Archive for Sunday, May 18, 2008
‘American Idol’ falls out of tune
May 18, 2008
Advertisement
“American Idol,” we need to talk. I just can’t pretend it’s working anymore. After seven years, it’s time to call it quits. I’m gonna slip out the back, Jack. Make a new plan, Stan. Take back the key, Lee, and get myself free.
In other words, “A.I.,” I want a D-I-V-O-R-C-E.
I know you ain’t too proud to beg, but don’t even ask for a trial separation. This is no seven-year itch. It will take more than a summer hiatus to heal after the worst season ever. I don’t know where we went wrong, but the feeling’s gone, and I just can’t get it back.
Don’t cry out loud. It’s nobody’s fault. Well, at least, it’s not MY fault. I showed up every week. I cheered, booed and, sometimes, tried to vote. Heck, I even cried during Season 3 (that Fantasia could really push my buttons). But it’s too late, baby. Something inside has died, and I can’t hide it and I just can’t fake it. Oh no, no, no, no, no.
In the first years of our relationship, you were so beautiful to me. Can’t you see? You were the perfect suitor for this wannabe superstar who spent her formative years singing to a hairbrush, a legend in my living room. I saw a part of me in every “American Idol” hopeful, even the dorky ones. Everybody plays the fool sometime. There’s no exception to the rule on a show that thrives on human exploitation.
But falling in love was such an easy thing ˚to do. Kelly Clarkson, Ruben Studdard and Clay Aiken were my first, my last, my everything. I laughed at all of Ryan Seacrest’s jokes. My love he didn’t need to coax. I even saw Simon Cowell in my dreams once. (But he wouldn’t stop insulting me, so it was more of a nightmare. He’s so vain, he probably thinks this column is about him.)
I told my “Idol”-deserting friends, if loving you was wrong, I didn’t wanna be right. They told me I’d better shop around — “Dancing with the Stars,” “America’s Got Talent,” “So You Think You Can Dance” — but I said, “Stop in the name of love!” If I can’t have you, I don’t want nobody baby!”
My husband pleaded, “Baby, baby, don’t get hooked on it.”
But I insisted, “Give me that remote, ’cause I don’t wanna miss a thing.”
Then you used me and abused me with Ryan’s sweet little lies (“This will be the best year ever!”), Paula Abdul’s cheatin’ heart (“Oh my God! I thought you sang twice!”), Randy Jackson’s double talkin’ jive (“Yo! Check it out. It was just all right for me, a little pitchy but you da bomb, dawg”) and Simon’s gratuitous cruel-to-be-kind routine (“You have invented a new kind of torture”).
I kept forgetting we weren’t in love anymore. So I kept on keepin’ on, through not one but TWO Beatles nights, Dolly Parton, Andrew Lloyd Webber and “inspiration” weeks. Might as well face it, I was addicted to love.
Yes, “Idol,” you’re a hard habit to break, but I’ve finally lost that lovin’ feeling. Sure, breaking up is hard to do but I will survive.
It’s you I’m worried about.
So, in the grand tradition of America’s Number One ratings grabber, I leave you with my swan song:
“American Idol,” stay away from me.
“American Idol,” Paula let me be.
Don’t come hangin’ around my door.
I don’t wanna see your show no more.
I got more important things to do
Than spend my time growin’ old with you.
Na na na na, na na na na, hey hey hey, good-bye.
Cathy Hamilton is editor of BoomerGirl.com and a 52-year-old empty-nester. Events recounted here may be embellished, exaggerated or completely made up because she can’t remember squat anymore.
Top ads RSS
- DISTRIBUTION CENTER TEAM LEADER Lawrence Journal-World is hiring for a ...
- HEAD MECHANIC OPENING The Jefferson County Road Department is taking ...
- Journal-World
- **Substitutes** needed for rural newspaper routes. *Early AM hrs. *Reliable ...
- Papa Murphy's Pizza is looking for part-time help. 15-25 hrs. ...
