Christmas compassion not about socialism

December 24, 2009


Apparently not content with his congressional majority that wishes to force Americans on a long march to health care disaster, President Obama has invoked the name of Jesus to broadcast his gospel of spreading the wealth around.

Speaking Monday afternoon to a group of children from the Washington, D.C., Boys and Girls Club, the president delivered a mini sermon on “why we celebrate Christmas.” He asked the children if they knew. One piped up and said “The birth of baby Jesus.”

One can imagine the reaction of the media and other elites had a Republican president asked such a question. That Republican would have been accused of violating church-state separation and discriminating against those who celebrate Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, or nothing. Because the president’s Christmas lesson perfectly fit his social goals, there has been no outcry.

The president spoke of what Jesus “symbolizes for people all around the world,” which he said, “is the possibility of peace and people treating each other with respect.” And then, in the best tradition of a community organizer, the president said Jesus is about “doing something for other people.” Even the “three wise men” were invoked to support the president’s idea of wealth redistribution: “...these guys ... have all this money, they’ve got all this wealth and power, and they took a long trip to a manger just to see a little baby.”

And what conclusion should be drawn from that journey? The president told the children, “it just shows you that because you’re powerful or you’re wealthy, that’s not what’s important. What’s important is ... the kind of spirit you have.”

To the president, this means the spirit of government taking from the productive and giving to the nonproductive. To him, Jesus is a socialist, or perhaps an early Robin Hood. Any first-year seminarian (if the seminary is a good one) could destroy this flawed exegesis.

Jesus of Nazareth was not a symbol. Neither was he just a good teacher as some who do not fully accept his teachings about himself like to claim. As Paul the Apostle put it, “Here is a trustworthy saying that deserves full acceptance: Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners — of whom I am the worst.” (1Timothy 1:15)

The call of Scripture is to do for other people, as we would like to have done unto us, but that call is personal, not corporate. That’s because only people can be compassionate. A government check too often brings dependence and a sense of entitlement. A personal touch builds relationships horizontally with others and vertically with God.

One up side to the current recession is that it has forced people to reconsider their priorities. To paraphrase one of the better-known lines from the film, “It’s a Wonderful Life,” the recession has given us a great gift: the ability to see what our lives would look like without stuff.

We still have stuff, too much in fact. Letting go of some of it has not caused people to die in the streets — despite the ludicrous claim by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid that someone dies in America every 10 minutes because they lack health insurance.

Anyone young enough to have living grandparents or great-grandparents should take a few minutes this Christmas to ask them what life was like when they were growing up. How many presents did they receive? Unless they came from wealthy families, they didn’t get much by today’s standards and they were probably more satisfied than we who have more than we need.

That’s the thing about stuff: We know it doesn’t satisfy, but we gorge ourselves on it anyway hoping the marketers are right and somehow it will bring satisfaction.

What those “wise men” brought were symbols — gold, frankincense and myrrh. What they symbolized was the grandeur of the baby who would become a man and who, in the words of John the Baptist, would “take away the sins of the world.” (John 1:29)

Ponder that this Christmas and every Christmas.


just_another_bozo_on_this_bus 8 years, 4 months ago

"Apparently not content with his congressional majority that wishes to force Americans on a long march to health care disaster,"

As usual, Cal begins his column with utter idiocy. We already have healthcare disaster. If Obama is to be criticized for anything, it's that he failed to march us away from it, not into it.

Paul R Getto 8 years, 3 months ago

Relax, Cal. Everyone messed with E.T.'s supposed philosophy. The great ESSENE TEACHER, if he were to 'return' would kick all our butts. People in power have misused the beatitudes for centuries. If there ever were a "christian' nation (still waiting) who could live up to the sermon on the mount, it would be of great interest to see what it looked like. Sir, you did write one good column years ago, when you bagged on the churches for hoarding money and property for their own glory, instead of distributing all we own to the poor, the weak and lame, as E.T. commanded. Like most great prophets, he was ignored and it wasn't long until his followers twisted the message for politics' sake.,

georgiahawk 8 years, 3 months ago

I wondered how right wing "christians" would reconcile their politics with the Christmas spirit! Pretty lame Cal, even for you! Now that Christmas is over, maybe now you can get back to decreasing the surplus population!

The Call to Scripture is personal and not corporate?!! What does that mean? God will forgive those a$$holes that are able to hide their greed behind corporate interests? Let me know how that one fly's Cal.

Paul R Getto 8 years, 3 months ago

It's hard, hard, I tell ya to follow the prophets' example. How much did Jesus own, Buddha, Ghandi? We all love our creature comforts and are loathe to share them with others. This is why the prophets were so radical and were often killed by those who already had a good life.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.