Oil-eating microbes possible spill solution

A plume of smoke from an oil burn is seen Saturday near the Discover Enterprise at the site of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico off the coast of Louisiana.

? One scientist compares them to the yellow chompers in the Pac-Man video game — hungry, single-minded little microbes fueled by the same fertilizer farmers use on soybeans, gobbling hydrocarbons from the oily waters, marshes and shores of the Gulf of Mexico.

Can the naturally occurring microbes help clean up the oil spill? Yes, experts say. At least in part, with some risk.

Officials are taking note. Florida Gov. Charlie Crist on Thursday visited a Sarasota company that sells microbes that eat oil. BP says it’s open to using them. And the federal government is contacting its pre-approved list of more than a dozen companies to see how quickly they can ramp up production.

Scientists call the process bioremediation.

“You take natural oil-eating microbes in the water and give them fertilizer to make them multiply and degrade the oil faster. Oil is a natural product. It’s inherently biodegradable,” said Terry Hazen, microbial ecologist in the Earth Sciences Division of the Lawrence Berkeley National Lab in California.

Oil-eating microbes are some of the smallest living things on earth, but they can have a powerful impact. They occur naturally in water and when they come in contact with oil, they eat it, producing the byproducts carbon dioxide and water. When fertilized with nitrogen and phosphorous, they grow in size and multiply and their appetites become prodigious.

Still, scientists caution that bioremediation is only a partial solution. It’s best used on sandy beaches and in salt marshes after the thickest oil has been removed by bulldozer and shovel. It’s never been tried before in deep water or open ocean.

And it runs some risk of damaging the very waters it’s meant to rescue. Some scientists say it may be better at times to let nature take its course.

Jay Grimes, a microbiologist at the University of Southern Mississippi, is a fan of the process: “It could help a lot. It was used in the Alaska oil spill (from the Exxon Valdez in 1989). It worked very well on the rocky shores.”

Bioremediation can’t do the whole job, said Chris Reddy, marine chemist at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts.

“The idea that microbes can come in and clean house from A to Z is not likely,” he said. “What they can do — on their own time — is eat some compounds and play an important role in the cleanup.”

BP says it’s looking into bioremediation. “Potentially we could do it, but we would need approval from the EPA,” spokesman Tristan Vanheganu said last week. “Typically it’s not done until the oil has stopped flowing.”

The federal government is working on possible bioremediation efforts. The EPA has created a National Contingency Plan Product Schedule listing more than 20 biological agents approved for use in encouraging microbes to attack oil spills. And the USDA’s Natural Resources Conservation Service is contacting the companies that make them to see how quickly they can ramp up production.

And there’s yet another oil-eating product, called Munox, made by Osprey Biotechnics of Sarasota, that has interest from Florida officials. Munox isolates natural microbes from nature, ferments them and adds proprietary ingredients to turn them into a concentrated liquid form to spray on oil spills.

But there’s a danger. Add too much fertilizer and you can create blooms of algae that use up all the oxygen in the surrounding water, creating “dead zones.” There’s already a 6,000-square-mile dead zone in the Gulf off the mouth of the Mississippi River, created years ago by the same fertilizers washing down from upriver farms.

“It’s pretty big and pretty scary,” said Jim Spain, professor of environmental engineering at Georgia Tech.