Archive for Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Editorial: Struggling campaign

United Way of Douglas County needs some additional help to meet its annual fundraising goal.

December 11, 2012


The United Way of Douglas County has sounded an alarm that it is only about halfway toward this year’s ambitious goal of $1.8 million, in an annual campaign that was to have ended Friday.

Organization and campaign officials concede that it is unusual for the effort to find itself so short of the mark, with only about $925,000 in hand, at this stage of the yearly drive. Most county residents probably assumed the campaign would meet its goal — as usual.

The 29 social service agencies that rely on the umbrella organization’s fundraising efforts for their support obviously are at risk. Some might suggest that the United Way itself may be also, if agencies ultimately were to adopt an every-man-for-himself attitude in order to campaign for their own operating funds. Such an eventuality would be detrimental to the agencies in the long run and to the communities in the county.

The organization has said it will continue to accept contributions past the campaign’s deadline in an effort to meet the goal, although they acknowledge that it’s unlikely they’ll match even the $1.7 million that was raised in 2011.

Several possible circumstances are considered as likely influences on the results to date. One has to be the general economic situation across the country. Unemployment and layoffs continue to affect Douglas County, with unusual buyouts at Kansas University providing just one key local signal of the national doldrums.

A second influence may relate somehow to the presidential election cycle. United Way leaders noted that the last time the drive fell short of goal was in the year of a presidential election.

A third, United Way officials acknowledge, could be concern or skepticism about changes and restructuring in how it now is allocating funds. The organization created three broad community goals (education, self-sufficiency and health care) and required participating agencies to show how their mission relates to at least one. That changed the allocation of funds, caused budget problems for some agencies, and may have upset some donors as well.

It’s difficult to measure the success of those changes after a single year, but United Way officials report they’ve already seen good early results in programs that received targeted funding to help boost student achievement. In the self-sufficiency area, a plan has been developed to improve coordination among several local food pantries by placing their management under a single agency. A 2012 United Way grant also allowed Health Care Access and the Douglas County AIDS Project to co-locate to better serve community needs in a more cost-effective way.

Only the United Way leaders themselves can evaluate the strategy, leadership and effectiveness of this year’s campaign, compared with previous efforts. If they determine that internal changes have affected annual giving, leaders need to step up to better explain their strategy or consider further changes.

Regardless, the community needs to recognize, with additional financial support, the value and importance of a unified fundraising campaign for essential social service agencies that face greater demands year after year.

It’s not too late to give; it’s never too late to support worthwhile agencies that serve our community well.


toe 1 year, 3 months ago

The United Way is no longer a viable system. The United Way was an intermediary created when information was difficult and unreliable. This was a good idea at the time, but as politics and employers merged to turn the United Way into a quasi-government entity, the idea fell on hard times. Employers have done incalculable damage to the United Way by forcing employees to give both their treasure and their time. If you gave to you church or to an organization directly, you were singled out for a talk. Team players are rewarded. Self thinkers and doers were punished. I will work the rest of my life to encourage direct giving in talent, treasure, and time. I believe strongly in sharing and community caring. Give with no strings attached, but give directly to those in need. To those still giving to the United Way. You are indeed helping, but you can do much much better. If you did not give because you were disappointed in the United Way. Give directly and do not delay.


Patricia Davis 1 year, 4 months ago

After a career in not for profit fund development, I say give directly to charities that do good work and that mean something to you. Cut the overhead, the angst about such United Way charities such as Boy Scouts of America and give local and directly.


Slowponder 1 year, 4 months ago

Two reasons for the diminished results.

First, the change in the United Way's policy of rather than supporting many organizations and concentrating on a particular area with a different area each year was a decision reached without any input from contributors. From this contributor's perspective, does anyone know of a succinct way to say, "Dumb idea."

Second, as a consistent supporter of the United Way, I just got my request for support last week. If you don't ask for support in the early Fall, it is logical that the total number of support is going to be down when reported in December.

What a way to run a railroad!


George_Braziller 1 year, 4 months ago

The organization I worked for turned down a request from United Way to apply for funds. We had received a small amount from them the previous year and it wasn't worth all of the strings attached to it. The statistics and data we were already collecting for federal and state funds weren't sufficient, they wanted us to collect entirely different number just for them.

It cost us more in staff time to meet their special requirements than the amount of we received so WE dumped THEM.


demonfury 1 year, 4 months ago

I think people are finally being educated on the reality that the United Way is predominately a politically run organization, rather than a charitable organization. If you do the research, you will find, as I imagine many former contributors have, that a very small percentage of your donation actually goes to the social services that the United Way claims to support. In fact, I've found that of every dollar they receive, approx. 80% of that dollar never sees a social program. It gets used to support the United Way, so that they can continue to raise money for these social programs. Also if you look at the payroll of the United Way's corporate management, (and this is why it's run like a wall street corp.), you will find that some of them actually make more annual salary than the President of the United States. Makes you wonder where the charitable priority is, huh? If you want to do the most good with your charitable dollar, give it to the Salvation Army.. Their public records show that over 85% of every dollar goes to the social programs they support. I know where my contribution is going this year.


Gandalf 1 year, 4 months ago

If you think things are bad now, wait until evilsam and his minions get rid of the charitable deduction credit.


Commenting has been disabled for this item.