Advertisement

Previous poll Next poll

KU has offered Turner Gill the head football coaching job. Would this be a good hire for the Jayhawks?

Response Percent Votes
Yes
 
69% 2999
No
 
30% 1299
Total 4298

Comments

jayhawks71 3 years, 2 months ago

"James Starks is an NFL caliber running back. "

James Starks is playing in the Superbowl and Naaman Roosevelt plays for the Buffalo Bills. Again, Gill won MAC games with NFL caliber players.

0

jayhawks71 4 years, 4 months ago

"Gill lost with MAC talent to MAC teams. ManJupiter lost with NFL-caliber talent (Reesing, Briscoe, Meier, Onyegbule) to the likes of K-State, Colorado, ..."

Drew Willy (QB) was just signed by the Indianapolis Colts. Jamey Richard (OG) plays for the Colts. Trevor Scott (DE) plays for the Raiders. James Starks is an NFL caliber running back. Naaman Roosevelt is an NFL caliber wide receiver. Gill lost with NFL caliber talent.

And before you get all giddy about how Gill can recruit NFL talent to play for him, of those named above, only Roosevelt was nabbed by Gill. Who are these great players that people have claimed that Gill recruited to play at lowly Buffalo? Granted, the man had a Herculean task to do so, but people are touting his successful recruiting to Buffalo. I ask who has he recruited to Buffalo? Not the guys I just mentioned. Perhaps he had amazing players there that went 5-7 this past year. But then won't he have "lost with NFL caliber talent" on his team?

Reesing ... NFL caliber? I think you're stretching a bit. But, I will play along. Weren't "NFL caliber" Reesing, Briscoe, and Meier the guys on the field that either threw interceptions or fumbled the ball away at critical moments this season? Don't get me wrong, these three have been wonderful players for KU--all players have bad games. They are responsible for a good deal of the success, but Mangino didn't throw 3 picks against the "shell" OU, Reesing did. Mangino didn't fumble the ball 2 times against Mizzou, Briscoe did... although, Mangino is oh-so responsible for the end of the game debacle. Mangino didn't fumble the ball at the Nebraska 4-yd line, Kerry Meier did. Yes, each of these guys has made wonderful and amazing plays in their time at KU, I don't deny that. And sure, the buck stops with the head coach when a team is unprepared/poorly prepared to play, manages time poorly, and makes poor play calls, but as for taking care of the ball on the field, that's on the players.

"...and an Oklahoma team that was a shell of its usual self." Sure they were a shell of their usual selves, but let's not attempt to characterize them as the Buffalo Bulls. This was a 7-5 team that beat the No. 12 BCS ranked Oklahoma State Cowboys 27-0. This was an OU team that lost 4 of those 5 games by a combined 12 points. This is an OU that lost 5 games only to teams in bowl games, one of which is playing for the national championship. And, let's not forget that Reesing threw 3 INTs that game, the first was on the very first play of the game.

0

Richard Payton 4 years, 4 months ago

Torbush and Long complete the new coaches resume. At Oklahoma Long won many games leading Oklahoma's offensive. Torbush was a powerfull defensive coach at Ole Miss. in the SEC. Also, did outstanding at North Carolina and one season at Alabama. Looks like many good days ahead for KU Football.

0

TLR 4 years, 4 months ago

Not a popular hire-why not wait and see?

0

gammimc 4 years, 4 months ago

And his daughter went to work in the athletic department a while back. Sorry fans, this whole thing stinks to high heaven. I wish him well, but I've seen excitement over a new coach turn into 4 seasons of 2-10, a firing, and the whole thing start over again.

Football is just a pastime 'til b-ball gets cranked up at Kansas.

0

bradh 4 years, 4 months ago

Gill sounds like a wonderful man and I hope Lew made the right choice. If Lew had the chance to hire coaches who had shown they could win like Harbaugh, Sumlin, Holtz, or Edsall and took a losing coach instead, he'd best hope this works out or he should be out the door (and I'm mostly a Perkins supporter) for a really poor hire.

Gill seems like Allen to me, without the wins before he came to KU. I just hope I'm wrong, but all I see is a coach who had losing records 75% of the time in the MAC replacing a winning coach in the Big 12. Looks like a major mistake to me.

0

Mister_Pink 4 years, 4 months ago

That is absolutely correct, Snoozy. Perkins set this deal up a long time ago. This is the worst coaching choice possible. And yes, Terry Allen days here we come!

0

snoozey 4 years, 4 months ago

I suspect this was a done deal before the Mangino witch hunt became public. Why not take the chance w Gill ?

0

yankeevet 4 years, 4 months ago

Lets go forward KU; new coach; new team.........hoorah!!!

0

squawkhawk 4 years, 4 months ago

Sounds like KU's version of the Ron Prince experiment. I'm on the fence on this one. If this does not work out it will be even more egg on KU's face.

0

riverdrifter 4 years, 4 months ago

Theres one word that sez it all and that one word is youneverknow.

