Archive for Sunday, February 12, 2006

Commuters consider hybrid cars

February 12, 2006


For commuters, the only thing that adds up quicker than the gasoline bills are the miles on the odometer.

Several commuters this week said that had them looking at new, fuel-efficient hybrid cars that run on a combination of gasoline and electricity. But most said they hadn't yet been able to bring themselves to buy one of the new-age vehicles.

"I like the idea of them, but they still seem a little cost prohibitive," said Deb Young, a Lawrence commuter.

The question with hybrids is whether the additional purchase price will be offset by savings in gasoline purchases. Here's a look at some of the math behind that analysis using the Toyota Prius, a popular hybrid, and the Toyota Corolla, a similar sized non-hybrid vehicle.

The 2006 hybrid Prius - with a suggested retail price of $21,725 - costs about $7,700 more than the comparable 2006 Toyota Corolla. But the Prius - with highway fuel mileage of 51 miles to the gallon - is 10 miles per gallon more efficient than the Corolla. With gasoline at $2.20 per gallon, a Prius owner would save $105 in gasoline bills for every 10,000 miles driven.

If a commuter put 20,000 miles a year on a car, it would take about 36 years - or about 720,000 miles - for gasoline savings to pay for the additional purchase price. Of course, if gasoline prices increase, so will the annual savings.

But compared to some other larger models, the Prius pays for itself much quicker. For example, the price difference between a Prius and similarly-equipped but larger 2006 Toyota Camry is $3,280. Fuel mileage is 18 miles per gallon better with the Prius. With gasoline at $2.20 per gallon, a commuter who drives 20,000 miles per year would pay for the additional purchase price through gasoline savings in about seven years, or 140,000 miles.


just_another_bozo_on_this_bus 12 years, 3 months ago

I thought hybrid technology was advantageous primarily for urban driving, where constant braking charged the batteries that powered the electric motor. Commuters who do primarily highway driving would rely mostly on the gasoline engine. Wouldn't they be better off getting a standard vehicle that gets good gas mileage (and joining a carpool?)

Richard Heckler 12 years, 3 months ago

A Toyota Corrolla and Matrix will get 36-40 mpg on the highway according to users. A Prius which is very quiet would get the best mileage in town thus make an excellent errand car. Of course if a commute to KC will involve much city driving then a Prius also makes sense in that scenario.

Corrolla and Matrix are the same vehicle. One of the most dependable cars on the planet.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.