Archive for Thursday, July 4, 2013

Egypt’s second revolution in two years touches KU faculty, students with ties to the country

July 4, 2013


Opponents of Egypt's ousted president Mohammed Morsi wave national flags and posters of Lt. Gen. Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi during a rally in Tahrir Square, in Cairo, Egypt, Friday, July 5, 2013. Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood called for a wave of protests Friday, furious over the military's ouster of its president and arrest of its revered leader and other top figures, raising fears of violence and retaliation from Islamic militants.(AP Photo/Amr Nabil)

Opponents of Egypt's ousted president Mohammed Morsi wave national flags and posters of Lt. Gen. Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi during a rally in Tahrir Square, in Cairo, Egypt, Friday, July 5, 2013. Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood called for a wave of protests Friday, furious over the military's ouster of its president and arrest of its revered leader and other top figures, raising fears of violence and retaliation from Islamic militants.(AP Photo/Amr Nabil)

Amid massive riots in Egypt and the second forcible ouster of a president there in less than two years, Kansas University graduate instructor Marwa Ghazali is having trouble researching her doctoral thesis.

Ghazali flew to Egypt last month to spend her summer studying a subculture living in Cairo graveyards for her Ph.D. in anthropology, but her efforts were thwarted this past Sunday— exactly one year to the day since Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi took office — when thousands of protesters took to the streets demanding the president’s resignation. After days of rioting, Morsi was removed from office by the military Wednesday night, and Adly Mansour, head of Egypt’s Constitutional Court, was sworn in as interim president.

Given all the tumult surrounding her, Ghazali—who was born in Kansas but whose family is Egyptian—has put her research on the back burner to witness the revolution’s developments unfold.

The protests are reminiscent of the “Arab Spring” of January 2011, when the world watched as Egyptians gathered in Tahrir Square — Arabic for “Liberation Square” — to ultimately oust then-President Hosni Mubarak. Eighteen months later, despite a new constitution and the country’s first democratic election, the protests returned.

The upheaval in Egypt is touching Ghazali and other KU students and faculty with Egyptian ties. Some, like Ghazali, have found themselves caught in the middle of the uprisings while visiting Egypt this summer; others are watching their home country with concern from a distance.

"Egypt is still in the middle of its revolution to establish a democratic state and if the people here have shown anything it is that they have agency," said KU professor of Religious Studies Jacquelene Brinton, who also has been in Egypt during the past week's protests. "They take to the streets to protest when they believe their country is headed in the wrong direction."

Diverse protesters, common complaints

Ghazali says while anti-Morsi protesters are rioting for a common cause, they are diverse in nature.

“There are three major groups in the protests, all with a different vision of democracy” Ghazali said, “Some never liked Morsi to begin with, while others voted for Morsi, but have not seen improvements in their lives since he came to power. ... The other group, known as 'secular forces,' are opposed to the Morsi’s Islamist party.”

Rather than going to opposition protests in Tahrir, Ghazali says she has been getting to know pro-Morsi Egyptians at protests at Rab’a Al-Adawiyya, where the anti-revolution forces are camped out. “It’s definitely given me a more balanced perspective,” Ghazali said. “You rarely hear their stories in the news.”

Like the United States, Egypt holds a presidential election every four years. Morsi was the 2012 presidential candidate for the Freedom and Justice Party, an Islamist political party with ties to the country’s largest political group, the Muslim Brotherhood. He won Egypt’s first democratic election in the wake of the 2011 revolution with 51.7 percent of the vote.

Many pro-Morsi protesters support of Morsi’s Islamist politics, but Ghazali says there are others who did not vote for Morsi and are not Islamist supporters, but understand the danger of overthrowing another president.

“I talked to one woman (at the counter protests) I noticed was not wearing a scarf,” Ghazali said. “Though she was not a Muslim and did not vote for Morsi, she supported him because if this is supposed to be a democratic process, Morsi should have three more years until the next election.”

Though Morsi was elected democratically, many Egyptians, such as KU student Marwan Ahmed, have distaste for the way Morsi’s administration has conducted itself over its year in leadership. While Ahmed has not been in Egypt among the protesters, he says the second Egypt revolution in just over two years was necessary.

“I would like to think of the current events as a continuation of the January 25 (2011) revolution,” Ahmed said in an interview from Dubai, where he's spending summer break. “They had to be overthrown as they destroyed the image of Islam, and the president is nowhere near qualified to control a whole country.”

Frustration boils over

After a year without witnessing change in the impoverished conditions of Egypt, Ghazali says anti-Morsi protesters' frustration has boiled over.

Ghazali says Egyptians view the president as the figurehead of the country and when things do not go well, he is the one held accountable. For example, Ghazali was in a taxicab when she saw a long line of drivers backed up and pushing their cars to a gas station.

