Reusable bags gaining ground on plastic / LJWorld.com

LJWorld Green

Lawrence store managers see huge increase in usage of environmentally friendly option

Robert Minor, a Kansas University professor, has been using reusable bags for at least 10 years. Minor, who was shopping in May at Hy-Vee Food Store, said he has about eight bags that he received for free at various conferences.

By Karrey Britt

June 11, 2009

Photo by Richard Gwin

Mandee Gieber, Lawrence, buys her first reusable bag at Hy-Vee Food Store on Sixth Street. Gieber bought a thermal one for $1.99 in May because it was on sale. She said she likely would buy more reusable bags to cut down on landfill waste.

It isn’t hard to figure out why using a reusable bag makes sense. There are tons of data on how unhealthy and costly it is to use plastic and paper bags.

Lisa Foster, founder of California-based 1 Bag at a Time, reminds shoppers that free paper and plastic bags are not free.

She said the costs were hidden in higher prices for other products and in higher taxes for landfills and cleanup costs.

She said cities spent up to 17 cents per bag for disposal. The average American uses about 520 bags per year. That adds up to $88 per person in taxes. New York City estimates that if each New Yorker used one less plastic bag per year, the city would save a quarter of a million dollars.

Foster offered more evidence of why people should ditch plastic and paper bags:

• The petroleum used to make 14 plastic bags is enough to drive a car a mile. The 380 million plastic bags that Americans throw away each year are made from millions of barrels of petroleum, adding higher costs for petroleum-based products like gasoline and energy for our homes.

• Littered plastic bags are an eyesore for humans and a deadly killer for wildlife. Just how deadly is a matter of debate among environmentalists and researchers. But Foster is convinced that in some parts of the ocean, there are six pounds of plastic for every pound of plankton.

“There is not a fish in the ocean that doesn’t have some plastic in its stomach,” she said. “The next time you order tuna, I guarantee you there’s dioxin in there from plastic that you think you’ve thrown away.

“We just think, ‘Oh, it’s just a plastic bag.’ But if you are an informed consumer and you understand the plastic doesn’t just go away, it comes back to us. It gets in our food chain. It gets in our waterways. It gets in our air.”

Get informed

Foster strongly encourages people to educate themselves. That’s because she was “duped” when it comes to paper bags.

“I’ve always been an environmentalist and I always picked those paper bags, but then I found that paper bags emit more global warming than plastic bags and I was horrified. I was so angry. I slammed kitchen doors for a week,” she said.

“I really felt like I had been cheated in some very basic way, and I went out of my way to get informed.”

Foster said the truth was that paper bags emit 70 percent more global warming gases than plastic bags in manufacturing and 50 times more water pollution. According to a number of environmental Web sites, Americans used 10 billion paper bags in 1999, consuming 14 million trees.

In 2005, Foster founded 1 Bag at a Time. The company sells reusable bags and promotes awareness about the impact of disposable bags.

She estimates one reusable bag replaces 1,000 plastic bags and saves the government about $170.

So far, business is good. She sold 200,000 bags in 2006, 2 million in 2007 and 8 million in 2008. She said the business has given her hope for our future generations.

“Sometimes, I have been very pessimistic about the world, about the state of humanity and where we will be in the future,” she said. “And then sometimes, like with this company, I am so optimistic about what people are capable of and the changes that people are capable of — even small changes can make a really big difference.”

Foster said she has heard the number of people using their own bags to shop is up 50 percent from the previous year.

Growing trend

That doesn’t surprise Lawrence merchants. Chris Wiltfong, assistant store director at Hy-Vee on Sixth Street, estimates there has been a 200 percent increase in usage since last year.

“It’s been very noticeable over the last year,” he said. “We sell a tremendous amount of them.”

Wiltfong estimated the store sells between 400 and 500 per week. Hy-Vee’s reusable bags cost about $1, and they recently began offering thermal bags for $1.99.

Last month, Lawrence resident Mandee Gieber bought her first reusable bag.

“It’s just the smart thing to do. All of my friends have them and they use them for multiple things,” she said. “I have so many plastic bags at home. You know, five minutes in the car and then forever in the landfills.”

Robert Minor, a professor in religious studies at Kansas University, has about eight reusable bags that he received for free at various conferences. He said he keeps them in his car and just grabs them before heading into the store.

“I don’t have to deal with plastic bags when I get home. I don’t have to worry about throwing those things out.”

Some stores like Hy-Vee and The Community Mercantile also offer incentives for shoppers to use their own bags. Both of the stores provide a 5-cent discount per bag.

Jacqueline Victor, general merchandise buyer for the Mercantile, said the store sold 2,400 reusable bags last year, twice as many as the year before. They sell an assortment of bags that cost between $1.29 and $8.

Victor said the Merc has been selling reusable bags for at least seven years.

“One of our main objectives here is not to just sell food, but to promote a lifestyle that is healthy both for the person and the earth. Reusable bags are just sort of a natural outlet of that,” Victor said.

