Conservative-liberal controversy makes hero of student

? Just before the final bell at Rancho Cotate High School on a recent afternoon, a campus supervisor reported to Principal Mitchell Carter on his walkie-talkie: “I’m in position. Subject in view.”

The focus of the extra security was a 17-year-old high school junior, Tim Bueler, whose claims of political harassment by “liberal” students and faculty have made him into something of a youth hero among conservative Web bloggers and radio talk show hosts across the country.

Since the beginning of January, Bueler has been escorted by an adult school official to and from every class and to his father’s car at the end of the day. The precaution was ordered by the school district superintendent after several confrontations between Bueler and fellow members of the school Conservative Club, and other students who object to what they claim are “racist” writings in the club’s political tracts.

According to a timeline issued by the Cotati-Rohnert Park City School District, the controversy started Dec. 3 when the Conservative Club, which Bueler organized last fall, posted an inflammatory flier at the high school announcing the creation of a “Conservative Hotline,” where students could report examples of “un-American” comments by their teachers.

“Let’s take a stand against the liberal traitors who call themselves teachers,” proclaimed the flier.

In response, an anonymous faculty member proposed a “Liberal Hotline” to counter the Conservative Club. “Have you heard any un-American comments expressed by your reactionary students lately?” the flier asked, parodying the original. “Let’s take a stand against the neo-conservative wing-nuts who call themselves Americans.”

On Dec. 12 Bueler distributed a Conservative Club newsletter in which he wrote that “Liberals welcome every Muhammad, Jamul and Jose who wishes to leave his Third World state and come to America — mostly illegally — to rip off our health-care system, balkanize our language and destroy our political system.”

The statement was borrowed directly from the sayings and writings of nationally syndicated San Francisco radio host Michael Savage, whom Bueler credits for inspiration.

The school district’s beleaguered superintendent, Michael Watenpaugh, has accused the Conservative Club and the high school staff of “missteps” since the issue erupted.

Bueler is delighted by all the attention. In an interview at his family home, Bueler ticked off the dozen or so radio and television talk shows that have featured his case, including those by Rush Limbaugh and Dr. Laura Schlessinger.

In an effort to defuse the situation at the high school, Watenpaugh sent lawyers to the campus to discuss First Amendment law, ordered the extra security between classes for Bueler and issued a statement accusing both sides of “missteps.”

The Conservative Club was wrong, Watenpaugh said, for distributing a flier and newsletter without first getting approval from the faculty adviser.

The school administration was wrong, said Watenpaugh, in suggesting Bueler leave school for a while in a “cooling off” period, which opened the door to conservative criticism.

Bueler refused to leave school, which has since prompted the admiration and attention of the conservative talk show hosts.