Legal groups to Justice Department: Back off

Post-Enron policy allows corporations to avoid paying many legal fees

? Two legal groups, including the American Bar Assn., are opposing a U.S. Department of Justice policy they say compels companies facing possible indictment to refuse paying legal costs of corporate officers or board members.

After scandals at companies like Enron Corp. and WorldCom Inc. cost shareholders tens of billions of dollars and wiped out thousands of jobs, the Justice Department in January 2003 issued a memo to guide prosecutors as they decide whether to seek criminal charges against a business.

The memo says prosecutors can consider whether the corporation appears to be “protecting its culpable employees and agents” through advancing attorneys fees, retaining the employees without sanction or giving the employees information about the government’s investigation.

The legal groups say the memo can inspire companies to do the opposite, including not paying legal costs for employees and agents.

Mark Alcott, president of the 72,000-member New York State Bar Assn., said the use of such tactics to “force companies to waive attorney-client privilege” has accelerated in recent months.

His group and the 400,000-member American Bar Assn. want the Justice Department to back off.

“This is a serious and threatening interference in the relationship between lawyers and clients,” Alcott said. “We don’t know if somebody is a wrongdoer until charges have been brought, a jury hears a trial and someone is convicted. Every person is entitled to a lawyer, and (company officials) have a legal right to have their employers pay those fees.”

Justice Department Spokeswoman Kathleen Blomquist said the department remains committed to the principles and guidance set out in the memo, but it will listen to concerns.