Archive for Saturday, December 15, 2007

Series of mistakes led to 3 wrong-side brain surgeries

December 15, 2007


The main entrance to Rhode Island Hospital is seen in Providence, R.I. The hospital was fined $50,000 and reprimanded by the state Department of Health after its third instance of brain surgery performed on the wrong side.

The main entrance to Rhode Island Hospital is seen in Providence, R.I. The hospital was fined $50,000 and reprimanded by the state Department of Health after its third instance of brain surgery performed on the wrong side.

— One operation went awry after an experienced brain surgeon insisted to a nurse he knew what side of the head to operate on - but got it wrong.

Another time, a doctor-in-training cut into the wrong side of a patient's head after skipping a pre-op checklist. In a third case, the chief resident started brain surgery in the wrong place, and the nurse didn't stop him.

All three mistakes happened at the same hospital in less than a year - Rhode Island Hospital, the state's most prestigious medical center and a teaching hospital for the Ivy League's Brown University.

That was startling enough, but just as surprising was that the errors happened despite an explicit set of required operating-room precautions adopted by the medical profession a few years ago to prevent "wrong-site surgery" mistakes. Those measures include the use of checklists, "time-outs" to double-check everything is correct, and indelible markers to show the surgeon where to cut.

"The problem's not going away," said Peter Angood, vice president and chief patient safety officer at the Joint Commission, an independent organization that accredits most of the nation's hospitals. "Organizations don't like to do this. It's complicated for them to do. Surgeons tend to resist it."

The mistakes at Rhode Island Hospital suggest that the precautions can still be thwarted by the human element - ego and overconfidence on the part of surgeons, and timidity on the part of nurses too afraid to speak up when they see something about to go wrong.

"There's a big cultural issue in most operating rooms where there's a hierarchical culture there. A surgeon is used to being the captain of the ship, and his or her word goes," said Diane Rydrych, assistant director of the division of health policy at the Minnesota Health Department. "If there's a culture where people are afraid to say anything to the surgeon because they're afraid they're going to get yelled at, that's a problem."

The Joint Commission gets about eight reports a month of wrong-site surgery, but hospitals are not required to report such incidents, and Angood said the real number is probably 10 times higher.

After the third mistake at Rhode Island Hospital, the institution was fined $50,000, ordered to tighten up its procedures and required to report to the state every time a doctor fails to follow the rules. The hospital also took unspecified "corrective action" against the doctors and nurses.

Mary Reich Cooper, chief quality officer for Lifespan Corp., owner of the nonprofit hospital, said the institution is encouraging the staff to report mistakes.

Rhode Island Hospital performed neurosurgery more than 860 times in fiscal year 2007. While three wrong-site mistakes represent just a small percentage, it is unusual for any one hospital to have so many, doctors said.

The first was in January, when a third-year resident didn't mark the place where he was supposed to put a drain in an elderly man's head, according to Lifespan. Both the doctor and nurse said later they weren't trained in how to use a checklist, Cooper said.

In July, a surgeon with more than two decades in medicine never wrote on a consent form which side of an 86-year-old man's head he would operate on to remove a blood clot, Cooper said. A nurse questioned why that wasn't filled out, and the surgeon said he remembered which side.

In November, during an operation on an elderly woman, the hospital's chief neurosurgery resident and a nurse discussed the correct side ahead of time, Cooper said. But for reasons that are unclear, the doctor marked and cut into the woman's scalp on the wrong side, and the nurse did not stop him, according to Cooper.

In all three cases, the doctor immediately closed the wound and operated on the correct side. The patients were OK, though the man in the July operation died a few weeks later from what the Health Department said were unrelated causes.


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.