Chicago ? Donna Lucy strolled past a colorful display of Lands’ End sweaters just inside Sears’ main entrance and surveyed the other changes at a retail chain where she has shopped for years.

“It’s brighter, it’s more wide open, and they’ve got better-quality clothing,” the suburban Chicago resident said approvingly. “And they’ve finally got shopping carts to help you out.”

Sears, Roebuck and Co., the one-time star of American shopping malls turned dowdy, is taking the first wraps off a makeover of its U.S. department stores – in time for the holiday shopping season.

Initial reviews from retail analysts and customers, such as Lucy in the newly remodeled store in West Dundee, Ill., are positive. But whether the restructuring can help troubled Sears regain lost retail glory and market share is a question that won’t produce a neatly packaged answer by Christmas.

“Big retail organizations can’t be turned around in a year,” said George Whalin, president of Retail Managements Consultants in San Marcos, Calif. “They seem to be on the right track. But they’re probably in for a very tough holiday season, and I think they are going to struggle for a while.”

Company’s downfall

Struggles are nothing new for Sears. Since being dethroned by Wal-Mart as the nation’s leading retailer in 1991, the 116-year-old company has been buffeted by a series of competitive and financial threats and hasn’t been able to shake its image as stodgy and old-fashioned.

Discounters Kohl’s and Target have siphoned off shoppers from its 870 department stores, specialty retailers have eroded more sales, and shopping mall traffic has tailed off. A ’90s campaign focusing on Sears’ “softer side” fizzled, taking away business from its strengths in hardline goods such as tools and home appliances – a market it still dominates. Apparel sales have fallen for 22 straight months in comparison with the previous year’s total.

Most recently, after working for two years to iron out the weaknesses in apparel, CEO Alan Lacy this fall disclosed unexpected problems in the credit business. That unit, generating a $1.53 billion profit last year, has been so successful in recent years that Sears has been dubbed a credit-card company with stores.

Sears acknowledged failing to anticipate the extent of skyrocketing delinquencies and bankruptcy filings in a customer base it boldly expanded in mid-2000 by introducing its own gold MasterCard. The world’s No. 2 MasterCard issuer, with nearly 25 million such accounts, was forced to set aside an extra $222 million in the third quarter for uncollectible bills.

Coupled with the fragile economy, the credit woes further clouded Sears’ recovery efforts and slashed two-thirds of its stock’s value between early June and Nov. 13, when it dived to a 20-year low.

Brand name signs and holiday decorations greet customers to the newly remodeled Sears store in West Dundee, Ill. Once the queen of American shopping malls, Sears, Roebuck and Co. is in the early stages of a makeover to shake its stodgy, old-fashioned image. The makeover includes such things as providing shopping carts, centralized checkout stations, wider aisles and simplified signs.

Time for a makeover

Credit issues aside, the overhaul of stores appears to give the Hoffman Estates, Ill.-based chain its best chance in years for a comeback. Sears is cashing out its traditional department-store model to become more like a discount store, addressing customers’ quest for easier, faster shopping, while simultaneously upgrading its goods.

Only 50 of the more than 600 full-line stores to be remodeled have been made over so far. The revamp, which is costing Sears $800 million this year, won’t be completed until the end of 2004. But changes already are on display in all Sears’ stores.

For starters, Sears has cleared the racks of eight weak-selling apparel brands and removed cosmetics as the first department shoppers encounter as they enter.

Showcased instead, in 184 stores by year’s end, is upscale casual apparel from Lands’ End, which Sears bought in June for $1.9 billion. Nearby are clothes from Covington, its new private-label line of classic apparel, available in all stores.

“What we’re saying to customers by positioning them near the main doors is that Sears is in the apparel business in a big way,” spokeswoman Peggy Palter said on a tour of the redone store at Spring Hill Mall in West Dundee.

She predicted that in a few years, Covington will bring in as much revenue as DieHard batteries, one of Sears’ three longtime blockbuster brands along with Kenmore appliances and Craftsman tools.

Self-service is a key part of the revamp – nearly 6,000 store sales jobs have been eliminated in shoes and several other departments. Also scheduled for many or most stores: expanded home decor, Tool Territory departments with workbenches for testing out the wider variety of brands, Big and Tall men’s departments, new “plasma” departments to showcase flat-screen TVs, and closet shops featuring wooden hangers and clothes racks.

As striking as any new brand or product, however, are the wider aisles, open design, simplified signs and centralized checkout stations, a strategy employed successfully at other chains.

“It looks nicer,” said Frances Reynolds of Elgin, another veteran Sears shopper, who was picking out hosiery to load into her shopping cart. “It’s more inviting.”

Retail analyst Roz Bryant said the new format is not only an improvement, it may have kept Sears from following in the footsteps of Montgomery Ward – a similarly venerable Chicago retailer which went out of business last year.

“You used to find yourself (at Sears) wandering around for what side of the floor you should be on, then you waited in line too long,” said Bryant, of Chicago-based Morningstar Inc. “If the stores had been left the way they were, I don’t know Sears would have hung on.”

Sears operates a Lawrence store at 2727 Iowa, and it has been partially made over with the addition of shopping carts and changes to the cashier stations.