Archive for Friday, September 23, 2011

Calif. bill would allow minors to seek STD prevention without parental consent

September 23, 2011


— Heated debate in the Republican presidential race over child vaccinations also is playing out in California as Democratic Gov. Jerry Brown considers whether to a sign a bill allowing children as young as 12 to get vaccinated against sexually transmitted diseases without their parents’ consent.

Religious leaders, pro-family organizations and GOP lawmakers have warned the change would erode the rights of parents to be involved in their children’s medical decisions. Supporters say the legislation is needed to keep up with new prevention treatments and help slow the spread of STDs among minors.

The bill passed the California Legislature along mostly party lines and now is on Brown’s desk. He has until Oct. 9 to act on AB499, and has not signaled his intent.

Currently, California minors are allowed to seek diagnosis and treatment for STDs such as the human papillomavirus, known as HPV, without parental consent but cannot get vaccinated without their parents’ approval. HPV is the leading cause of cervical cancer.

“I don’t think we should be playing Russian roulette with kids’ lives,” said Assemblywoman Toni Atkins, a Democrat from San Diego who authored the legislation.

Opponents say the push for inoculation by medical officers and women’s health advocates tramples on parents’ rights. Just as minors cannot get a tattoo or piercing without parental approval under California law, opponents say parents should be involved in a child’s medical care, whether it’s treatment for a migraine or sexually transmitted disease.

“Our children need the knowledge and wisdom of their parents in order to make complicated medical decisions,” wrote Los Angeles Archbishop Jose Gomez in an online newsletter. “This legislation would leave our children to make these decisions without the benefit of their parents’ wisdom.”

Although the California bill was introduced back in February, vaccinating minors became a hot national topic recently when Republican presidential candidate Michele Bachmann attacked Texas Gov. Rick Perry for issuing a 2007 executive order mandating the HPV vaccine for young girls.

That mandate was overturned by Texas lawmakers, but Perry said during a GOP debate that supporting the vaccinations means supporting life.

HPV is the most common sexually transmitted disease. According to the bill’s author, HPV has become the world’s second leading cause of cancer deaths among women. It was blamed for more than 400 deaths in California in 2008, the latest year for which statistics are available.

Two vaccines are available. One is licensed as Gardasil by Merck and the other is Cervarix, manufactured by GlaxoSmithKline. They are most effective if given before a person becomes sexually active.

If Brown signs into law, minors also would be able to get other STD prevention treatments, including new medicines that help prevent HIV infection if given within 72 hours of exposure.


jhawkinsf 2 years, 6 months ago

One of the assumptions we make as a society is that the parent is the person best able to make decisions for their children. Certainly there are exceptions. But in general, the parent needs all the tools at their disposal to make good decisions for their children. Information is the greatest tool I can think of. Children getting medical treatment is something all parents should know about, with only those rare exceptions where courts may rule that it's not in the child's best interest. Getting treated for an STD, or any other medical procedure is part of the issue. Prevention of further dangers should also be included. How can any parent prevent what they are not informed of? If it were my 12 year old, yes, I would want him/her treated. But I would also need to know how this came to be so that I can prevent it from happening again.


its_just_math 2 years, 6 months ago

"Religious leaders, pro-family organizations and GOP lawmakers have warned the change would erode the rights of parents to be involved in their children’s medical decisions."

Those dratted darned pesky conservative nutcases! How dare they deny the gubment more power.


ljwhirled 2 years, 6 months ago

The primary roll of government, as seen by the Thomas Jefferson and his Republican allies, is to protect the rights of the individual.


ljwhirled 2 years, 6 months ago

Everyone has a RIGHT to protect themselves from diseases (and violence) regardless of age.

It is a natural right and is not given by man. The right to self defense is even recognized in animals.

According to Amnesty International there are 2,500 individuals in the United States serving sentences of life without parole for crimes committed when they were under 18.

Old enough to serve life without parole, old enough to get medical advice and intervention to prevent disease.


Reta Cosby 2 years, 6 months ago

Twelve year olds can get STDs, but can't drive, get license, buy cigarettes or liquor, and must go to school. Something's terribly wrong with this picture. Check the authorities over these kids to see who's putting them in jeopardy of contracting these diseases. Twelve years old?! Come on now! If kids this young are getting STDs, Child Welfare need to be part of the Budget Cuts.


Commenting has been disabled for this item.