LJWorld.com weblogs Dangerous Ideas
Posted
by Paul Decelles
February 2, 2008 at 12:26 p.m.
Fossils and Faith
"Resurrected Life" is a quite interesting article but there are just some things about it that really bother me as a scientist and as a religious person. For instance, Mr. Detrich thinks that non believers have nothing to live for. Personally I don't believe it is in my ken to say whether or not someone else has anything to live for based on their beliefs. Granted I don't know what is going on in the depths of atheist Richard Dawkins' psyche, but he certainly seems to think his life has a point.Second of all I am bothered by this statement about nonbelievers:"They might just accidentally come to the conclusion that life would be better if they believed in a super being, in a creator, rather than life would be better if your actions didn't matter."This is a kinder gentler version of Pascal's wager which basically says you should believe because the reward is eternal bliss and the penalty eternal damnation. I have never been impressed by this wager in it's original form and I am even less impressed with Mr. Detrich's kinder gentler version. Also, does Mr. Detrich's kinder gentler version extend to devotees of, say, Krishna or for that matter any sort of belief in a supreme being?Next, I wonder why is the notion of God "creating" incompatible with scientific explanations of how life came to be and evolved? Mr. Detrich seems to at least accept the geological time scale. Well, if that scale is valid then why could not God's actions to bring change be seen from our end as being-well - evolution? Finally what am I to make of the concluding statement in the article where he says it is "better to be on the side of good than on the side of bad." Well what about that? Is some one automatically good because they believe in a higher power and some one automatically bad because they don't? Or is some one automatically bad because they believe that evolution happens? Does Mr. Detrich still think we are "evilutionists" as he writes in his "musings"?http://www.spearofjesus.com/musings.html
Marketplace
Arts & Entertainment · Bars · Theatres · Restaurants · Coffeehouses · Libraries · Antiques · Services
- On the street: How did you spend your Memorial Day? May 28, 2012 · 37 comments
- District Attorney Charles Branson to run for third term May 29, 2012 · 13 comments
- National group seeks repeal of 'Stand Your Ground' law in Kansas May 27, 2012 · 165 comments
- Information gap May 29, 2012 · 2 comments
- Experts: Remedial college classes need fixing May 28, 2012 · 19 comments
- Kansas tax act most regressive in nation May 27, 2012 · 275 comments
- Poll: Have you ever considered running for public office? May 29, 2012 · 1 comment
- U.S. military sees new appreciation May 28, 2012 · 46 comments
- Blog: Iranian Nuclear Energy: Will It Destroy Lives Or Save Them? May 29, 2012 · 4 comments
- Tax gamble May 26, 2012 · 94 comments
- Kansas tax act most regressive in nation May 27, 2012
- Thread of pain ran through Jackson’s career June 28, 2009
- Friends mourn Lynn Bretz, former voice of KU May 28, 2012
- Hilltop executive director Pat Pisani stepping down May 28, 2012
- Town Talk: UPDATE: Frank Male files for county commission; keep an ear open for local sales tax talk; city hires new city engineer; wholesale water district buys land near Kaw; weekly land transfers May 29, 2012
- How to help: Guides needed for Lamplight Tour of Black Jack Battlefield and Nature Park May 27, 2012
- Disciplinary action taken against Haskell employees after investigation of student-athlete test scores May 15, 2012
- Library kicks off reading program May 27, 2012
- Town Talk: UPDATE: Thellman files for re-election to county commission; News of salvage yards, curbside recycling and a pig May 25, 2012
- City, county mull upgrade to emergency radio system May 28, 2012
Comments
LJWorld.com doesn’t necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post. Read our full policy. Also, read about banned accounts and harassing comments.
justbegintowrite (Ronda Miller) says…
It seems in some respects that people who do not "believe" would enjoy their lives more. They are living in the here and now, and not concerned with eternal damnation.
I don't believe that you have to believe in order to be a good person, and, as we have learned many times over, a religious person isn't always morally right in their beliefs.
This is a good topic for debate.
kansascrone (Virginia Rigney) says…
exactly, ronda - i know many people who do not "believe," many of them coverts. they have experienced both sides of the coin and have chosen a life without religion.
in comparing them to those i know who are religious there are virtually no differences in them relative to purpose in life, personal integrity or any other way of contrasting the two groups as a whole.
justbegintowrite (Ronda Miller) says…
How come you said that better than I did kansascrone?
JJE007 (anonymous) says…
It also disturbs me that some see glory in reaching the top of their belief hierarchy. While that may go hand in hand with total selflessness and total selflessness may serve what so many perceive as "the greater good"...does it, really?
*Though I have it in spades* 2/2/2008
This world begs for an afterlife,
as death is so foreign to the living,
and selfishness runs so rampant.
And it is so much more cost effective to fold to Ceasar,
even betting our lives,
with eternal bliss is in the pot.
I will certainly go to the hell
of the loving master
if that is his wish,
for I am an ignorant fool
and; therefore, my damnation is deserved,
however eternal it may be.
I do wonder
about how eternal it should be
and how I'd deserve so much more time than my peers
but am hopeful
just the same
that ignorance is indeed...bliss.