Archive for Sunday, June 23, 2002

CPA may serve as mediator

June 23, 2002


My husband and I have decided to call it quits after 32 years. Our children are grown, married and have children of their own. My husband is a retired chief operating officer of a large company, has stock options, a 401(k), pension, etc. I have a flower and decorating shop (corporation), and we both own stock.

We have each contacted lawyers and gotten fee estimates of upwards of $50,000 each. We know what we have. Isn't there an easier and less expensive way to go our separate ways?

While we are not advocates of mediation in every case, situations like yours seem to cry out for it. The question becomes: Who should be appointed as the "neutral" to help us settle the economic issues of our case?

We believe that in situations like yours where there are complicated valuation and division issues, a qualified certified public accountant might be a wise choice. This does not mean each you doesn't need a matrimonial lawyer. It does mean, however, that the lawyer's job description changes and the cost of services should be reduced.

Traditionally, for example, when one or both of the spouses owns a business, a professional practice, stock options and qualified retirement funds, two lawyers each using valuation and tax experts will, after months of haggling, present their positions to a Family Court judge.

In addition to the duplicative expense, since each expert probably will present an entirely different opinion of value, a disinterested judge will decide which expert to believe, and you lose control of your economic future.

Today, more and more certified public accountants can be engaged as mediators. As a professional, the CPA understands the roles of the attorneys. As a mediator, the accountant helps the lawyers prepare a plan that can accomplish a fair and equitable economic solution.

The mediation process might involve joint meetings and individual conferences as well as communication with each attorney. Where necessary, the mediator helps collect and collate the economic picture of the marriage generally at a lower cost.

One of the beauties of using a CPA as mediator is that, in a comparatively short period of time, the economic picture of the marriage will be put in place so that, should a settlement not be reached, the lawyers can take over and litigate all or a part of the case in a shorter period of time and at less cost. And since the mediation process is not binding until an agreement is signed, failed mediation results cannot be used in subsequent court proceedings.

Bottom line: If your matrimonial situation involves retirement, a family business or other economic issues that could take months or years to resolve in the court system or which can't be handled in the court setting (like concurrent estate planning, business succession issues, etc.) we believe that mediation through a certified public accountant has merit.

Again, this does not mean that each of you doesn't need a lawyer, but it does mean that you might be able to save some time and money.

Contact the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants or your state CPA organization for more details.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.