Archive for Sunday, January 6, 2008

Does Obama win in Iowa hint at American colorblindness?

January 6, 2008


Ray Ballentine was waiting for a sign to throw his support to Barack Obama. And when Obama coasted to victory in Iowa's caucuses, there it was - evidence that the senator had the broad racial appeal to get to the White House.

"I did have some reservations before, but he certainly got my vote now," Ballentine said, eating a brisket and roast turkey salad with hush puppies at The Q Shack, a barbecue joint in Raleigh, N.C. "I was sort of undecided, but I feel like he can win the presidency."

Obama's convincing win in Thursday's caucuses in Iowa - a state with just a smattering of minority voters - demonstrated the Illinois senator's support crosses racial lines and bolstered the notion that America is receptive to electing its first black president.

Whether Obama's appeal stretches beyond the farm fields of Iowa will become clear over the next month as the freshman senator faces a series of tests on different political terrain - beginning with Tuesday's primary in New Hampshire, another overwhelmingly white state.

But for Ballentine, who had been wavering between Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton and Obama, Iowa was a tipping point. Like many black voters, he says, he was looking for proof that Obama could garner white support. Yet he wonders if the rest of the nation is as willing as Iowa to embrace the idea of a black president.

"I'm not really sure if they're ready, you know," he said. "I think it's time. He's speaking about change, and certainly that would be a change for this country. A change for the world."

Polls have indicated the vast majority of Americans say they would support a black candidate seeking the White House. A Gallup survey conducted in early 2007 found only 6 percent of men and 5 percent of women said they would not vote for a black presidential candidate - a seismic political shift from 50 years ago when more than half those surveyed felt that way.

Though Obama's win captured headlines and gave his campaign fresh credibility, he is not the first black candidate to triumph in a Democratic presidential contest.

In 1988, civil rights leader Jesse Jackson, making his second bid for the White House, piled up Democratic primary wins in Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, Virginia and the District of Columbia along with caucus victories in South Carolina and Michigan.

But Obama's roots and resume - as well as his campaign - are unlike other black candidates who've run for president. The son of a father from Kenya and a mother from Kansas, Obama was just a child during the dawn of the civil rights movement, grew up in Hawaii and Indonesia and has not made race the centerpiece of his candidacy.

"Obama is running in a way that a lot of white voters feel very sympathetic," said Merle Black, an Emory University political scientist. "He doesn't make them feel guilty. He's not running a Jesse Jackson campaign or an Al Sharpton campaign. He's positioned himself to be a candidate who happens to be black, rather than a black candidate."

For some voters watching Obama, his campaign - and his Iowa success - are simply reflections of changing times.

"America's becoming more open-minded," said Mark Jambretz, a 36-year-old sales director at an Internet company in San Francisco. "I, as a Republican, can say that, and we need to open our eyes to people representing all ethnicities."

Still, he said he could envision some "radical groups" taking violent steps against a black candidate or president.

That also worries Ballentine, the 53-year-old North Carolina electric utility field technician.

"I think he will certainly need to beef up his security, because I think there's these wackos that will go to any extent to make sure he doesn't win," he said. "It's sad to say that, but I think it's a possibility. Some people just don't want to see that happen."

Obama received Secret Service protection last spring - the earliest ever for any presidential candidate. He acknowledged at the time that some of the threats against him were racially motivated.

Some voters, though, say Obama's race may not be that much of a factor in his campaign.

"I think that America wants a lot of change. I don't necessarily know if it matters that he's black or not - just that they want something different," said John Beckner, while waiting for a table with his daughters outside Matt's Big Breakfast, a diner in the shadow of downtown Phoenix.

Beckner, a 34-year-old systems engineer who is white and married to a black woman, said he knows not all Americans will be able to look beyond Obama's race. "I'm sure he's going to alienate some people that just aren't ready for that, or think he has special interests or a minority agenda," he said. "... But the thirst for change is so strong ... that would probably be enough to get him elected."

Standing nearby, Nancy Bergkamp said it's experience that counts and Obama doesn't have it.

"He's out there, 'Oh yeah, let's change, let's do something different and all that.' But I think he's kind of a flash in the pan at this point. I think he's very unproven," said Bergkamp, 51, a registered Republican. "The fact that he's black is somewhat of an afterthought. Maybe I'm naive, but I would like to think we're beyond that."


Dollypawpaw 6 years, 3 months ago

NAACP folk voted for him because he is half black. Democrates are the biggest racists around.


Tom Shewmon 6 years, 3 months ago

Yeah, why is this 'journalist' race-mongering?

What if the candidate were pure Asian and very Asian looking? Albino? Fat? Ugly? Transgender? Deformed?

Come on now, this is a no bigot zone.