“People were cursing Morsi for the lack of fuel," Ghazali said. "I asked my cab driver what Morsi had done to cause the problem and he said, ‘The father is expected to provide food for his family. People see Morsi as Egypt’s father, and he is not providing for his people.’”

Brinton says Ghazali's story reflects a common sentiment among protesters.

"What precipitated the ousting of Morsi was the dissatisfaction of the people. Life has gotten more difficult for so many. Prices are rising, jobs and fuel are getting scarcer and security is lacking, so crime rates have risen," Brinton said. "Is all of this Morsi's fault? Probably not. But he never addressed these problems in terms of how he hoped to change the situation."

Ahmed, while not directly affected by the day-to-day challenges of the unkempt Cairo streets, says he is still glad to see Morsi go.

“Unfortunately, a group that uses religion in a wrong way to control Egypt has reached this far in the previous elections,” Ahmed said. “They claimed that they would use religion the right way to control the country — and they attracted attention and won the elections — but after a year, it was apparent that the president himself is a hypocrite.”

As the nation faces its second tumultuous transition in just over two years, Ghazali says Egyptians have not yet had an example of what it is to be a democracy.

“Some have equated the word ‘democracy’ with the right to overthrow a government,” Ghazali said. “We should not throw a revolution every time we don't agree with a president. We cannot have a ‘historic moment’ every year.”


George_Braziller 4 years, 9 months ago

This comment was removed by the site staff for violation of the usage agreement.

jhawkinsf 4 years, 9 months ago

You sure do provide some interesting links. However, you should provide a disclaimer, something along the line that readers should wear their tin foil hats prior to reading. Or at least watch that commercial on T.V., you know the one, where the woman says "you can't put anything on the internet that isn't true". Where did you read that? "On the internet".

Anyway, thanks for the chuckle.

jhawkinsf 4 years, 9 months ago

"The President ordered 15,000 Russian troops ... " To do what, invade Mars?

Any statement that begins "the President (of the U.S.) orders 15,000 Russian troops" is foolish on it's face.

jhawkinsf 4 years, 9 months ago

Pheps, I suggest you google your source, European Union Times and read the critiques by others of your source. I'll save you the trouble, it's called racist, skinhead, BS, etc. It's specifically called "not a news source". Do you have any credible sources, or will you hold firm to something that is nothing more than a blog from discredited sources?

Steve Jacob 4 years, 9 months ago

This was not a revolution, this was a coup. What is the point of elections if you arrest all the winners a year later. Now the Muslim Brotherhood will not be allowed any say in a new government and civil war may happen. Kind of like the Taliban in Afghanistan.

Lisa Medsker 4 years, 9 months ago

Is it just me, or is it indicative of extreme Narcissism that people believe the unrest in other countries has anything to do with whom is the President of ours?

AverageCitizen 4 years, 9 months ago

I am split over the Egyptian uprising. On one hand, the rule of law and the democratic process allows for a governed people to vote out those that are not doing a good job. It establishes a way for citizens to live peacefully. On the other hand, a government that starts messing with the courts, free speech, and cutting out participation of large chunks of their people is a dangerous administration. What if the people had started a coup to oust Hitler earlier in his grab for power? By the time people recognized what he was doing Hitler had TOTAL control. Sometimes it’s too late to do anything after a leader has dismantled the countries entire infrastructure of government. Morsy could have decided to suspend presidential elections in the future after he had an iron grip on the country and it would have changed into something other than a democracy no matter how it started out. Perhaps the people had already decided that was the case since Morsy reneged on many of his promises. We can’t just wholly transplant our western democracy to another country. Our beginnings were just different and Egypt has to find a way for itself.

Jean Robart 4 years, 9 months ago

"They take to the streets to protest when they believe their country is headed in the wrong direction." Maybe we should take the same action?

verity 4 years, 9 months ago

We did/have done so. Remember when Bush 43 wanted to start the war with Iraq---and after the war was started? The U.S. media (liberal indeed) pretty much ignored the marches/protests. One had to go to sources like the BBC to find out about them. I took to the streets, as did many others. Maybe things have to get a lot worse (i.e. Vietnam War with a draft) before we get out of our comfortable existence and do something.

Leslie Swearingen 4 years, 9 months ago

I do remember doing that very thing during the Vietnam War. LBJ was president and we chanted, "hey, hey, LBJ, how many kids have you killed today?" He decided not to run for another term. Nixon ended that war after we chased the Viet Cong until they caught us. Every bit of that war was on the nightly news and it was horrible. Now we have no such knowledge of the war in Afghanistan and what really goes on.

Use of drones makes us forget that war is still up close and personal for those on the ground, it is not just another video game.

verity 4 years, 9 months ago

Interesting. Apparently at least four people liked your comment that you didn't make.

Odd goings on here at the LJW.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.