Archive for Wednesday, September 18, 2013

Education commissioner to respond to Kansas GOP resolution on Common Core standards

September 18, 2013


— Kansas Education Commissioner Diane DeBacker plans to send what she described as a “friendly” letter to the state Republican Party this week, correcting what she and other education leaders are calling misinformation that the party is circulating about the Common Core standards for reading and math.

That letter will be in response to a resolution that the Kansas GOP state committee adopted last weekend calling for Kansas to withdraw from the Common Core Standards.

“We saw the resolution about education in Kansas,” DeBacker said following today's State Board of Education meeting, where that resolution was a major topic of discussion. “We'll try to clear up some of the myths and some of the false information. But really it will be to say let's sit down and talk about this.”

The standards were initiated by the National Governors Association and the Council of Chief State School officers. They have been adopted in 45 states and the District of Columbia, and are intended to raise academic expectations so students will be prepared for either college or the workforce by the time they graduate high school.

The resolution, however, says that the Common Core “implicates the states in an unconstitutional and illegal transfer of power to the federal government and unaccountable private interests.”

It also says they were adopted in Kansas “without meaningful input from” Kansas parents, teachers and other taxpayers.”

“That's absolutely not the case,” DeBacker said.

The resolution also asserts that the new state tests that go along with the standards, known as the Smarter Balanced assessments, will impose “burdensome new testing requirements,” and that they will require “collection and sharing of massive amounts of personal student data.”

DeBacker said the state board adopted the standards in 2010 after more than two years of public discussion, including input from Kansas teachers. She also said students will be tested the same number of times as they are now, and that there will be no more data collected about students than what the state collects already.

State GOP Chairman Kelly Arnold said he wasn't familiar with all the details of the resolution. He said it was proposed by a number of state committee members and adopted by a vote of the state committee during a meeting last weekend.

“Personally, as a chairman, I'm continuing to talk to individuals from both sides of the issue to get a deeper understanding of the Common Core,” Arnold said. “It really just became a hot topic this last year.”

DeBacker said she would send the letter on behalf of the Department of Education. But the board itself, which is made up mostly of Republicans, many of whom support the Common Core standards, opted not to get involved in a political battle with the state party.

“To me, it's a political thing. I'm part of the Republican Party,” said board Vice Chairwoman Sally Cauble, of Liberal. “I'm kind of having trouble with how they even voted on this.”

Board member Deena Horst, a former Republican state legislator from Salina, agreed.

“I'm perfectly fine with the department addressing the misconceptions, and I just think they need to be addressed,” Horst said. “I think politically, there's a division we all know about, and that's what this is.”

Education news
Have a story idea?
Contact Journal-World education reporter Elliot Hughes:


weeslicket 4 years, 9 months ago

from the article: State GOP Chairman Kelly Arnold said he wasn't familiar with all the details of the resolution. He said it was proposed by a number of state committee members and adopted by a vote of the state committee during a meeting last weekend.


Shelley Bock 4 years, 9 months ago

Bottom line is that the Republican hierarchy has no idea what the objections are, except it is "best" to follow what more radical right wingers want. Common core academics have been in place for at least 2 years in some districts. Where have the Tea Party radicals been?

The Republicans are letting the tail wag the dog of their party. They are surely alienating moderates and clear thinking Republicans from the party. Maintain Tea Party purification of the Republicans and their actions are going to improve America, but not in the way intended.

Centerville 4 years, 9 months ago

Bottom line: if you have children in a school that's subscribing to this, you can opt them out of the intrusive questionnaire. There's no reason for that info to be passed along to our education bureaucrats.

tomatogrower 4 years, 9 months ago

Too late. They have been collecting that data for years. When you enroll your kids, you can choose to answer the questions or not, but it's nothing new. Who do you believe. Some Tea Party person who admits they have never entered a school or looked at the curriculum, but read on the internet that it's bad, or someone who has been working in education and working to implement the program?

optimist 4 years, 9 months ago

Simple answer is neither. Both are prone to their own bias. All should take the time to educate themselves and make up their own minds. There is entirely too much follow the leader going on with regard to political issues. Both sides rely on hyperbole, misinformation and the ignorance of the general populous in order to manipulate the political landscape. The solutions are to educate yourself and for the government to stop interfering with choice in education.

chootspa 4 years, 9 months ago

The government doesn't interfere with choice in education. You're free to homeschool, private school, or parochial school to your heart's content. That doesn't mean you get taxpayer money to do so.

That's not interference. If you want interference, start taking taxpayer money. Then Uncle Sam will have to check up on you and impose standards.

chootspa 4 years, 9 months ago

Except that there's not any intrusive questionnaire. That's a fabrication from the tin foil hat brigade. There's just subject matter testing, same as there was under the old system.

Tyler Palmer 4 years, 9 months ago

Frankly, the opposition to Common Core is stupid. We keep hearing that these folks are tired of the federal government trying to control education which is simply ignorant, since this is a multi-state coalition effort, not a federal government project. Our elected state officials continue to do their constituents a huge disservice by failing to correct misinformation and educate people that come to them in opposition that have clearly been mislead about issues. Our elected state officials have a responsibility to educate themselves and the public on the facts, rather than regurgitating what ALEC and other corporate legislative interference organizations that are pushing ideological propaganda instead of fact-based information give them.

IreneAdler84 4 years, 9 months ago

I find it interesting that none of the objections are about the actual standards, or educational merits of the standards. It's all hair on fire "here come the revenuers, Martha!"

Thomas Bryce Jr. 4 years, 9 months ago

It is no wonder our Legislature is against Education. Look How well it has worked out for them.

Paul R Getto 4 years, 9 months ago

Give 'em Hell, Diane. You are fencing with clowns. Shove them back in the car, voters, and dismiss them from the circus ring in 2014. The standards are not the real issue. This is another Republican Unicorn like voter fraud, guns, gods and gays. Keep the SHEEPLE scared.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.