Advertisement

Archive for Tuesday, June 21, 2005

Judge reverses ruling prohibiting sketches

June 21, 2005

Advertisement

Carrie Parbs, Martin K. Miller's former mistress, is shown in this courtroom sketch. June 21, 2005.

Carrie Parbs, Martin K. Miller's former mistress, is shown in this courtroom sketch. June 21, 2005.

A judge on Monday reversed her earlier ruling that prohibited the Lawrence Journal-World from publishing sketches of two adult witnesses in a first-degree murder trial.

District Court Judge Paula Martin ruled Monday that sketches of defendant Martin K. Miller's former mistress, Carrie Parbs, and his friend Laura Cuthbertson could be published despite their requests not to be sketched.

Martin said she initially thought the two were covered by a Kansas Supreme Court rule that states a judge can order that a "witness of a crime" not be photographed in court if the person does not want to be.

But upon further research, Martin said, neither fit the legal definition of being a "witness of a crime."

In making the decision, Martin continued to rely on rules that govern electronic and photographic media coverage of court cases. The newspaper argues that those rules are incorrectly being applied to sketches and that the judge's decisions are an infringement on the First Amendment right to freedom of the press.

The newspaper is still asking the Kansas Supreme Court to overturn a related decision by the judge, which prohibited the newspaper from sketching or publishing sketches of Miller's two children, ages 14 and 12, who testified for the prosecution. The Supreme Court has yet to decide whether it will hear that argument.

Comments

flutter 9 years, 6 months ago

Why would you want to publish sketches of those kids? They are going through enough pain and trauma...they do not need to have their likenesses published in the local paper and online for people to see and then be able to recognize them. The Journal World's pursuit of this matter is simply ridiculous. Leave those poor kids alone and in peace. You've covered the story, published other photos. What's the point?

Commenting has been disabled for this item.