Animal-rights issues on ballots in three states

Oklahomans will vote whether to ban cockfighting

? Animal-rights activism is colliding head-on with rural tradition in Oklahoma, where voters will decide Nov. 5 whether to ban cockfighting in one of the last three states to allow the bloody spectacle.

Supporters of the proposed ban say cockfighting is inhumane and gives the state a bad name. Opponents say the sport, also legal in Louisiana and New Mexico, is a livelihood for people who raise the birds and is no crueler than the way chickens are raised and slaughtered.

Cockfighting became legal in Oklahoma in 1963, when the state Court of Criminal Appeals ruled that a fowl is not an animal and is thus exempt from state law against animal fighting.

Specially bred gamecocks are fitted with razor-sharp spurs or knives. They are placed in dirt pits and often fight to the death. Illegal gambling is often the big draw.

“It’s barbaric abject cruelty to animals,” said Janet Halliburton, who led the petition drive to put the measure on the ballot. “It makes us look like a bunch of knuckle-dragging animal abusers.”

Most Oklahomans have never seen a cockfight and polls show the ban is likely to pass by a wide margin. Still, two of three gubernatorial candidates, Democratic state Sen. Brad Henry and independent Gary Richardson, oppose the ban. Republican Steve Largent favors it.

Outgoing Gov. Frank Keating has endorsed the measure, saying, “It is simply embarrassing to Oklahoma to be seen as one of only a tiny handful of locations outside of the Third World where this activity is legal.”

However, a former governor, David Walters, opposes the measure, saying it would halt a source of income for some impoverished rural communities.

“Some of these people are dead-dog poor and I have a hard time telling them we’re going to take your livelihood away,” he said.

The measure on the Oklahoma ballot would make it a felony to hold cockfights, keep equipment or facilities for cockfighting or possess birds for cockfighting. The penalty would be up to 10 years in prison.

A long knife is among a collection of cockfighting tools owned by Naconna Bennett, 16, of McAlester, Okla. Voters in Oklahoma, one of three states that allow cockfighting, will decide Nov. 5 whether to ban the sport.

In New Mexico and Louisiana, there have been periodic attempts to outlaw cockfighting, but they have always failed in the Legislature.

Oklahoma is one of three states with animal-welfare initiatives placed on the Nov. 5 ballot through citizen petition drives.

l In Florida, voters will consider a proposed amendment that would make the state the first to outlaw the practice of confining pregnant pigs in small metal cages.

Florida ranks 30th in the nation in hog production. But backers of the amendment hope its endorsement by Florida voters will send a message to legislators in major hog producing states such as Iowa, North Carolina and Minnesota, which do not have citizen initiatives.

l In Arkansas, voters will decide whether to make the state the 38th with felony penalties for extreme acts of animal cruelty.

Opponents of the measure include the state Game and Fish Commission, the Arkansas Farm Bureau Federation and the state’s associations of cattlemen, pork producers and poultry producers.

The coalition contends the ballot item could expose farmers, hunters and fishermen to unwarranted accusations of animal cruelty. The other side says the measure is aimed only at deliberate, malicious acts.

Under the measure, acts of extreme cruelty to animals could be punished by up to six years in jail and a $10,000 fine. Currently, any act of animal cruelty is a misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in jail and a $1,000 fine.