Archive for Thursday, December 23, 2010

Eudora man charged with animal cruelty sues Osage County

December 23, 2010


A Eudora man, who faces misdemeanor animal cruelty charges in Osage County, has filed a federal lawsuit alleging that county officials wrongfully seized his horses in the case.

Salah Ibrahim’s attorneys filed the lawsuit Monday claiming Osage County Sheriff’s officers used a veterinarian who had little experience caring for horses as part of a plan to seize the horses from property Ibrahim owned in Osage County.

Osage County prosecutors earlier this year charged Ibrahim with one count of cruelty to animals and one count of unlawfully disposing of dead animals, both misdemeanors.

Prosecutors allege Ibrahim abandoned 12 horses from April 1 to April 16 in a field he owns and failed to provide food, water, protection and other care the animals needed.

But in the civil lawsuit, Ibrahim’s Lawrence attorneys, Mark Emert and Brennan Fagan, claim their client provided adequate shelter, food and water for the animals.

The attorneys acknowledged in the lawsuit that it was a harsh winter and that at least one horse did not survive, although “many farm animals died across the state of Kansas.”

The suit also alleges Jacob Henry, a sheriff’s deputy, called Ibrahim on April 15 and expressed concern for the horses, offered to take two of the horses into his own possession and then the next day demanded that Ibrahim “surrender his rights to all of the horses.”

The plaintiff claims the next day Sheriff Laurie Dunn and other officers prohibited one of Ibrahim’s employees from coming onto the property as sheriff’s officers used all-terrain vehicles to corral the horses and later send them to Emporia.

But Ibrahim’s attorneys claim officers did not have a warrant or court order and that they ignored the advice of a veterinarian that the horses could stay on the property. They also said officers stressed and harmed the horses when they corralled them.

Prosecutors have said authorities found two horses dead on Ibrahim’s property and that after the horses were seized another one died.

Osage County Attorney Brandon Jones, who is not named in the suit, said the civil case would have “no effect on the criminal case whatsoever.” A two-day criminal trial is scheduled to begin Feb. 14.

Ibrahim is suing the Osage County Commission, Dunn and Henry on three counts, accusing them of violating his rights to protect his property, trespassing and depriving Ibrahim of his property.

Dunn said Wednesday she was unaware of the lawsuit and could not comment.

According to the suit, Ibrahim is seeking $75,000 in actual damages on each of the three counts. He’s also seeking punitive damages.


KEITHMILES05 7 years, 2 months ago

Good for him. Nothing like law enforcement not following the law.

somebodynew 7 years, 2 months ago

If you knew this guy, you wouldn't be cheering for him (at least i don't think so). Not sure LE was correct in what they did (not enough info in this article), but at least there are a couple of horses that were saved, cause I am quite sure Salah would have let them die.

grtnrse 7 years, 2 months ago

I'm speculating here too but I'd probably do something lawless to save an animal also! End justifies the means? Probably not, especially if your LE, but why are you so antagonistic??

Kris_H 7 years, 2 months ago

"Prosecutors allege Ibrahim abandoned 12 horses from April 1 to April 16 in a field he owns and failed to provide food, water, protection and other care the animals needed."

If that allegation is true, there's no question law enforcement did what they had to do. And as far as another horse dying after they were taken into custody, when you starve animals for a length of time, it's sometimes difficult to start feeding them properly again, and especially horses can have issues related to that.

The above doesn't sound like it had anything to do with winter. April 1 to April 16? Not winter.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.