Marketplace
Arts & Entertainment · Bars · Theatres · Restaurants · Coffeehouses · Libraries · Antiques · Services
- Open to debate October 13, 2008 · 25 comments
- Protesters: Indigenous peoples, not Columbus, should be celebrated on holiday October 13, 2008 · 7 comments
- Obama headquarters reopens in Lawrence September 6, 2008 · 86 comments
- Why are intellectuals the enemy? October 12, 2008 · 78 comments
- Weblog: Freedom Of Speech, in Lawrence? October 13, 2008 · 80 comments
- Mexican marijuana cartels sully US forests, parks October 12, 2008 · 84 comments
- Weblog: John Lennon and Tina Turner in Concert: Just Imagine! October 9, 2008 · 35 comments
- Bad apples? They’re a part of motherhood October 13, 2008 · 22 comments
- On the street: How old do you think girls should be before they start wearing makeup? October 13, 2008 · 36 comments
- One person taken by helicopter to hospital after accident at Oread Inn construction site October 13, 2008 · 20 comments
- KU will meet Texas Tech at 11 a.m. on ESPN or ESPN2 October 13, 2008
- Keegan: The race to say yes to Kansas October 13, 2008
- Medicare hot line takes toll on nerves October 13, 2008
- One person taken by helicopter to hospital after accident at Oread Inn construction site October 13, 2008
- Sen. Pine resigns from drainage district board October 11, 2008
- Vanity plates show LUV4KU October 12, 2008
- Firebird boys upstage girls October 12, 2008
- $2,500 reward offered in cat mutilations case October 13, 2008
- Bill Self gets a job … October 13, 2008
- Why are intellectuals the enemy? October 12, 2008



18 May 2008 at 5:26 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
TopJayhawk (Anonymous) says…
This article is as ignorant as the show.
18 May 2008 at 8:56 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
gkwhdw (Anonymous) says…
Who cares if Cathy Hamilton is a 52 year old boomer? We don't need you to decide what we do and don't enjoy viewing at home. Buzz off, don't break down the door Stan, get away from house,mouse , get out of our hair,Claire! See how ignorant you sound Cathy? Let people enjoy the tube!
18 May 2008 at 9:24 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
Dorothy Hoyt-Reed (Dorothy Hoyt-Reed) says…
I do believe she has a right to voice her opinion, and she did it in a very funny creative way. Just because you're addicted to the show doesn't mean others are. And don't worry, she doesn't have the influence to get the show cancelled.
18 May 2008 at 10:48 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
mom_of_three (Anonymous) says…
I never understood the draw of “American Idol” and it's probably only been on in our house maybe twice in seven seasons. (people probably don't get why “medium” is one of my favs, either).
But I thought Cathy's article was hilarious and very creative.
The only igoranant words I read were used in the first two posts.
18 May 2008 at 1:44 p.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
shorttrees (Anonymous) says…
Sounds like the first couple posters just didn't get it. Probably too young and wouldn't know the songs she quoted if they heard them…
19 May 2008 at 8:27 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
capami (Anonymous) says…
You go Cathy! What a clever essay.
These season has disappointed me and I even went to the Idol Gives Back concert. Despite the constant selling of David VS David, I am happy AI gave America and the world a fresh and new talent from Texas by the name of Jason Castro. His performances of Daydream, I Don't Wanna Cry, Hallejuah and Somewhere OVer the Rainbow were show stoppers.
19 May 2008 at 8:43 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
yellowhouse (Anonymous) says…
I am just saying that its a great competition, it gives young talent an avenue to become stars, and its competitive edge is interesting. And you have to wonder which David will win. David Archeltto is definately the winner.
19 May 2008 at 9:17 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
Multidisciplinary (Anonymous) says…
After reading this, I can't believe she left out “Love will keep us together”.
This reminds me of a section in Pirates of the Carribean. Maybe it was the second one. Where they are out in the woods, and use some well, just plain bad slapstick. And then again, and we thought, on no!
But then, they just kept right at it for so long that it became insanely laugh out loud outrageous fun.
Sometimes a person really has to milk something to get the best laughs.
19 May 2008 at 9:38 a.m.
Suggest removal
Permalink
geniusmannumber1 (Anonymous) says…
u r old idol 4 eva lololololololololo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11!!!!!!1!1!!!!!!!!!!