Trip to Treece / LJWorld.com

Archive for Saturday, August 15, 2009

Maybe a firsthand look at the problems in a former mining town in southeast Kansas will convince federal officials of the need to take some action.

J-W Editorials

August 15, 2009

It appears that members of the Kansas congressional delegation may be making some progress in their quest for fair treatment of a southeast Kansas town devastated by the aftereffects of lead and zinc mining in the area.

Sens. Pat Roberts and Sam Brownback and U.S. Rep. Lynn Jenkins jointly announced this week that they had convinced the federal Environmental Protection Agency to send three top officials to Treece to get a firsthand look at the situation that endangers residents of the Cherokee County town. According to a press release, the EPA is considering the use of federal stimulus money to address topsoil remediation in Cherokee County, but the Kansas delegation hopes that, after visiting the area, the EPA will support a longer-term solution: a $3.5 million federal buyout plan for Treece.

The story of federal cleanup efforts in this area is dramatically illustrated in a tale of two cities: Treece and Picher, Okla. The two towns are less than a mile apart. Both were mining towns and part of a 40-square-mile area that is considered one of the worst among the EPA’s Superfund cleanup sites. However, the treatment of the two towns has been very different, as detailed in a March 2007 Journal-World report.

Because of the state line that runs between them, Picher and Treece are located not only in different states but in different EPA regions. Thanks to the efforts of U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe, R-Okla., a $60 million cleanup program was approved for Picher several years ago. While homeowners and businesses in Picher were being bought out by federal funds, the residents of Treece got nothing.

A recent Associated Press story reported that one of the last residents of Picher was finally accepting the buyout and moving. The same story reported that the $3.5 million buyout still was under consideration for Treece, which now is filled with “dilapidated houses, sinkholes as large as baseball fields and uncapped mine shafts.” Seventy families remain in Treece probably because they can’t afford to leave.

Even though the Kansas delegation is several years behind the Oklahoma officials who helped Picher, it’s good that Treece is finally getting the attention it deserves. It seems unthinkable that EPA officials could look at the situation in the two towns and conclude that Treece has gotten a fair shake. The first step was to get them to look at the situation up close and personal, and the Kansas lawmakers should be congratulated for making sure that happens.

Discussion

LJWorld.com doesn't necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post.
Read our full policy. Also, read about banned accounts and harassing comments.

15 August 2009
at 7:14 p.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

Orwell (Anonymous) says…

A generation ago the Brownbacks, Robertses and Jenkinses of their day would have been out rabble-rousing, condemning any “interference” by the EPA with the “free enterprise” gradually destroying Treece. We would have heard endless whining about “big government” and “wasted taxpayer dollars.”

The tragedy is their failure to learn the real lesson of Treece and apply it to present environmental threats to our health and safety. They're perfectly satisfied to let some other generation solve it, rather than take present responsibility for a current threat.
23 August 2009
at 10:57 p.m.

Suggest removal

Permalink

rshrink (Anonymous) says…

C Street Brownback will be running for governor now and pushing for coal fired plants. He is incapable of caring about the environment. If allowed to have his way, more mining and pollution will take place. Brownback was a rubber stamp for Bush, who was responsible for looking the other way regarding pollution and claiming this was the only way to save our economy. Guess what, under his watch, our economy was devastated, so apparently we need not pay attention to these servants of the big corporate interests.