be incarcerated for felony crimes, and the inmates do not have the best behaviors."

Low wages, high competition

Proctor testified last week before the Joint Committee on Pensions, Investments and Benefits, which may consider legislation to standardize the pension benefits of Corrections Department employees.

But she said that before lawmakers look at pension benefits, they should first address the issue of wages, which she said are so low, few correctional officers stay in the system long enough to earn retirement benefits.

"Improving retirement benefits for correctional officers is a great goal, but retirement benefits are meaningless if employees cannot be retained on the job long enough to earn those benefits," she said.

That's especially true for officers at the state prison in Lansing, which is just a few miles away from a federal prison where the minimum starting pay is more than $39,000 a year, and can be as high as $51,702, depending on experience.

By comparison, the starting pay for a state correctional officer is $13.61 an hour, or about $28,000 a year.

"Many employees stay at Lansing long enough to gain some experience and training, and then make the move to the federal facility," she said.

Proctor said the state also competes with county jails for employees because many of the jails also pay more than the state.

In Douglas County, for example, the starting pay for a jail officer is $15.19 per hour, or $31,595 per year, nearly 12 percent more than the state's starting pay.

Proctor cited examples of correctional officers who struggle to make it from paycheck to paycheck. She said some have reported sleeping in their cars the last night or two before payday because they can't afford the gas to commute to work. Others reported skipping meals at the end of a pay period to make sure their children have enough to eat.

Proctor said the Department of Corrections faces other funding issues that also put the safety of officers at risk.

"At many facilities, the radios don't work," she said. "Employees patrol and transport inmates in vehicles that are too old and run-down to be safely maintained. There are not enough anti-stab and anti-ballistic vests at the facilities. At Hutchinson, costs for uniform parts and utility belts have been shifted to employees."

KPERS and budget issues

Proctor's testimony sparked a sharp response from Sen. Ty Masterson, R-Andover, who also chairs the Senate Ways and Means Committee. He suggested that if corrections officers want more pay, they may have to give up something in the form of retirement benefits.

"I think there’s some universal acceptance that we need to be paying our correctional officers more," Masterson said. "I think where we hit an impasse with an organization like yours is there is an expense to a taxpayer-insured retirement system which creates a difficulty on the other side of that."

He suggested that if the officers want more pay, they should consider volunteering to become unclassified employees, which would mean giving up their civil service protection, and then joining a new kind of retirement plan being launched next year that requires a smaller contribution from the state.

Proctor said she did not think most members of her union would accept that tradeoff, at which point Masterson questioned whether she actually represented the union members.

"You don’t represent the individuals. You represent an organization," Masterson said.

"I represent a member-driven organization," Proctor replied.

"But you would imply that they’re monolithic in their thought process," Masterson shot back.

"I would say that we go with the will of the majority," Proctor said, "so we did survey on this issue. And we have surveyed on the classified (versus) unclassified issue. And by and large, employees tell us they need the protections of the classified system."

Meanwhile, Department of Corrections officials said they would just like to see some kind of "parity" in retirement benefits for the different classes of employees in that agency.

Correctional officers in adult prisons are now part of a special class within the Kansas Public Employees Retirement System. They make slightly larger contributions out of their paychecks but are allowed to retire earlier than other KPERS members because the nature of their jobs tends to shorten their careers.

But parole officers and guards in the juvenile corrections system are part of the regular KPERS plan.

For years, many have suggested that correctional officers ought to be part of the separate Kansas Police and Firefighters pension system, which allows even earlier retirement but requires higher contributions from employees.

But Proctor said given the low wages currently being paid, most officers could not afford the higher contributions for the KPF system, even if it meant getting better retirement benefits.


John Sickels 3 years, 6 months ago

Dave Trabert? Where is Dave Trabert? You are falling down on the job Dave Trabert!!

What is the KPI plan for improving working conditions and pay for guards?

Oh, I imagine it involves privatizing prisons somehow, turning the inmates into an unpaid labor force for Koch Industries or something along those lines.

James Howlette 3 years, 6 months ago

Privatizing prisons is exactly where it will go.

Brock Masters 3 years, 6 months ago

Keep in mind this is a chronic problem, not one created by this administration. It is, regardless of whoever is responsible, one that needs to be corrected.

