Archive for Tuesday, November 15, 2005

Bad moon rising?

Myths are lunacy, some scientists say

November 15, 2005


Debbie Nall swears she doesn't need a calendar to determine the lunar phase.

She says she knows that when students are cranky at Central Junior High School, where she is a lunchroom cashier, there's likely a full moon.

And she says she saw exactly the same behavior among residents at Brandon Woods Retirement Community, where she served 16 years as activity director. Residents were just more agitated during a full moon.

"There is some truth to it, because I've seen it," Nall says. "You can just tell their behavior changes, and usually to me it's more for the bad behavior. (Students are) more hyper and climb the walls."

The theory that things get a little crazy during a full moon - like the one tonight - has been around for centuries. It's perpetuated by werewolf tales, folk stories and urban legends.

But scientists say despite all the commonly held beliefs about full moons affecting behavior, the notion is nothing more than moonshine.

"There's no statistical truth to it," says Bruce Twarog, professor of astronomy and physics at Kansas University.

Twarog says he's yet to see a scientific study that proves any connection between the moon's cycles and human behavior.

Most who believe there is a connection between the two argue that because the moon controls tides, and, because more than half of the human body is made of water, it would be a logical assumption that the moon could affect the body as well.

But Twarog says it's simply a matter of scale. Unlike the earth, the human body is too small to be affected by the moon's gravitational pull. One study in 1996 debunking the moon myth said a mother holding her child exerted 12 million times as much force as the moon does.

The numbers

Those who believe the moon myth have tried to tie the lunar cycles to a variety of effects, including increased childbirths, more crime, the stock market, fertility, natural disasters, suicides and car accidents.

Data collected in several areas in Lawrence from the past year show no trends on full moon days.

At Lawrence Memorial Hospital, there were an average of 2.75 babies delivered on full moon dates since November 2004. That compares with an average of 3.09 births among all days.

There were, however, a few more emergency-room visits on full moon days - 82.3 per day on average, compared with a 77.7 average on all days.

But Brian Hunt, an emergency department physician for 12 years, says he doesn't think there's a full-moon effect.

"We always joke about it, that the ER gets busy when the moon's full," Hunt says. "The reality is, I have not seen any correlation. I don't see anything objective to it."

He says the days emergency department staff can plan on being especially busy aren't during full moons. They're busier on basketball and football game days, or during weather events such as ice storms.

"I don't alter my psyche or medicine based on the phases of the moon," Hunt says.

Likewise, Douglas County emergency personnel didn't see increased activity during full moon days during the past year - in fact, they saw less activity. There were an average of 21 fewer 911 calls on full moon days, when those days were compared with the average for the same days of the week.

There are several specific types of calls that seemed to increase on days with full moons. Those include fire alarms, car stops and "special calls."

But Jim Denney, director for emergency communications for Douglas County, says he thinks other factors - such as storms - on those days were responsible for the increased calls.

Perception persists

But some people are still convinced of the connection.

Kathleen Firns-Hubert, of Lawrence, says the phenomenon landed her some extra cash while she was a waitress at a cocktail lounge in St. Louis. The clientele had a different attitude on full moon nights, she says.

"Not only was the place jumping, but the people had a different sense about them - like they were really letting go," she says. "Sometimes it took me a while to recognize a pattern, and often I would remark to a co-worker, 'Wow! I wonder what's going on. It's crazy here tonight.'

"Invariably, either someone would comment about the fact that it was a full moon, or I would find out later that it had, indeed, been the case."

William Medlock, also of Lawrence, takes the full moon phenomenon to another level. He's a practicing Wiccan, and says many of his beliefs have a connection with the cycle of the moon.

"Most of the time, when there's a full moon, I'll do a small recognition of it," he says.

That often involves lighting a candle and saying a few words to the god and goddess he worships - the god focuses on seasonal changes, the goddess focuses on nature and changes such as the lunar cycle.

"It's more sacred," he says. "I spend more time outside when there's a full moon, and I'm looking up more. I have more of a feeling inside of joy."

For Medlock, the cycles of the moon represent the various cycles of life. And he's pretty sure the full moon affects others, too, with gravitational forces and so much of the body made of water.

"Of course we're going to be affected," he says.

But Twarog, the KU professor, says people who see the full moon effect tend to be the ones looking for it.

For instance, during the Aug. 19 full moon, Lawrence Memorial Hospital saw eight births - more than twice the normal number. Someone could take a quick glance at limited data such as that and attribute it to the full moon, he says.

"You tend to look for the effect, and if something happens, it's, 'Ah, it's a full moon,'" Twarog says. "The times nothing happens, you don't remember those."


Spoken1 12 years, 6 months ago

Porkribs, just what do you attribute that completely ignorant, hateful, irrational, and just plain stupid comment to?

mangoisgood 12 years, 6 months ago

What a waste of a front page.

Why not put informative, important, and interesting articles on the front page, like the ones hidden in the World section?

Superstitious human interest stories do not belong on the front page. Especially not when there's actually news to cover. What a

bankboy119 12 years, 6 months ago

lol spoken how is that hateful...or irrational....or ignorant....or just plain stupid?

yourworstnightmare 12 years, 6 months ago

Actually, this is just the sort of story that the LJW needs to be covering.

Ignorance and superstition are succeeding reason and reality in Kansas, so why not a story about "lunacy"?

jmckean 12 years, 6 months ago

Full Moons make me hungry for pork ribs.....yum, yum!

DGL 12 years, 6 months ago

Maybe the Kansas School Board will vote to have the full moon theory thaught in classrooms because life is so complex that it can't be explained fully without the full moon theory.

DGL 12 years, 6 months ago

Haha! It's sad that our state is so pathetic we're laughing at ourselves.

dex 12 years, 6 months ago

i'm glad i'm not paying for this. oh wait, I WANT MY TIME BACK!

Commenting has been disabled for this item.