Archive for Wednesday, July 15, 2009

British musician, wife commit assisted suicide hand-in-hand in Switzerland

July 15, 2009


— He spent his life conducting world-renowned orchestras, but was almost blind and growing deaf — the music he loved increasingly out of reach. His wife of 54 years had been diagnosed with terminal cancer. So Edward and Joan Downes decided to die together.

Downes — Sir Edward since he was knighted by Queen Elizabeth II in 1991 — and his wife ended their lives last week at a Zurich clinic run by the assisted suicide group Dignitas. They drank a small amount of clear liquid and died hand-in-hand, their two adult children by their side. He was 85 and she was 74.

The deaths were a poignant coda to Edward Downes’ illustrious musical career, and have reignited a debate in Britain about whether people should be able to help ailing loved ones end their lives.

The couple’s children said Tuesday that they died “peacefully and under circumstances of their own choosing” on Friday.

“After 54 happy years together, they decided to end their own lives rather than continue to struggle with serious health problems,” said a statement from the couple’s son and daughter, Caractacus and Boudicca.

“They wanted to be next to each other when they died,” Caractacus Downes told London’s Evening Standard newspaper. “They held hands across the beds.

“It is a very civilized way to be able to end your life,” he added.

Downes’ manager Jonathan Groves said the couple were inseparable and would have reached the decision together.

“Sir Edward would have survived her death, but he decided he didn’t want to. He didn’t want to go on living without her,” Groves said.

One of Britain’s most renowned conductors, Downes had a long and eminent career, which included years as head of the BBC Philharmonic and a five-decade association with the Royal Opera House.

In recent years he had become almost blind and nearly deaf, increasingly relying on his wife for support.

Joan, a former ballet dancer, choreographer and television producer, had devoted years to working as his assistant, but she was recently diagnosed with cancer of the liver and pancreas, and given only weeks to live.

Groves said he was shocked by the couple’s deaths but called their decision “typically brave and courageous.”

The double suicide is the latest in a series of high-profile cases that have spurred calls for a legal change in Britain, where assisted suicide and euthanasia are banned.

Under British law, assisting a suicide is punishable by up to 14 years in prison. But courts have become reluctant in recent years to convict people. No relative or friend of any of the Britons who have died in Dignitas clinics has been prosecuted.

The Metropolitan Police force said it had been notified of the deaths, and was investigating. Charges are unlikely.

Despite evidence of changing attitudes, parliamentary efforts to change the rules have all been defeated — most recently last week, when Parliament’s upper chamber, the House of Lords, voted down an amendment that would have relaxed the prohibition on assisted dying.

Sarah Wootton, chief executive of campaign group Dignity in Dying, said the couple’s deaths showed the need to regulate assisted suicide.

“This problem is clearly not going to go away,” she said.

“People should be able to make such decisions for themselves, but safeguards are the key,” she said.

Peter Saunders, of the anti-euthanasia group Care Not Killing, argued that loosening the law could “put vulnerable people, many of whom already think they are a financial or emotional burden to relatives, carers and the state, under pressure to end their lives through a change in the law.”


Mark Zwahl 8 years, 7 months ago

Good for them! Wait, let's keep this illegal so people have to die suffering or by means otherwise gory - and currently disgraceful.

Cait McKnelly 8 years, 7 months ago

Oregon has had a legalized assisted suicide law in place for twelve years. Now Washington (state) and Montana have laws as well. John Ashcroft, the AG under the first W Bush administration, made several attempts to make end runs around the Oregon law, threatening to prosecute doctors who participated in the law under federal DEA laws. Those attempts were shot down by federal courts. One of his last acts as AG prior to resigning was a request for the Supreme Court to intervene and overturn the law. SCOTUS refused. Personally, my belief is that faced with certain death any adult should be permitted to choose how that death occurs. I am not a proponent of euthanasia but I do believe that people should be able to state in their advance directives a desire to end their lives if they become incapacitated from Alzheimer's or other irreversible cognitive disorders and cannot make the decision for assisted suicide themselves.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.