We have a responsibility to ensure safe working conditions for the correctional staff.

And, as I and other conservatives have said, wages should be dictated by the market, not a government mandate. Well here is a perfect ofexample of where the market is demanding higher wages. Brownback and the legislature need to establish a wage that will attract and retain correctional officers to provide a safe work environment for them.

Dick Sengpiehl 3 years, 6 months ago

Fred, how do you think Brownback and his administration can "establish a wage" as you say. Because of his tax policy it certainly looks like some cuts are in order. Do you REALLY think this particular need will be filled before other priorities?

Brock Masters 3 years, 6 months ago

No, I don't think Brownback will fix this problem. As you pointed out there is a revenue shortfall making it difficult if not possible to increase wages.

Just because I said they need to do it doesn't mean they will.

Dorothy Hoyt-Reed 3 years, 6 months ago

Not according to Ty Masterson, conservative. And not according to Merrick. They are state employees so they don't produce anything.

Brock Masters 3 years, 6 months ago

True in bothe public and private sectors.

Brock Masters 3 years, 6 months ago

Eileen, gotta call BS on your statement that the KS budget shortfall is projected to be in the billions in the next couple of years. I follow this stuff and have not seen it projected to be in the billions. Nearly a billion, but not billions.

Cite your source please.

John Sickels 3 years, 6 months ago

Quite reasonable Fred. You are right. The market is definitely showing that pay for the guards is too low.

But Brownback and the legislature are not interested in what the market is saying. They listen to their ideology, not facts.

If they listened to the market (two credit downgrades, large businesses like Boeing leaving the state) they wouldn't be considering massive spending cuts and keeping their stupid tax cuts.

Andy Anderson 3 years, 6 months ago

Bear in mind.

Lawrence public government schools trains the human-

Government people release the human into the wild-

Demands new library to entertain the released human-

Government people infuse the Nation with millions of poor felons from other countries.

Demands new Police station to control the poorly trained human, poor felon from other countries-

Demands bigger prison for those humans caught-

People in government make these demands under the meme of fear. Doom and gloom.

Sycophant's of the government people use code words to enhance doom and gloom. Brownback's fault. Bush. Koch. Alec. Racism. Bigot. Fracking. Earthquake. Kobach. Rock Chalk Park.

The bottom line of this article. Government demands more guards/staffing to oversee humans in prison, or there will be trouble

Paul R Getto 3 years, 6 months ago

A harbinger of things to come. Government don't need no stinking employees!

Phillip Chappuie 3 years, 6 months ago

I might suggest the Ty Masterson, R Andover, go up to El Dorado and work a few shifts with the fellows. He could gain some insight after he wet himself.

Pamela Shanks 3 years, 6 months ago

I agree that Senator Masterson would gain a lot of insight on the difficulties guards experience if he participated as an observer. I know someone who quit Lansing in May to take a lower paying job with promise of future pay raises because he felt unsafe and stressed by the daily working conditions. And as it turns out he was right. The June 10 incident was very scary for all involved.

Leslie Swearingen 3 years, 6 months ago

I am surprised they can find anyone to work there.

William Cummings 3 years, 6 months ago

Thirty three years ago this month, corrections officers at Lansing Correctional Facility [then known as Kansas State Penitentiary] staged a walkout over issues of bad prison security and poor pay. During the months leading up to the action, a corrections officer was murdered; another was stabbed; and there was an escape involving seven inmates from the maximum security perimeter, and which resulted in the serious wounding of a law enforcement officer.

In the In the months following the walkout, the state did end up making some sorely needed improvements, including adjustments to pay and benefits.

Our elected officials should right now be taking a more serious look at providing an appropriate level of funding for this vital element of the criminal justice system, rather than waiting until the threat to staff lives and to public safety in general becomes even worse. Solving this problem will not get less expensive by putting off dealing with it.

Joe Blackford II 3 years, 6 months ago

Another hit from Sam The Sham & The SayNOs, RayR's "Faith-based Ministry Prison Warden Blues."

Look for the Sham's subliminally epic LP "I Shot The Adrenaline," from Chuck & Dave K's PAYOLA RECORDS, at your local Alco store.


Hmmmmm, how much will those newly unemployed Alco employees contribute to Sham's experiment?

Commenting has been disabled for this item.