0

philosodork 4 years, 4 months ago

rgh and jayhawks71: Gill lost with MAC talent to MAC teams. ManJupiter lost with NFL-caliber talent (Reesing, Briscoe, Meier, Onyegbule) to the likes of K-State, Colorado, and an Oklahoma team that was a shell of its usual self.

As far as his 20-30 record at a mid-major: He got twice as many wins in five seasons as the school had managed in its previous six seasons since moving up to Division 1-A (or whatever the NCAA's marketing people want to call it now). They went from 2-10 his first season to a conference title and bowl bid in his fourth (beating an undefeated team ranked #12 to get said title).

Credibility compared to Big-12 coaches? How about finalist for the Assistant Coach of the Year while at his alma mater--where, as QB coach, he helped produce an All-American (Frazier) and a Heisman winner (Crouch).

He'll do just fine in Lawrence, methinks.

0

ghays 4 years, 4 months ago

Nebraska--Gill's alma mater--didn't want him, but he is OK for KU! Way to go, Perkins.

0

jayhawks71 4 years, 4 months ago

"Wasn't Coach Mangino's record last year 5-7 too?"

Yes, and Mangino lost to teams like Texas, Oklahoma, Nebraska, and Missouri. I believe they are all going to bowl games and one of them is playing for the national championship. Another of them came 1 second away from beating Texas.

Gill lost to teams like Bowling Green, Temple, and Western Michigan... oh and Pitt!

0

derekbaker21 4 years, 4 months ago

Are you kidding? This guy has less credibility than ANY big 12 assistant coach. There is no reason to hire this guy whatsoever. They might as well just let the defensive coordinator run the program for a year and see how he does. If all you people want out of your football coach is a nice guy, have someone from the english department at KU run the football team. I want a football team that wins games in the big 12. If this hire is true, it looks as if we will be heading back to the days of Terry Allen and 3-9 seasons. Is it really that hard to think that a decent football coach with REAL credibility would want to come to KU? They have between $2.5 and $2.9 million dollars per year to pay, new facilities, talk of a new "Gridiron Club", and have won some legitimate bowl games in the last couple of years. Give me Tommy Tuberville, Skip Holtz, Kevin Sumlin, or Brent Venables any day. We need someone with a big name and REAL potential to lead this program and bring in big-time recruits. Turner Gill would do a great job, at Blue Valley Northwest or Tonganoxie High School, but he has no business going up against Bob Stoops, Mack Brown, or even Gary Pinkel.

0

anon1958 4 years, 4 months ago

Uncle Fester caused all that drama to hire a coach with a 20-30 record? Epic failure for Lou.

Good luck to the new coach and dont turn your back to your new boss.

The football team will be swimming in red ink regardless who the coach is, you can rely on that.

0

demonfury 4 years, 4 months ago

We'll let's see, Ms. Little, new Chancellor - black, Mr. Gill, new football coach - black, Mr Sayers, new Director of Athletics Fund Raising, and Special Projects - black.... Can we finally say that KU it all about recruiting all the liberal money it can get it's hands on by using minorities? If KU really wanted to get the job done, they should fire Lew Perkins, Bonnie Hendrickson, and Bill Self, and replace them all with blacks. As far as I'm concerned, I feel that KU is just as crooked as our President - also black. Mangino came in here for 8 years and amassed a more impressive bowl appearance / win percentage than any other coach in KU history, including Fambrough. He had the single best record in all of NCAA football 2 years ago, which includes the national champion and runner up. BCS bowl win, National Coach of the year, Big 12 Coach of the Year, and several dozen other awards to boot. Then a whinner - also black, complains of mistreatment and we throw the coach away like yesterday's garbage. Then replace him with a man with a losing record. What the hell is KU thinking? Just another step toward their own inevitable demise. I wonder how many of the 54,000 seats will be empty next September? I know mine will belong to someone else.

0

Randall Barnes 4 years, 4 months ago

COULD HAVE MADE A BETTER CHOICE. BUT OHH WELL.

0

rgh 4 years, 4 months ago

I hope for the sake of the University and the players that he does well, but I can't help but feel he can't handle coaching in the Big XII after having a 20-30 record as a mid-major coach.

I'm sure he was about 3rd or 4th on the list or they would have offered it to him much sooner. He does have some Texas ties which should help in recruiting but he needs to have a better staff than what he has at Buffalo. I would have taken a big time program's assistant who could bring in several big time assistants and recruiters from this area.

Hopefully Coach Gill will prove me wrong.

Rock Chalk Jayhawk and best of luck to Coach Gill and the players.

0

notigers4me 4 years, 4 months ago

I believe that if this is true and Turner Gill is coming to Kansas, we have made the best hire possible. I just get a real good feeling about Turner. One thing for sure he won't be found cussing out the meter person. I also bet that he will be able to find his parking spot on the first try and won't be trying to create one out by the dumpster. Turner Gill is a class guy who will do very well at Kansas.

0

justsmile2day 4 years, 4 months ago

Wasn't Coach Mangino's record last year 5-7 too?

0

gregsharp 4 years, 4 months ago

Makes them look good and I think he will do fine

0

Commenting has been disabled for this item.