Archive for Sunday, July 30, 2006

Study finds women, doctors downplay female heart pain

July 30, 2006


— Women with heart-attack symptoms wait longer than men to go to the hospital and, once there, often don't get the same level of care as men, a Michigan study covering metro Michigan cities has found.

The study, first publicized this week, documents that men and women respond to and are treated for heart problems differently - at hospitals big and small - despite more than 10 years of programs and awareness efforts to correct the problem.

It shows that far more work needs to be done to educate women about warning signs and to educate doctors to aggressively diagnose women when they go to hospitals with symptoms.

Too often, women don't act quickly enough to get to a hospital when they have heart-attack symptoms, experts said.

They downplay warning signs or may not have classic chest pain, the most common sign of a heart attack in men and women. And women, particularly the older they get, may have unusual and persistent symptoms such as shortness of breath, stomach pain and fatigue.

"I didn't want to bother anyone," said Carolyn Crossman, 52, of Belleville, Mich., explaining why she lived with chest pain for five days before relenting to a son who insisted she go to the University of Michigan Medical Center on July 17. She had a heart attack later that day.

When she left the hospital two days later, she was told to exercise and reduce her stress. But that's hard, because she spends most of her day in a wheelchair, she said. She takes four heart disease medicines. And one of her three teenage children has serious emotional problems and is destructive at home, she said.

"The doctors said, no stress. How am I going to do that?" she asked.

Still, projects to close the gaps between men and women are under way.

Through a program started by Dr. Kim Eagle, co-director of the University of Michigan's Cardiovascular Center, emergency room workers at nearly three dozen Michigan hospitals are using checklists developed by the American College of Cardiology to review key recommendations before a woman is discharged.

The list includes nearly a dozen items that help ensure a woman doesn't return with another heart attack. It calls for individual counseling about diet, exercise and smoking cessation; and four or five medicines that help keep arteries unclogged and the heart pumping right.

Eagle was senior author of the large Michigan study, which found that following the recommendations on the checklists cut in half a woman's risk of dying within a year from a heart attack.

About 12 percent of women, Eagle said, have mild symptoms or blockages in tiny arteries that don't show up on standard tests. Such was the case for Sherry Bumpus, 35, of Ypsilanti, Mich.

She awoke June 12 with pain in her back between her shoulder blades, as well as aches at the top of her teeth, she said. A nurse practitioner, Bumpus took two over-the-counter pain pills, breast-fed her 7-month-old baby, served breakfast to her 2-year-old toddler and went to the beauty shop for a haircut before taking her pain seriously.

When she got home, her pain moved from her back to her chest. She finally went to the hospital around 5:15 p.m., after arranging for child care. Routine tests found no problem, but a cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) discovered she had suffered a heart attack.

She said her case is a textbook example of just how unpredictable heart attacks in women can be.

"I'm a health care provider, and I didn't think I had a heart attack," she said. "Neither did my colleagues or the emergency room doctors."

What women should know about heart disease

Q: What causes heart disease in women? A: High blood pressure, diabetes and high cholesterol are typical causes of heart disease. Other factors that increase a woman's risk include smoking, obesity, oral contraceptive use after age 35 and an endocrine disorder known as polycystic ovary syndrome.

Q: Are women's hearts different than men? A: Yes. Their heart muscle, as well as the vessels supplying it, tends to be smaller. As a result, blockages in smaller arteries don't always show up on tests.

Q: How do women avoid heart problems? A: The best way to reduce risk is through lifestyle changes, particularly, weight loss if needed; 30 minutes of daily exercise; and a low-fat diet. Extra weight causes the heart to work harder, raises blood pressure, increases your bad cholesterol and triglycerides and decreases your good cholesterol. Avoid processed foods, sweets and carbohydrates. And get regular checkups and blood tests. Ask for the breakdown of components of cholesterol, not just the total number.

Q: What causes a heart attack? A: Usually, the arteries that supply the heart or brain with blood slowly develop deposits of cells, fat and cholesterol, or plaque. This buildup can narrow blood vessels and cause them to burst, causing a heart attack or stroke.

Q: What should a woman do if she has symptoms such as chest pains, shortness of breath or abdominal discomfort? A: She should call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department.

Q: Do women suffering a heart attack have the same symptoms as men? A: Not always. The most common signs are chest pain, nausea, vomiting and neck, back and jaw pain. But in women, there are other symptoms: fatigue; shortness of breath that persists, seems severe or different; indigestion; and abdominal discomfort.


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.