Archive for Monday, June 6, 2011

Lawrence man gets 34 months for attempted robbery; judge emphasizes traumatic impact on victim

June 6, 2011


A Douglas County judge on Monday denied a 20-year-old Lawrence man’s request for probation and ordered him to serve 34 months in prison for a February attempted robbery in the Oread neighborhood.

“The next thing (the victim) knows, he’s lying on his back in the snow with a gun to his face. He did nothing to deserve that,” District Judge Sally Pokorny told Franklin Spottedtail, 20. “What you have taken from him is forever — his sense of peace and well-being. He’s going to feel like ‘this could happen to me again. I could be in danger.’ And that’s a terrible thing to take away from people.”

Spottedtail in April pleaded guilty to attempted aggravated robbery and obstruction. He was arrested early on Feb. 26, and prosecutors accused him of running up behind a 43-year-old man in the 1100 block of Tennessee Street and grabbing the man’s arms as a co-defendant, 18-year-old Clinton Vince Dubray, tried to hold up the man with a gun.

A Lawrence police officer interrupted the robbery as he drove into the area, and both men ran away before they were later arrested.

Dubray has pleaded no contest to the same charges and is scheduled to be sentenced later.

Spottedtail, his defense attorney, Hatem Chahine, and his parents on Monday had asked Pokorny to give him three years on probation as they mostly blamed his behavior on substance abuse. Chahine had asked for an aggressive substance abuse and mental health treatment programs to be part of his probation conditions.

“There’s not one day that has passed that I did not think about what I did,” Spottedtail said. “I’m not proud of myself.”

But prosecutors said alcohol did not seem to be a factor in the planning and failed execution of the robbery.

“I don’t know what treatment somebody can have to prevent them from committing this type of crime,” Assistant Douglas County District Attorney Michael Allen said.

Pokorny said she didn’t see evidence Spottedtail was intoxicated during the crime and said he had failed while serving on probation in past cases. She ordered him to serve 34 months in prison for the attempted aggravated robbery count and concurrently serve five months for the obstruction conviction.

He will be given credit for serving nearly two months in jail already.


Deb Engstrom 2 years, 10 months ago

Absolutely!! I know of very few young adults who go to prison and are able to turn it around on their own, particularly with substance abuse issues, no HS diploma and no work experience/skills. No wonder the recidivism rate is so high!!


Deb Engstrom 2 years, 10 months ago

Justice?? I'm not sure. He'll go to prison and fine-tune his criminal skills. No treatment or therapy so he'll return to Lawrence in 36 months as a better criminal, drug and alcohol abuser and unable to get gainful employment. His next "attempted" crime probably will be more than an attempt.


cletus26 2 years, 10 months ago

well i be... that is good news. and i hate when folks always try to blame substance abuse. the people doing this kind of stuff, know what they are doing. justice has prevailed!!


mutualrespect37 2 years, 10 months ago

Yeah? Why don't the freaking conflict-of-interest judges in Douglas County do something about the white collar criminals in the KU HR Department who use their dishonest bully pulpit to frame workers with false crimes by inventing witnesses and tampering with evidence.? This is felony misconduct, yet I was told by a local hillbilly lawyer if I wanted to press the matter I would need to stand trial.

Most people are used to more civilized internal grievance processes a work that don't criminalize protest by abusing in-house conflict-of-interest police power. KU is guilty as heck though, so they must think blaming the victim is the only way to avoid liability for mistreating people. It's a terrible lesson to take away from Lawrence that government and law enforcement in backwoods towns are that dirty,corrupt and incompetent and virtually run on lies--especially after the horribly abusive intrusive, illegal civil rights violations and character smears I was subjected to by the heavy-handed KU HR office.


UNIKU 2 years, 10 months ago

"Spottedtail, his defense attorney, Hatem Chahine, and his parents on Monday had asked Pokorny to give him three years on probation as they mostly blamed his behavior on substance abuse." What a cop out! This clown is probably blaming society for making him be a substance abuser. What a joke! He got what he deserved. And he's lucky the guy he assaulted wasn't packing or he'd have buckshot in his spottedtail.


Carrie Coffey 2 years, 10 months ago

Thank goodness, these kids just find a person and blast them with there fist and that person did nothing wrong! Hope they get what they deserve and serve lots of time to think about hurting innocent people again!


consumer1 2 years, 10 months ago

Yes!! Justice comes to Lawrence Kansas.


Commenting has been disabled for this item.