Archive for Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Another bad year for BCS

November 22, 2011


Over at the Bowl Championship Series, the short answer to the question of when there will be a playoff in college football remains the same.


But get back in touch with the BCS next week, or better yet, with their sponsors after the Jan. 9 championship game and ask the question then.

For years now, playoff advocates have been drawing up nightmare scenarios that would shame the BCS out of business, but this season it’s practically guaranteed that the title game will leave fans unsatisfied.

Last week, four of the top seven teams in the BCS standings lost their footing and left an unprecedented three teams from the same division — the SEC West — holding down the top of the leaderboard.

Two of them, most likely current No. 1 LSU and No. 2 Alabama, figure to be on hand at the Superdome for the title game. But even if No. 3 Arkansas grabs one of those spots, the newly crowned BCS champion will seem more mythical than ever.

Remember, the BCS hijacked the postseason in 1998 with the promise of matching the No. 1 and No. 2 teams at the very end. And every time logic didn’t jibe with their rankings, the guys in charge “tweaked” the formula after the championship game and promised it wouldn’t happen again. You can argue over which school got jobbed the worst since then, but the two unofficial tweaks that matter here — a team must win its conference championship; the BCS finale shouldn’t be a rematch of a regular-season game — likely means it’s the fans who will feel cheated the most.

What makes this season even more aggravating is that the rankings are just about right. Arkansas ventures into Baton Rouge on Friday and if the Razorbacks pull off an upset and go on to beat SEC East entrant Georgia in the conference championship, they will have earned the trip to New Orleans. There are 14 one-loss teams in the mix at the moment, but few would deny that LSU — even if the Tigers lose to Arkansas — and Alabama would be the most deserving of the lot. The problem is that all three would have flaws we might be willing to overlook if they had to clear a path to that championship game on the field — it’s called a playoff — instead of relying on computer operators and best guesses to deposit them there. Now, there’s virtually no chance the winner gets the benefit of the doubt from the majority of fans.

Recent scandals at Southern California, Miami, Ohio State and Penn State have, at the very least, the whiff of corruption, not to mention what the NCAA terms a lack of institutional control. So how fitting is that the BCS, which has twisted itself into a pretzel countless times to hang onto the postseason franchise, could finally get called out by the fans for doing exactly what it was created to do?

It’s shaping up to be a bowl season that will be memorable for all the wrong reasons. Can’t wait to see how the BCS tries to tweak its way out of this one.


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.