Archive for Thursday, April 8, 2010

Payday lenders defend policies amid backlash

April 8, 2010


— When Jeffrey Smith needed some quick cash to pay a medical bill, he turned to a payday loan store near his home outside Phoenix.

He took out a string of payday loans and fell into a vicious cycle where he would call out sick from work so he could pay off loans and take out new ones. The experience left him in bankruptcy, lying to his wife and fighting thoughts of suicide.

Stories like Smith’s and a growing backlash against payday lending practices have prompted legislatures around the country to crack down on the businesses.

In the most severe case, Arizona lawmakers are on the verge of shutting down the entire state industry. A law took effect in Washington this year capping the amount of payday loans and the number that a borrower can take out in a year. In Wisconsin, lawmakers are debating whether to regulate the industry.

Payday lenders say they are providing an important service, especially in an economy where people are short on cash. Detractors say the industry preys on desperate people with annual interest rates that exceed 400 percent.

Payday loans are short-term, high-interest loans that are effectively advances on a borrower’s next paycheck.

For example, a person who needs a quick $300 but doesn’t get paid for two weeks can get a loan to help pay the bills, writing a postdated check that the store agrees not to cash until payday. The borrower would have to pay $53 in finance charges for a $300, two-week loan in Arizona — an annual interest rate of 459 percent.

Payday loan stores are ubiquitous in Arizona, especially in working-class neighborhoods of Phoenix where the businesses draw in customers with neon lights and around-the-clock hours.

Payday lenders in Arizona several years ago were granted a temporary exemption from the state’s 36 percent cap on annual interest rates. The exemption expires June 30, and the industry says the interest cap is so restrictive that it will have to shut down entirely.

Bills that would have kept the industry alive languished in the House and Senate, and the year’s third and final attempt was pulled Tuesday amid a lack of support.

Consumers frustrated with the economy “look for a dog to kick,” said Ted Saunders, chief executive of Dublin, Ohio-based Checksmart, a payday lender that operates in 11 states, including Arizona.

“They want to find a villain,” Saunders said. And opponents “have done a good job of painting a big X on my back.”


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.