max1 6 years, 3 months ago Melanie Morgan and the KSFO crew should really consider whether or not this is the right profession for them. . . they've taken aim at Barack Obama, attempting to revive the incessantly debunked Madrassa smear put forth by Insight Magazine, which is owned by a man who claims to be the messiah. The only problem is Catherine Moy, the small town California journalist who operates as Morgan's personal goon squad, didn't check out her source before repeating his "research" as truth. In addition, Moy's source, Andy Martin, is an unapologetic anti-Semite. As a shining symbol of democracy, the United States capital is not ordinarily a place where coronations occur. So news that the Rev. Sun Myung Moon, the eccentric and exceedingly wealthy Korean-born businessman, donned a crown in a Senate office building and declared himself the Messiah while members of Congress watched is causing a bit of a stir. Andy Martin's columns and coverage continue to drive the 2008 presidential race,1,3826076.story%3Fcoll%3Dchi-newslocal-hed February 10, 2006, Chicago Tribune Perennial [Republican] candidate [Andy Martin] back for another race He has repeatedly refused to answer questions from the Tribune and has in the past unsuccessfully sued the newspaper for libel. . . Martin also has expressed anti-Semitic attitudes in the past. When he ran for Congress in Connecticut in 1986, the name of his congressional campaign committee included the phrase "to exterminate Jew power in America," Federal Election Commission records show. In a 1983 personal bankruptcy case, he referred to a federal bankruptcy judge as a "crooked, slimy Jew, who has a history of lying and thieving common to members of his race." In a related court filing in the case, he also expressed sympathy to the perpetrators of the Holocaust. "I am able to understand how the Holocaust took place, and with every passing day feel less and less sorry that it did, when Jew survivors are operating as a wolf pack to steal my property," Martin wrote in an April 21, 1983, personal bankruptcy proceeding.


max1 6 years, 3 months ago

"I would have no problem voting for a black candidate, but Obama's Muslim education, etc. bothers me quite a bit." -canyon_wren "There are far too many rednecks in this country who will not be able to set aside his race and his "muslim education"." -Bladerunner "But, some right wing extremist attack professionals put out a fake email about him attending a madrassa." -Reality_Check

Reality_Check is correct. Bladerunner and canyon_wren have been duped. The initial rumor has been attributed to no other than the Illinois Republican, Andy Martin. I've tried to explain repeatedly who Andy Martin is, and once again I have posted some references to him below. The "madrassa smear" spread like wildfire through right-wing media after Martin's accusation was published in Rev. Sun Myung "The Messiah" Moon's Insight Magazine. "Barack Hussein Obama, closet Muslim (denies), black man-ain't happenin' : I'm afraid you're out of touch if you think America will elect a black man to the highest office." -right_thinker Incidentally, the Rev. Sun Myung Moon has been a Bush family crony for decades. Let's begin with the Reverend "Messiah" Moon. Insight magazine claimed in a January 2007 article that Barack Obama spent at least four years attending what is variously described as a "madrassa," a "radical Muslim religious school If you've ever wondered how agit-propaganda works, you might take a look at the latest case study from the Rev. Sun Myung Moon's media empire a bogus story about Barack Obama attending a Muslim "madrassah" when he was six years old, a smear that was then attributed to operatives of Hillary Clinton.


Jason Bowers-Chaika 6 years, 3 months ago

I really dislike the phrase color blind. It is an attempt to try and ignore our diversity rather than embrace it. People who say they are color blind are deluding themselves. Yeah he's black BFD. Black Fine Democrat. He is the best thing since sliced bread whether that be white bread or dark.


Reality_Check 6 years, 3 months ago

Does Obama win in Iowa hint at American colorblindness? No, because it was some Democrats in Iowa voting in caucuses. You cannot project from that anything to do with how the general election will go in the rest of the country.


Reality_Check 6 years, 3 months ago

Wow, the Right Wing Attack Machine never sleeps, and you sheeple fall for it over and over again.

Once again, for the record, here are the facts: Obama attended a Muslim elementary school in Indonesia for two years. That's it! It was not a madrassa. He was not a Muslim, never was a Muslim, and was raised a Christian by a Christian from Kansas. He wasn't raised by his father, who was Muslim.

But, some right wing extremist attack professionals put out a fake email about him attending a madrassa. The Fox Noise Channel picked it up as if it were fact, and then their wacky pundits started spinning it.

I'm no Obama fan, but facts are truth, and Right Wing Extremist b.s. is lies. Always has been, always will be.


Mkh 6 years, 3 months ago

Personally I find this entire thing basically racist as can be. I so sick of people saying we should vote for Obama because he is "black", or because it's time for a "black person to be President". This is nothing but BS from the collectivists. It shouldn't matter one bit of difference what a person's skin color is, it should not be in the discussion or the debate. Vote for the best Person, the best American. If you feel that is Obama, than great. I happen to not. But we need to stop categorizing everyone in terms of interest groups defined by race/gender/and sexual orientation,etc. "Groups" do not deserve rights, All Individuals Deserve Equal Rights and Opprotunity no matter what group they can be placed in by the small minded.


Bladerunner 6 years, 3 months ago

And he got no education there in that radically muslim dominated country? R-i-g-h-t. You really believe that or are you lying to yourself because its what you want to believe?Obama doesnt have the experience to lead this country. As the polls show....He is popular with some crowds but the bottom line is....There are far too many rednecks in this country who will not be able to set aside his race and his "muslim education". I believe a vote for Obama is a wasted vote and will ensure the republicans another 4 years in the white house.


raiderssb 6 years, 3 months ago

What are you talking about - his Muslim education?! He wasn't educated as a Muslim, he just happened to live in Indonesia VERY BRIEFLY as a young child.


classclown 6 years, 3 months ago

Apparently not if if news media figures continue to see a need to bring it up.


canyon_wren 6 years, 3 months ago

I would have no problem voting for a black candidate, but Obama's Muslim education, etc., bothers me quite a bit. Still, he is a big improvement over Hillary--I'm glad the Iowa thing turned out the way it did. Will be interesting to see how this whole thing unfolds over the next months.


lounger 6 years, 3 months ago

Obama is good no matter what colour he is. What a grand speech he gave after!!!!


Commenting has been disabled for this item.