Archive for Wednesday, July 26, 2006

Health Policy Authority to study human cloning

July 26, 2006


Legislative leaders Tuesday ordered a study on human cloning, but anti-abortion advocates anticipated the report would be a whitewash.

"This just hacks us off," said Kathy Ostrowski, a spokeswoman for Kansans for Life.

During the last session, proponents of a one-year ban on state funding of embryonic stem cell research held up consideration of a budget bill. But they agreed to drop their demands for a ban if the Legislature called for a study of the topic between legislative sessions.

"This was part of the agreement," Senate President Steve Morris, R-Hugoton, said after the Legislative Coordinating Council ordered the study.

Opponents of embryonic stem cell research, including anti-abortion groups, had wanted the issue to be studied by a legislative committee.

Instead, the council gave the task to the new Kansas Health Policy Authority, a nine-member panel that has assumed oversight of most of the state's Medicaid programs and its insurance programs for state employees and uninsured children.

The authority was told to study the different types of cloning and the various terms used for types of research.

Their study must use a president's council report on cloning as its foundation in studying scientific terminology. But it also must consider terminology for stem cell research from the National Academies of Sciences and National Institute of Health. The authority also was told to study the national guidelines for stem cell research recommended by the National Academies of Sciences.

Ostrowski said she wanted the study to be done by a legislative committee, whose members are accountable to voters.

And, she said, the Health Policy Authority's executive director, Marcia Nielsen, favors stem cell research.

But Nielsen denied that her personal views would affect the study, which she said would focus on scientific definitions to help legislators in debating the issue.

"They are asking for clarity around definitions as opposed to recommendations," she said.

- Staff writer Scott Rothschild can be reached at 785-354-4222.


badger 11 years, 10 months ago

Frankly, I want to see the studies performed by people who aren't accountable to voters.

The decisions made based on the studies, the expenditures of funds, the course chosen should all come from people who are accountable, but the actual collection and evaluation of data needs to come from people who aren't worried about losing an election if their findings make them unpopular at home. That's the only way you get accurate data analysis, from someone whose job doesn't depend on the data falling in with public opinion.

Then, with accurate data and analysis, an informed people and their legislature have a better set of tools for determining the state's course of action.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.