Discussion

LJWorld.com doesn't necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post.
Read our full policy. Also, read about banned accounts and harassing comments.

11 June 2009
at 6:52 a.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

just_another_bozo_on_this_bus (Anonymous) says…

“The 380 million plastic bags that Americans throw away each year ”

This can't be right. It must be several times higher than that.
11 June 2009
at 6:59 a.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

davidsmom (Anonymous) says…

I was using canvas bags before it was “trendy,” even before I began to think a lot about the environmental impact of the plastic. My house got overrun with plastic bags and it drove me nuts. The canvas bags are so much sturdier and hold so much more. I do get paper sometimes because I use those to collect all my recyclable paper.
11 June 2009
at 7:10 a.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

dulcinea47 (Anonymous) says…

It's really sad that people still think not using plastic bags is going to save the planet. We are so far past that point.
11 June 2009
at 7:19 a.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

grammaddy (Anonymous) says…

If everybody did just one thing….
11 June 2009
at 7:56 a.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

Coach_Eric (Anonymous) says…

And here's where I feel conflicted…

I understand that these bags are bad for the environment for a number of ways. However, my wife and I reuse these bags - every one. We use them in our trash cans, to pick up dog waste, even to collect grill ash. I feel like we reuse them effectively. And I feel like if we don't use them as we do, that we'd use something else in their place (like in our trashcans).
11 June 2009
at 8:29 a.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

consumer1 (Anonymous) says…

I need the plastic shopping bags to pick up my dog's Doody when we go for a walk. I have thought about putting up dispensers around town for other dog owners. Recycle, reuse, and pick up your dogs doody.
11 June 2009
at 9:41 a.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

notit (Anonymous) says…

If you bring your own bags to checkers, as long as you tell the clerk, they will pay you ten cents per bag!!! That is what I have heard anyways. If that is what it cost per bag they are paying way too much for some bags. wow

11 June 2009
at 9:45 a.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

jrlii (Anonymous) says…

While reusable bags are worthwhile, you are ignoring the other possibility: No bag at all.

Generally when I just buy one thing or a few small things which easily fit in my pockets, I ask the checker to “Save the sack.”

My plastic bags generally get used a couple or three times before they (usually holey) go to the landfill. What do they get used for? Sometimes they get a second round as grocery bags, Some get used as laundry bags to haul dirty clothes to the laundry room and finally, most get used as trash bags.

And remember paper bags take up far more landfill space than plastic bags holding the same volume.

One thing the city could do to encourage recycling is to charge by volume, instead of the present residential flat rate, where someone like me who puts out a couple grocery sacks worth of trash a week subsidizes households who put out a dozen 30 gallon bags worth.
11 June 2009
at 9:46 a.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

number3of5 (Anonymous) says…

I am with consumer1, I use plastic shopping bags to pick up both of my dog's doody. This is a twice a day occurence. My mastiff sometimes has such a large pile that it takes two bags to handle it. Is there a free alternative to this plastic bag? How many stores use the bags made from vegetable products such as corn?
11 June 2009
at 12:58 p.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

myvotecounts (Anonymous) says…

I love my reusable grocery bags. Each one holds a lot more than a plastic grocery bag, too. I usually only need one or two reusable bags to carry all of my groceries from the store. There isn't a plastic grocery bag in my house that I know of, and my house is better for it. The transition was amazingly simple and gratifying.
11 June 2009
at 6:53 p.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

joebloe (Anonymous) says…

Why can't they make biodegradable plastic bags? They have poop bags that are biodegradable.
11 June 2009
at 7:13 p.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

tumbilweed (Anonymous) says…

They do. They're called paper bags.
11 June 2009
at 7:15 p.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

Multidisciplinary (Anonymous) says…

I read so many conflicting articles on the carbon footprint for making those cotton bags..if you've already got them..great. Reuse the plastic ones you've got..but I think there are a lot of arguments out there…ya know? It's pretty easy to be a hear someone say, Oh this is bad, here's a solution that sounds reasonable, so let's all jump on the band wagon. But do those doing all the talking, have all the facts or are they selling the sacks and a movement in general..like the need for their whole business?

A man on a corner selling a hat to keep the sun off you head may sell some straw hats. Do fine one year. But what will he do the next, if he then has ball caps, tennis visors, sunglasses, beach chairs with umbrellas, sunscreen, special clothing, foods that fight skin cancer, etc.

The more they get people to 'think' they are making a change, the more they sell..whether or not they actually know if what they are selling is the correct answer to the problem.

Like the rubber under the playground right now. Some cities are now reconsidering that kids are breathing in and swallowing toxins, so they are removing it all, whereas previously it was touted as a “Save the planet by using recycled tires and protect the kids too!” promotion.
6 August 2009
at 10:30 p.m.

Permalink

ecotrendbags (Anonymous) says…

This comment was removed by the site staff for violation of the usage agreement.
6 August 2009
at 10:37 p.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

puddleglum (Anonymous) says…

why don't you do what normal people do?

just burn your trash..it's fun. been doing it since 1973.

no plastic, no paper, just soot.