Archive for Saturday, July 11, 2009

Women’s groups quiet on Sotomayor

July 11, 2009


— Women’s groups, euphoric when President Barack Obama chose Sonia Sotomayor for the Supreme Court, have been remarkably quiet in the weeks since on the judge who would be the court’s third woman ever.

Sotomayor’s few rulings on reproductive issues have made abortion rights activists unwilling to crusade on her behalf, and other liberal women’s organizations say they’re waiting to voice full-throated support until they know more about her record.

Their relative silence may be helping Sotomayor — who’s been accused of letting her personal experiences interfere with her judging — more than it hurts her.

“She’s been able to rise above some of that interest group politics,” said Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., a member of the Judiciary Committee that will begin questioning Sotomayor next week in a marathon set of highly publicized hearings.

Prominent Republicans may have made that job easier for Sotomayor, Klobuchar said, by attacking her early on as racist, unintelligent and temperamental — criticisms that were quickly rejected by the party’s senators.

Hispanic groups have led the charge in promoting and defending Sotomayor, who would be the first Latina to serve on the Supreme Court.

And in the weeks since Sotomayor was nominated, civil rights organizations, law enforcement leaders and some environmental groups have come out in enthusiastic support, some holding news conferences, calls with reporters, and launching new Web sites to champion her nomination. Several have written letters to the Judiciary Committee advocating her confirmation.

Most women’s groups, by contrast, have hung back. Aside from issuing favorable statements the day she was chosen, they have done little publicly to press for her confirmation.

Melody Drnach, the vice president of the National Organization for Women, said it’s a question of resources for her group, which has been electing new leaders and is embroiled in the debate over health care reform.

“We’re doing everything we can do in terms of supporting her,” Drnach said, adding that the group will soon step up its efforts behind the scenes, counting votes for Sotomayor and lobbying if necessary to get senators to support her. The group’s D.C. chapter plans a rally Monday outside the confirmation hearings.

Drnach acknowledged that early on, NOW talked internally about whether and how strongly to support Sotomayor given her unknown record on abortion rights and the lack of specific indications in her rulings about how she would handle issues important to women.

Marcia D. Greenberger of the National Women’s Law Center said organizations like hers are not holding back in any way on support for Sotomayor, but they’re busy delving into her record to see what kind of a justice she would be. The center is working on a report on Sotomayor that will be made available after the conclusion of her confirmation hearings.

The National Association of Women Lawyers rated her “highly qualified” this week, but in a letter to the Judiciary panel, its president, Lisa Horowitz, noted that in certain areas important to women — including domestic violence and reproductive choice — the group had “no decisions to review.”

Don’t expect to hear from NARAL Pro-Choice America, the abortion rights group. Its leaders clammed up about Sotomayor once she was nominated, and the group is spending its time and resources pressing senators to ask her questions about the right to privacy during the hearings.


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.